“I’ve both shopped and sold here. Both experiences were great. The prices are pretty good for the quality you get. I don’t feel any price gouging when I’m here. They are discerning about what they take, but I have no trouble finding cool items when I’m there. I usually look for unique hoodies when thrifting.
In terms of selling, the cash back is also good. I didn’t really know what to expect, but overall the amount received was worth it to me. I was able to drop off the clothes, run my other errands and pick up my offering.
I don’t know the staff members by name, but I just want to say the entire staff is attentive, organized, and polite. For a newer store, you all are doing great! I look forward to seeing you all soon!”
“Kind, caring VOLUNTEERS run this shop on Madison. Donations accepted on Wed and Friday only. They have a snack counter and all those proceeds help with their pantry across the street in the old Big Lots store.”
“I've been a few times, and like all thrift stores, some visits have been better (for me) than others. It's a great size - big enough to have a large selection, but it's not overwhelming. Merchandise is clean, well organized, and reasonably priced. The staff is very friendly. Highly recommend.”
“i had the most incredible experience at Newman ~ first not only did i save over $150 but i found exactly what i was looking for. Zachary’s service to others and hospitality is truly remarkable and will go down in history. ps the earth is flat and no one ever landed on the moon ~ Stanley Kubrick was a remarkable director …
however if you want a very rare NASA apollo 13 hat its only $11 ~ but its worth about $75”
“They had lots of Christmas stuff and the store was busy with happy shoppers. We found a couple of flower pots for our new baby Christmas Cactus ? They're going to look great together!”
“Great place to find kids clothes and toys at a lower cost. The staff is so nice and have helped me many times- both with finding things and selling things. I'm so grateful to be close to a location.”
“Really clean store, their men's selection was small but they stuff they had was really cool. I talked to one of the employees and he said they were always looking for more men's clothing. The staff was very friendly and I would recommend checking it out!”
“I found what will be my wedding dress here for $95 in beautiful condition! A wonderful shop with a nice variety of things, benefitting a great cause. Always worth a stop whenever I'm in town!”
“This goodwill was so clean and organized, I wasn't scared to pick up certain items. I know this is a ritzyer part of town compared to where I live and the Goodwill's that are in my area, but they didn't have opened used hygiene products (which they are not supposed to sell) none of their kitchen appliances had mold or food or mystery stuff in them they were all clean. And I found some great items. I find good stuff around my typical ones too but they have items that are in my opinion a serious health concern to even have in the store and they tend to be so packed full of bs items that you know no one is going to buy and that should have never been put out for sale let alone not put straight into the trash.”
“I was just wondering, enjoying a wonderful day and decided to stop at one of my favorite bargain stores. I found a couple of great deals. Staff were busy and friendly. And, I look forward to returning soon. ??”
“Great array of new furniture/closeouts and reconditioned appliances. They offer financing. Delivery is a little pricey, but convenient if you don't have a truck!”
“I stopped by Goodwill Store one afternoon just to browse, not really expecting much. After digging through a few racks, I actually found a couple cool items for cheap. That’s kind of the fun of it—you never know what you’ll come across. It’s simple, a little messy, but perfect if you enjoy the thrill of thrift hunting.”
“Scott thank you for being a kind human being. You are an asset to the Salvation Army, you smile and greet people and I even heard you say Hola to a Hispanic family to make her feel welcome. You deserve to be advanced to management because your other colleague lacks people skills- well I should say he discriminates as to who he will use his people skills with. He never greets me when I walk in the store, but then someone else will walk in and he acts as though he is the epitome of kindness. Scott is the only reason why I give 5 stars. As for the dude who seems like he is always PMSing when I come to that store I will find out who is above him and report him. Never assume because a person comes to Salvation and shop that they have to because I don't.”
10AM - 7PM
4129 W Washington St, Indianapolis
Thrift Stores
“I got a lounger, patron table with 6 chairs, 4 dining room chairs and a living room chair for $455. The patio furniture alone would have cost that much! Rented a U-Haul which was conveniently located a few blocks away from habitat for humanity. Guys loaded up the cargo van with all of my items and I was on my way! Couldn’t be more pleased with the items I bought.”
“Decent selection, but no fitting rooms. Returns are store credit, but you can use it at any network Goodwill in the area. This store is clean and relatively organized (for a thrift store).”
“I found a most incredible item and at first, I didn't know how I would use it! I'm going to hang necklaces and bracelets on it. This item is a work of art! Amazing at $9.99!!”
