Goodwill Store in Fishers is a small, clean, and well-organized location that offers fair prices on many items. The store features a wide selection of merchandise, including clothing, books, and holiday-themed items, although some items like books and certain clothes can be overpriced. The staff is very friendly and hardworking, maintaining the store’s good appearance and managing long lines efficiently by calling more people to the register when needed. Despite its size, shoppers can find some good deals, but pricing can vary significantly between locations, with some customers noting inconsistencies and higher prices on items like T-shirts and scrubs. The store has recently undergone a remodeling phase, which temporarily limited the available merchandise. Some reviews express concern over the store’s smaller size and higher prices, questioning the organization’s non-profit status and where extra income is going, given that items are donated and there are no house pickup services. Overall, the store provides a positive shopping experience with a helpful staff, reasonable prices on many items, and a clean, organized environment, though some customers wish for more consistent pricing and better value on certain products.
This is a really good Goodwill location that doesn't have overpriced goods.
November 2025
I found a most incredible item and at first, I didn't know how I would use it! I'm going to hang necklaces and bracelets on it. This item is a work of art! Amazing at $9.99!!
September 2025
Nice store typical items for thrift erst with friendly staff
