8AM - 10PM
805 East Main Street, Middletown
Thrift Stores
“What a great thrift store. I love that it combines my love for second hand/sustainability and supporting animal rescue, especially since they're currently supporting Perfectly Paired Pitties (P3), one of my favorite rescues to volunteer for.”
“Love this place! Saw a video on instagram & took a little road trip just to check this place out! It was well worth it! (I live an hour & a half away)
Spent about two hours there & got some amazing finds! The staff was super friendly & it was easy to see everything.”
“Purchased a recliner last week from their online store for my mother-in-law. Everyone was knowledgeable, professional and courteous. The recliner was as advertised and my mother-in-law is more than satisfied with the purchase. Thank you, Heritage!”
“Cute little store to pop into - interesting to browse in front part - the middle & back part were mostly clothes which I didn't look at. Seemed to be nicely priced items - not crazy expensive. Worth a stop in!”
“I noticed a lot of negative reviews, but as a buyer and not a seller, I didn't have any issues. I browsed for prob 10min and ended up buying only a sun dress, but if I'd had more time I prob would have gone home with more. I was a little disappointed in the selection or lack thereof with regards to shoes/boots in my size, but that's the nature of second hand stores--it changes all the time.”
“The Middletown Goodwill tends to have a lot of really nice items (sometimes even brand new or name-brand) and is a good place to look for second-hand furniture. However, the prices are way too high for a thrift store! Goodwill gets their stock for free from donations!”