Jewelry Stores near Nutley, NJ

30 locations found near Nutley

“Talented, friendly, and honest professionals who will absolute foster a good relationship with you if you want that!

I requested a custom-made ring here and they absolutely delivered.

Throughout the entire process, the owners were professional, smart, friendly, and helpful. They respected my wishes and requests, and weighed in with their insight which was enlightening. As the ring was being made, they walked me through the sourcing and crafting process gave regular updates, and did not at any point try to nickel and dime me, or try to force me into binding, multi-page contracts.

I also loved that there were regulars who I would see in the store that seemed to know the owners. They talked as if they were greeting friends, and it was clear to me that the owners had good relationships with these patrons who came in for things like smaller repairs and replacements.

Trio does it all: quality jewelry, custom-made pieces, engagement rings, wedding bands, or even more affordable gifts, watches, chains, plating or re-plating, and repairs. Can't recommend Trio Jewelers enough!”

4.8 Superb42 Reviews

“I love going here! Everyone is always so nice and knowledgeable. I especially appreciate Gabriel for answering all of our questions with no judgement. I can tell he’s very knowledgeable and efficient. My go to spot for jewelry and repairs. <3”

4.4 Superb67 Reviews

“Maria was great! She helped us pick the perfect engagement ring and was very helpful and friendly every step of the way. Loved working with her and so thankful we did!”

5 Superb307 Reviews

“Rick made a beutiful custom pendant necklace for me . Kept me informed all through the process . Craftsmanship was exceptional and customer service is second to none . Highly recommend !”

5 Superb240 Reviews

“I went in to sell some gold scrap and had a fantastic experience. Mike was incredibly honest and professional; right off the bat, he offered me an excellent payout without me even having to ask for a price first. It’s rare to find that kind of transparency. Highly recommend asking for Mike if you want a fair deal! Only place I’ll go in the future.”

5 Superb252 Reviews

“Michael restored my mother's watch and was so helpful in showing me how to maintain it, that I knew I wanted to work with him to create a custom piece of jewelry. Michael definitely understood my vision and created exactly what I wanted. The jewelry is beautifully made and given the work and materials, I felt it was very fairly priced. From a big project to a small one, I would absolutely trust Michael.”

5 Superb172 Reviews

“I wanted to create a very special piece I wouldn’t be able to find anywhere. Kerry and her team completely blew my expectations out of the water! The amount of detail they were able to achieve on such a delicate item has left me and the recipient speechless. Kerry is also very knowledgeable about the industry as a whole and was able to use that knowledge to bring to life my ambitious idea at an excellent price point”

5 Superb264 Reviews

“First time ever going here was greeted by 2 of the most amazing friendly and helpful staff sales people ana and nick .I was shopping for a specific wat ch and they found it for Me and with a great smile and awesome price .I highly suggest if anyone is in the market for any type of jewelry or watches please don't hesitate and come to Jared on rt 4 in Paramus and see ana and nick simply the best in every way you'll love there hospitality. Love ya Mr cody .”

5 Superb143 Reviews

“Went for an engagement ring and my sales rep was Jenny! Jenny was awesome in every way imaginable. Super friendly helpful. Made the whole experience very smooth and easy. Cannot recommend them enough. They help you through every step of the process provide all kinds of support and work with your budget as well. The final product will blow you away!!”

5 Superb226 Reviews

“Jordan worked with me to get the most beautiful earrings. They’re big and sparkly and sit perfectly flush against my ears. I can’t stop looking at myself in the mirror. They’re perfect!”

5 Superb131 Reviews

“They saved us in a last minute request! The best experience I’ve ever had with a jeweler. Thank you Jeffrey and your shop Angels Faviola and Ariel. We had a last minute need for wedding bands and they delivered in less than hr. My fiance and I suffered a family loss and decided last minute to continue with the wedding, except we didn’t have the wedding bands! I gave it a try and they helped us an hr before closing time. Thank you again Jeffrey, Ariel and Faviola for this and for your kind words and compassion.”

4.9 Superb293 Reviews

“WOW is an understatement. This place is amazing! There's a range of very high quality but affordable items. I can't wait to come back and buy some more stuff.”

4.9 Superb294 Reviews

“Always a good experience at W. Kodak. The staff is knowledgeable, sincere, and care deeply about the entire customer experience when shopping for watches, jewelry, etc.

Al helped me get sorted with a pre-loved timepiece that is no longer being manufactured and the process was quick and enjoyable. Kodak was able to acquire, authenticate, and take care of the process for me with incredible turnaround time. I would definitely recommend Al and all of the Kodak staff when in search of diamonds or that next hard-to-find watch and plan to do business with them in the future.”

