Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis, IN

30 locations found near Indianapolis

“Working with Nadia is an absolute pleasure. Her customer service is exemplary, but what sets Nadia apart is her professional approach, expert knowledge, and her candid, yet thoughtful advice.”

5 Superb220 Reviews

“Cute little jewelry shop. Had them repair two older pieces and they really took care of me. They had them done so quickly that I had to wait until the following day to come collect them. The prices were better than reasonable. I’ve had one of the items replaced two other times and Windsor did better work for less money. Will absolutely be back for future repairs.”

5 Superb222 Reviews

“My absolute favorite jewelry store in Indy. Jamie is so knowledgeable and caring, and is always on the lookout for things she knows I would love. Amazing service and gorgeous pieces!!”

5 Superb182 Reviews

“Highly recommend Diamonds Direct Indianapolis! Make sure to speak with Kris, when you get there. Kris provided an amazing ring shopping experience and was very kind, helpful, and knowledgable. Overall, 5 star experience! Can't recommend this place and Kris enough!”

4.9 Superb270 Reviews

“If I could give a higher rating I would! Brendon went above and beyond the expectations you would have of an outstanding employee. Great attitude, knowledgeable, patient and very professional. I thought he was a manager because of his excellent customer service! If you stop by, ask for Brendon and you won’t be disappointed”

4.9 Superb254 Reviews

“They had an amazing assortment of crystals and rocks. Their herbal and tra section was awesome. And the individual working was kind and helpful. Great place to buy some witchy gifties.”

4.9 Superb213 Reviews

“I was just at gold and diamond,my experience there was excellent. I purchased a custom grill and I was very pleased with the outcome. It's beautiful it fits perfectly, and the quality of gold is simply beautiful. It looks great in my mouth. I would like to thank y'all for such excellent service. I recommend gold and diamond 💎 in Lafayette to any and every one out there. Great prices as well.”

4.9 Superb140 Reviews

“I love this little shop so much! There are so many cool clothes in this quaint little store. And, they’re super helpful if you need help choosing or with sizes.”

5 Superb86 Reviews

“It was amazing! She worked with my budget and was very understanding and helping provide me with multiple options to purchase jewelry I wanted. She was communicating with me and friendly. I was able to get multiple pieces of jewelry at a great price.”

4.8 Superb198 Reviews

“Very professional, great prices. If you’re in Indy and want jewelry, these are the guys to go to. One of the best stores i’ve been to!!
Dp is very helpfull ….”

4.8 Superb187 Reviews

“I came across this jeweler back when I was looking to repair a gold bracelet. They were very reasonable and did such a nice job that I decided to stop in when I was looking for a ring to celebrate my cancer remission. I couldn’t have found a more perfect ring for what I wanted—big enough for my middle finger and a little bit of sparkle. They gave me a fair price and let me use a bracelet I traded in for credit. Thank you for the beautiful memento!”

4.9 Superb94 Reviews

“They’re reasonable and determined to help you with any jewelry issues they located a hard to find watch band that I couldn’t find and was able to install it as well I will be an returning customer”

4.8 Superb172 Reviews

“We had such an amazing experience today at this location. We went shopping for my daughter’s 12th birthday and she loves Kendra Scott. We went to the color bar and every employee was so kind and courteous. They helped us pick jewelry, stones and also kept us updated on pricing for everything. Specifically, Maggie, was so incredible. My daughter picked two pieces at the color bar and had such a great time. Such a fun experience!”

4.8 Superb155 Reviews

“I walked into Master Jewelers as nervous as I could be… in my hand I had 2 VERY special rings. A solitaire from my grandmother and cluster set from her mom (my great grandmother). These 2 items were priceless. The moment I met Arlene I knew this was the place to trust with my treasures. She sat down with me and we designed a ring that used all the components of the 2 rings. She let me know up front it was a process and would likely take 6-8 weeks to complete. She sent me texts/videos of the process along the way. Yesterday my husband picked up the ring… I cried. It far exceeded my expectations. It is BEAUTIFUL. A big thank you to Arlene and Master Jewelers for making my family heirloom into a beautiful ring that I will pass along to my daughter someday.”

4.8 Superb146 Reviews

“Every single time I’ve gone here it’s been a 10/10 experience - the piercings are painless and the people are so sweet!! My last time I got my hidden helix and Kaitlyn was absolute perfection. Highly recommend.”

4.8 Superb128 Reviews

“Heather consistently demonstrates a high level of professionalism, a considerate approach, notably refraining from any high-pressure sales tactics. She as a high knowledge of watches, I anticipate engaging her services again in the future.”

4.8 Superb125 Reviews

“Everyone at this location is so sweet and helpful! Brittlee is especially very kind and she went above and beyond for me. I definitely recommend bringing any jewelry needs here!”

4.8 Superb116 Reviews

“They have a variety of different unique items and the lady was really nice and patient while I browsed around and found something to buy for my wife. I will be going back!”