“I had questions and it seemed like only 1 person had all the answers and was busy. I ended up leaving without purchasing anything. Overall it was still a nice store and probably one of the cleanest locations. I will go back at another time.”
“Great selection of clothing and the staff was extremely accommodating and nice towards me and my family. Will be coming here over and over again. Thank you for the help today!”
“I would like to thank Clickgoodwill for being honest, I bought book named “ Marinas and small craft harbors” through Amazon, it’s supposed to be used book, and they “mentioned Pages may include limited notes, highlighting, or minor water damage but the text is readable.”Actually, the book which I received almost like a new, it was in perfect condition, I couldn’t find single defect.Really appreciate your honesty. All the best for you.Warm regards from Kuwait”
“My friend today in need if a dryer! Doing a little searching here or there on marketplace with little to no success on a dryer mainly over priced as to the reason! She decided maybe check in at goodwill and see if they have one! Blessings come I'm ways you can't imagine or when, reluctantly maybe to many dryers or no space! She managed to buy one at a low price you wouldn't believe! I am so grateful that Goodwill stores exist and how far they go to help someone in need! ??”
“Everyone in their mother's uncle's nephew's great grand-niece was there on a Sunday evening 'round 5pm. The place is huge. A lot of bins with clothes (mostly) but also some furniture and misc garage stuff. There were basically no dishes or kitchenware items. They charge $1.79/lb for stuff, unless an item is over 15 lbs then it might be priced differently.
I couldn't find very good quality clothes, but that may vary day-to-day. People in there move + dig FAST like they're racing to grab the good stuff... honestly just take your time and hope you find something good. I'd prefer to just go to a regular Goodwill.”
“I really haven't stopped into a goodwill since they took the tag cookie sales away, but decided to see what they had. I walked around for a min and even though I was shocked by the prices, I wasn't. I've read many reviews and watched YouTube videos on how Goodwill prices have escalated, and they truly have. This store wasn't busy and I ran into the usual overcrowding shelves, but with the prices they have on the merchandise........I can see why they was full and overcrowded! I was looking for a basic muffin pan and found one and surprisingly for it being almost brand new, it was only $2.99! And that is my kind of price! I don't know to be mad at goodwill for their prices, but they could at least bring back the sale tag for the week to give a customer a reason to go in their doors.”
“These 2 cashier girls, both with red hair, were very sweet and kind, after I forgot my receipt, I went back home to get it, and as soon as I came back, they instantly remembered me, one of their names is Lizzy, I hope they stay for a while”
“Brandy is an amazing manager at this location! I shop here frequently and ever since she’s been here I can see changes being made. I actually shop here more often nowThank you Brandy!”
“I had a pretty good experience at this Goodwill overall. They had a great selection of clothing, which is always a big plus when you’re browsing for deals or unique finds. I also noticed a large variety of kids’ books, which is awesome for families, along with a smaller section for movies and music.
One thing I really like about this location is that they almost always have some kind of cabinetry or furniture available in the back. It’s nice to be able to check for those bigger items since you never know what you might find.
The prices seem to reflect how costs have been going up lately, but they’re still reasonable for what you’re getting. Overall, a solid spot to thrift and worth checking out.”
“Another Goodwill headquarters over here on the West Mission Street do a great job with helping this able people to get back to work back into the workforce get their social life together and other services that they provide that you might find interesting if you want to apply for a job with the Goodwill of Central Indiana trust me if anything that you can do to help them do it donate clothes cars appliances or something like that then you can get all in good working condition that they can make a profit off of the help benefit of the individuals with disabilities.”
“Wow, this is definitely the best Goodwill I have ever been to! Not kidding. I have been to a "couple" all around Indiana and this one is by far the best for several reasons. 1. This gentleman who works there (Feb 20, 24) was going round to each isle and sorting and straightening items. It was so well organized! I told him too! 2. I got an important phone call from my doctor when I was getting ready to check out, I could do both. I asked the cashier if I could park my cart near the register and run outside to take call. She watched it for me the whole time I was outside! She was very nice and professional. I told her how much I appreciated her help. Thanks PAT!!! 3. The store was very clean and restrooms were very clean. I definitely give it 5 stars!”
“The couches and chairs are amazing. They're all good for different things. And I saw a really cool guy in a cowboy hat ?. And there was a cartoon pencil made out of Clay. BTW autocorrect won't let me do Clay without capital c. I don't care that the pencil has no graphite. This store is amazing.”
“Stopped in the "furniture" side while trying to find 5he "antique" side. I was impressed and mad that I didn't know about this place when I was looking for new furniture. I will recommend and keep it in mind in the future”