Butchers near Oakhurst, NJ

10 locations found near Oakhurst

“Fully stocked and whatever I needed that was not in the case, was brought from the cutting room when I asked for it. Good selection of prepared foods from shwarma to all kinds of side items like breaded veggies. Very busy as usual before Shabbat.”

3.5 Good15 Reviews

“Update below.
My husband recently bought beef short ribs from this place, they were horrible, 3 lbs for about 42.00, horribly fatty and tasteless.We bought the same item from the previous owners and they were perfect. Find another butcher. When places change ownership it usually is bad.
Update 9/6/2025, the owner refunded the money for the order, I would say this is exceptional customer service and I would definitely deal with them again.”

4.8 Superb161 Reviews

“Had the cheesesteak and it was full of flavor and was just great. Definitely one of the best in NJ and Philly. Will definitely be visiting regularly to get this particular sandwich”

4.7 Superb96 Reviews

“We stopped into Dutch Hill Farm Market and Meat Shoppe to pick up steaks for Father’s Day and left with so much more than just dinner—we found our new go-to butcher! We had the pleasure of meeting (who we believe was) the owner, who was incredibly warm, welcoming, and knowledgeable. He walked us through the different cuts and recommended the Wagyu New York strip and spinalis—both were absolutely next level. Everyone was raving. The meat was insanely tender—like butter! We also tried the teriyaki pineapple sausage, and it was divine. From the quality of the meat to the customer service, this place is top tier. Can’t wait to come back!”

4.9 Superb43 Reviews

“Excellent local place. Nice people. Amazing chickens and slaw and pies and the such. Cash only!! Call ahead to reserve is the way to go. Thank you to everyone there. Your food is delicious”

4.7 Superb113 Reviews

“I ordered some NY strip steaks & ground meat for the first time - our family really enjoyed them. Taste much better than the larger boxed “organic” food stores. Much fresher & tastier. Highly recommend”

4.4 Superb114 Reviews

“The butcher was running late so the owner took charge and cut for me the finest prime rib I have ever prepared and served at our Thanksgiving family dinner. Raves for a merchant who runs a great business.”

4.2 Good100 Reviews

“Very small but efficient basic meat market. They do have fish but an extremely limited selection and it's frozen. They do have good fresh meat at reasonable prices and special meat packages that are budget friendly. The meat is good. Service is very good.”

3.3 Good7 Reviews

“Best quality butcher shop, period. Hidden gem that rivals NYC steakhouse quality and beats the emerging on-trend restaurants/shops that trade on ambiance. A steak snob, I only buy steaks from Mr. Prime and come here for Bell & Evans chicken breasts that are way fresher than at your conventional amazonian grocer.”

3.8 Good26 Reviews

“Always a great time when we go, but this time was above and beyond. Marc was absolutely amazing. He made us feel like a million bucks. The apps were delicious but the entrees were out of this world. The preparation on the meat was simple yet was better than anything we have had before. Just when we thought it couldn’t get any better Marc convinced us to try the churro bowl and oh my goodness do not skip the churro bowl. 11/10 and big shoutout to Marc”

4.2 Good651 Reviews