4.9 Superb65 Reviews

“I actually found Steve through a recommendation on an Indianapolis Reddit page, of all places. We had some family diamonds we wanted to use for my wedding band and make a few changes to my engagement ring. I shared a couple of inspiration photos and he absolutely nailed it. He was super easy to communicate with, and the pricing was very transparent and fair. We’re honestly blown away by how everything turned out!”

5 Superb47 Reviews

“Highly recommend seeing Matt for any of your jewelry or wedding ring/band needs. Browsing or looking to buy, he made the experience very simplified and laid back and he's very down to earth, and made us feel welcomed and comfortable. Didn't try to push anything on you for a quick sale and is knowledgeable about all of the products, and explained the processes and costs very well.”

4.7 Superb247 Reviews

“I had a great experience at Gold Cobbler. I brought in two watches one needed a battery replacement and the other needed to be resized. They were able to take care of both and also provided helpful information about the second watch and what would be needed for any future servicing.”

4.8 Superb96 Reviews

“I love this place. The owner is so nice and helpful. Really unique items and I love the permanent jewelry🥰 They have a great selection for whatever occasion you might be shopping for and it’s wonderful to have a local business amongst the endless chain stores.”

4.8 Superb95 Reviews

“I've been a loyal customer of Martha's for over fifteen years, and I honestly wouldn't trust my watches or jewelry with anyone else.

What started as servicing my Rolex turned into a relationship I've relied on ever since. Over the years, I've purchased several watches from her, had her repair my diamond engagement ring, and brought her countless pieces that needed attention. Every single time, they come back looking better than new.

The thing that sets Martha apart is trust. When you're handing someone a treasured watch, a family heirloom, or an engagement ring, you need to know it's in good hands. Martha is knowledgeable, dependable, honest, and always fair with her pricing. In fact, I've yet to find anyone who can match the quality of her work for the price.

More than that, she treats her customers like family. After fifteen years, I consider her part of mine.

If you're looking for someone you can trust with your watches or jewelry, I can't recommend Martha highly enough.”

4.8 Superb84 Reviews

“I never miss a chance to visit when I’m in the area. I absolutely love this store! jewelry that lasts, adorable trinkets, and the funniest/relatable stickers for my junk journal :))”

4.7 Superb194 Reviews

“I visited The Jewelry Lady with my mother and sister for my sister’s birthday. The space is beautiful, bright and inviting. The staff were very friendly and knowledgeable. Joan went above and beyond, spending nearly two full hours with us to help my sister select pieces she loved for her birthday gifts. She didn’t do the uncomfortable press that many jewelry salespeople do where they steer you to the most expensive pieces. Instead, she asked excellent questions to determine my sister’s everyday style, her comfort level with jewelry types and occasions she would be wearing the pieces. She helped my sister try on each piece, made suggestions and listened carefully to the responses so she could make other recommendations. Joan was also very attentive to my mother and to me although we weren’t purchasing any jewelry that day. It was clear that Joan is interested in building organic client relationships, seeing everyone as a person first and then a customer. We were all very pleased with the experience, and would recommend The Jewelry Lady to anyone!”

4.9 Superb49 Reviews

“If you’re looking for an engagement ring please go here. Highly recommend excellent service, staff, and products! One of my friends told me about Khamis so I went in and really appreciated all the staff for their knowledge and care. They worked with me on the price and it was more than reasonable. Mary ordered my engagement ring and had it all ready in a couple days. Amazing people to work with, excellent communication, and the engagement ring is beautiful and just what we wanted. Thanks so much to everyone at Khamis for providing us the perfect ring”

4.9 Superb48 Reviews

“Dennis and Rhonda were such a delight to talk to and they really spent a long time with me educating me and going through the options. While ultimately we decided there was nothing they could do to address my concerns with my ring, I appreciate above all else their honesty and their integrity. I can tell without a doubt in my mind that they will not accept a job unless they are confident they can make it better. I will never hesitate to take my pieces to them from here on out!”

5 Superb22 Reviews

“This place is completely adorable first time here my husband took me there. They have so many different things from mugs to smelly goods to earrings and bracelets. Pleased with my purchase got my favorite color earrings, cute coffee mug and a Zodiac perfume set. Highly recommend and will return customer service was great! ??”

4.9 Superb25 Reviews

“The two gentlemen that that word there. July 23rd 2025 was amazing to work with. They quoted me 1 price 2. Replace 2 diamonds and my engagement ring. And when they got done, they discounted it quite a bit, which I was very shocked. And very appreciative, because neither one of them had to do that which impressed me, I looked at the rings, and I've decided there's a few that are 1 to purchase. Put it on top of that. My green, what's beautiful? He cleaned it and polished it on top of checking the diamonds in my set and replacing the 2 diamonds. Thank you. I would suggest this company to anybody”

4.7 Superb46 Reviews

“A beautiful business run by lovely people. I had my watch resized by Charlie while George gave a tour of the century-old business and building. Don't let the second floor location scare you off, it is worth your time to experience the craftsman ship and history imbued in Edward E. Petri Company. They are a true Indianapolis Gem and I cannot wait to go back to indulge in something a little fancier!”

5 Superb15 Reviews