Hotels in Edgartown, MA

“A Flawless Holiday and Weekend Escape!
We were searching for the quintessential Martha's Vineyard experience for our July 4th weekend, and the Edgartown Inn delivered well beyond our expectations. This beautifully modernized historical Captain’s house manages to honor its maritime roots while providing every contemporary comfort you could ask for in a boutique luxury stay.

The true heart of the Edgartown Inn is its incredible staff. A special note of gratitude goes to our host, Neusa, who went above and beyond to ensure every detail of our stay was seamless. She, along with a warm, attentive, and highly professional hospitality team hailing largely from Jamaica, provided a level of service that felt both deeply personal and effortlessly polished. They made the Inn feel less like a hotel and more like a welcoming coastal home.
The culinary rhythm of the day at the Inn is an absolute delight. Mornings begin with a beautiful spread of coffee, fresh muffins and croissants, offering the perfect light fuel before heading out to explore. Returning to the Inn in the afternoons was just as rewarding, as we were consistently greeted by the comforting aroma and taste of freshly baked cookies —a small but highly anticipated detail that perfectly captured the property's inviting charm.
They have the perfect Edgartown location - You simply cannot beat this location! Situated right in the core of Edgartown, the property allowed us to easily navigate the best of the area on foot. We were just a short, scenic stroll away from the iconic Lighthouse Beach (the inn supplies towels, chairs and umbrellas to use if needed), as well as the vibrant shopping and dining scene that defines the downtown area.
If you are looking for an impeccably managed, historically rich, and perfectly located basecamp for a Martha's Vineyard getaway, the Edgartown Inn is an absolute must.”

“One of the best resort we stayed, especially the activities you can do and free unlimited s’mores , free unlimited coffee, tea. Free tennis clinics, clambakes party, we really enjoyed the warm hospitality of the staff. It feels like we all went to a group vacation with people who stayed there. No isolation at all. Also the beach is so clean. We have stayed in almost every 5 star capcod resorts and this is the best experience till date. My kid also enjoyed.”

“We had a wonderful experience staying at the Christopher in Edgartown. Best location. Super friendly staff. Yummy breakfast! Thanks so much for your kind hospitality! Highly recommend!”

“Beautiful quiet hotel, with lush green landscape & fresh flowers, meticulously decorated room with comfortable beds, very professional & friendly staff from the front desk team Abby & Jackson to the kitchen staff who prepared & served tasty breakfast every morning.
They helped us leave Martha’s Vineyard with great memories.
P.s. if you are a Gilmore Girls fan, you definitely feel the vibe here:-)”

“great location and great price for our room. would stay here again for sure. just one thing is the rooms walls are thin and heard the person nextdoor to us at six am on the phone for literally three hours. otherwise the staff was great extremely friendly and fun!”

“The front desk staff and Megan at the pool were outstanding! The guy working in the “behind the view” bar was not polite and was very overwhelmed. Super slow service. They seemed understaffed in there . I recognize it’s not yet peak season, but it seems strange for such an expensive 5 star hotel to not have waitstaff out on the massive (and stunning) front porch. Everyone had to go get their own drinks and there was no food allowed out there. Room was spotless and bed super comfortable . Could hear every footstep above us, though so bring ear plugs. Super close to a very quaint downtown. We rode the bikes and they were great! The bellmen set them up for us, adjusted the seats, etc. Was sad that the lighthouse is covered and under construction. Really detracted from the beach either all the vehicles and work supplies. Overall, a great stay .”

“Where to begin - this was simply the best hotel experience we've ever had, from welcome to checkout. The staff was kind, thoughtful, and took time to genuinely get to know us. The hotel was spotless, the room beautiful, and the location puts you steps from Edgartown; breakfast was incredible, and the nightly homemade chocolate chip cookies were a perfect touch. We'll stay here every time we return to the Vineyard.”

“This hotel has the perfect vibe of comfort , class and cozy ! Perfect location, well appointed rooms and the staff is like family! wouldn't stay anywhere else”

“We had the most wonderful week at Faraway. We were in for our son's wedding during the Nor'Easter. As guests were rushed onto the island, they accommodated by changing our rooms and letting us stay late when needed. Every staff member knew what we were going through and did everything to make our stay as easy as possible. But even outside of storm, I loved sitting every morning in the lobby, drinking coffee that they provided and listening to the great music. The also had an open bottle of sparkling rose available in the lobby. The rooms were very comfortable, we stayed in a king in the main house, and we stayed in the most spacious three bedroom suite in the court house which had three bathrooms and was on two floors. It gave us plenty of space to spread out. They also had a pool and hot tub outdoors with an outdoor bar and their restaurant, the Newes is a fantastic 250 year old Irish pub with the best, lightest dill and lemon clam chowder on the island. The hotel was walking distance to all the shops and restaurants and they had free parking, which is hard to find in downtown Edgartown. I can't recommend this hotel enough. Such great people working there.”

“I had a wonderful stay at Edgar's Hotel in Edgartown. The rooms were very clean, which made my stay comfortable and enjoyable. The staff were amazing—always helpful and friendly, making me feel welcomed throughout my visit. I highly recommend this hotel to anyone looking for a great place to stay!”