5 Superb207 Reviews

“This experience was really good!!!Imani helped me choose the perfect ring my promise ring. Not only did she help me find a ring but even help me get a bigger diamond for a similar price. This is the best place!”

4.9 Superb278 Reviews

“I absolutely love Noellery! Every time I walk in, I’m met with kindness and genuine care. On my last visit, I mentioned I had recently gotten my ears pierced and was having trouble after one of my studs came out. The woman helping me went above and beyond—she guided me through choosing the right earring, gave me alcohol to clean my ear, and offered helpful advice to avoid further irritation. On top of that, she gifted me a cute little necklace to cheer me up and included extra earring backings just in case. It’s rare to find such thoughtful customer service. Highly recommend!”

5 Superb157 Reviews

“Thank you Abe and Patrick, for designing my wedding rings, they are gorgeous and fits perfectly on my chunky fingers. You gave me what I used to only dream of. The clarity and size is to perfection and Im ready to move on to my next piece. Heart and Gold is my forever one stop shop for my fine Jewels. ?❤️”

5 Superb119 Reviews

“Love this location!! I always come to Miriam (it’s been years)! Check her out and check them out for a wonderful jewelry experience. I actually refuse to change locations so I’m speaking based on my reality. ❤”

4.9 Superb206 Reviews

“Ms. Sakine and Ms. Likiana were very attentive and knowledgeable about the products. They have wonderful products, and I would definitely recommend them with pleasure.”

4.9 Superb155 Reviews

“Great customer service. I read the reviews and went to the shop to get one of my watches battery changed and get the other one fitted right on the wrist. The gentleman (owner) at the shop was so nice and showed me a few things on the watch for maintenance did the work on the watches right away. Highly recommend”

5 Superb93 Reviews

“Austin's Jewelry is the best, they gave me very professional and personal attention, all the staff are very nice, Austin repaired a special bracelet for me with my husband's ashes, I love it, thank you all so much, I will definitely be returning ❤️”

5 Superb91 Reviews

“My husband and I got our weddings bands and my engagement ring from Mazzo - and whenever we have needed a repair or anything from him he always delivers! Great guy and local business.”

5 Superb134 Reviews

“Great place, I'm not Indian but my best friend is and he's having a wedding. She help me find an outfit with an extremely great rate. Highly recommended”

5 Superb92 Reviews

“Nothing but the best of designers, personal service and value. Although I’ve moved, Fredrick’s is my favorite and only place to buy jewelry!!”

5 Superb146 Reviews

“I’ve been working with Alex at Yanina for a couple of years now, and I genuinely can’t say enough good things. Whether I’m buying something new, bringing in old pieces to redesign, or just getting a simple resizing job done, every single time the work is beautiful and the experience is delightful.

I feel so lucky I found them. Their collection is beyond stunning, and if you have something custom in mind, they’ll bring it to life better than you could have imagined. Alex is truly amazing!!

. . , But be warned: if you walk in, you’ll likely walk out a lot more sparkly! I always do!!”

5 Superb132 Reviews

“We had such a wonderful experience at KAY Jewelers thanks to Maggie! We came in simply to try on inspired rings for a potential engagement and to find out our ring sizes, and Maggie went above and beyond. She was incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and brought such great energy to the entire experience. She made us feel comfortable, never rushed us, and answered all of our questions with genuine enthusiasm. Overall, she was an exceptional sales associate and a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend asking for Maggie if you visit!”

4.9 Superb132 Reviews

“Great place to get jewellery.. Family owned business.. ..They make you feel like a family member. The personal touch they all give you is amazing.. .. I finally found a place I can trust with everything I want in a jewellery store.”

4.9 Superb142 Reviews

“Amazing jewelry and excellent customer service. The staff was friendly and helped me find exactly what I was looking for. High quality pieces and fair prices. Highly recommended!”

4.8 Superb313 Reviews

“I’ve been patronizing Mahtani for years to repair my watch collection as needed. Today I walked in and asked them to look at a pair of earrings my wife bought elsewhere for our son’s wedding. The clasp on one earring was not closing properly. They fixed it in less than 5 minutes. That’s why they’re my go to Jeweler! Check them out!”

5 Superb111 Reviews

“Noelle was extremely kind helpful and friendly. In addition to her jewelry expertise she also recommend lots of great spots to explore in the area!

The jeweler is gorgeous and the customer service was even better. We’ll be back very soon!!”

5 Superb128 Reviews

“Great service all around, staff was very friendly. I was running late trying to get there before they closed and they waited for me! A lot of transparency, fair pricing and I sold gold to them as well. Definitely my go to place moving forward. Thank you again!”

4.9 Superb144 Reviews