About Middletown - Goodwill Retail Store & Donation Center
The Middletown Goodwill Retail Store & Donation Center is generally described as a big, clean, and well-organized store with a good selection of merchandise. Reviews frequently note friendly and helpful staff. However, several customers feel prices have gone up and can be expensive. A specific concern is raised about the weekly colored tag sale, with a suspicion that sale items may be pulled from the floor, leaving none available. Some shoppers also note the presence of resellers. Overall, it is seen as a generally pleasant thrift store where people often find items to purchase. The location supports the local nonprofit mission of Goodwill Industries of Monocacy Valley.
One of my go to thrift stores lo e this one and monocacy
October 2025
The Middletown Goodwill tends to have a lot of really nice items (sometimes even brand new or name-brand) and is a good place to look for second-hand furniture. However, the prices are way too high for a thrift store! Goodwill gets their stock for free from donations!
April 2025
This is the nicest Goodwill I’ve ever been in! It smells very clean and is very organized. It’s a little on the pricey side, but definitely some more reasonable prices too. Will come back for sure!
