Jewelry Stores near Old Tappan, NJ

30 locations found near Old Tappan
View Map

“Lori and everyone at Massoyan Jewelers are incredible! They helped me every step of the way with designing my dream ring. I couldn’t be happier with it. If you’re looking for jewelry, this is the spot!”

4.9 Superb55 Reviews

“I recently had the opportunity to sell some gold coins, and the experience couldn't have been better. From the moment I walked through their door, I was met with warmth and professionalism. They took the time to thoroughly assess my coins and provided an excellent competitive offer.But what truly stood out to me was their commitment to transparency and integrity. I felt confident throughout the entire process, knowing that I was dealing with a business that holds itself to the highest ethical standards.In a world where it's often challenging to find a business you can trust, I am grateful to have discovered this hidden gem. If you're looking for a reliable place to buy or sell coins, or if you have any jewelry needs, I wholeheartedly recommend this family-run business. They've certainly earned my trust and respect.”

5 Superb151 Reviews

“Had the greatest experience at Mamari Jewelers! Special thanks to Rami, who went above and beyond to find the exact watch I was looking for to give my now husband as a wedding present. Amazing family owned business so happy to have found them!”

5 Superb140 Reviews

“Eddie and his brother were so great to work with! They treated me like family taking the time to talk through what I was looking for my engagement ring. I liked their old school way of working with clients. Highly recommend them to anyone looking for jewelry!”

5 Superb122 Reviews

“They are the best I have taken my ring to have it fixed. Great job cannot tell it had been damaged… they do great quality work I wish I could take a picture of the ring.. I have bought jewelry from them twice I love the price they do the layaway I love it ? I love the layaway plans”

5 Superb116 Reviews

“After going in and getting my ears pierced, I sat and talked to Mike for awhile. We discussed about me getting engaged soon and different kind of diamonds he could get. He told me when I was ready to just give him a call. I called him a few months later and he had a variety of diamonds for me to choose from. He was so easy to talk to and he made this whole experience a breeze. We designed my band and he nailed it, I honestly couldn’t be more happy with Mike and the service he provided. I would highly recommend this place. Thanks again Mike!”

5 Superb79 Reviews

“Silverman Jewelers is my absolute favorite jewelry store whether I’m looking for a special gift, a casual piece or just looking! They are always friendly and helpful but not “pushy.” Their inventory is exceptional!!”

4.9 Superb119 Reviews

“Abe is an extremely nice guy, stopped in to get new batteries in my watches and tighten the clasp on my necklace. He was extremely nice, and quick. He did it all free of charge. Abe’s a great guy, I will definitely be back, and he will be my go-to for anything jeweler related!”

5 Superb62 Reviews

“My fiancé and I have both been coming to Danson Jewelers for years because the service alongside the excellent pricing is unmatched. While my fiancé enjoys her various necklaces, rings and bracelets, I decided to see if Jack could help me find an engagement ring. Needless to say, Jack jumped on the task and actually came back to me in a shorter time frame than expected with a ring that perfectly fit my budget.I know when either of us are in the market for a new piece, this will always be the first and only place we are stopping!”

4.9 Superb74 Reviews

“Can't recommend this place enough! Steve helped me with my engagement ring and super helpful throughout the entire process. I went into the store with little to no knowledge about diamonds and rings and Steve was able to help me feel comfortable with what I was purchasing. Steve was honest and flexible with any request I had. Will be returning to the store for all future jewelry needs.”

4.9 Superb70 Reviews

“I recently approached the good people at Bergio in Closter about the possibility of designing a custom necklace of 22K gold meant for a dear someone with unusual medical sensitivities. Over the course of several visits they patiently helped me envision the perfect solution to this romantic challenge, sourced the gold and then executed the gift perfectly, I could not be more grateful for the way they invested themselves personally in this deeply meaningful endeavor.”

5 Superb44 Reviews

“Lindsay helped us a few months ago and we didn’t buy. But she left such an amazing impression that we had to come back. The service can’t be beat. The quality of rings/jewelry is truly some of the best. We are collectors and had a hard time picking because of the amazing selection. Lindsay was here again and not only did she remember us, but she remembered what we were looking at before. She knew our style and we never felt pressured. It’s rare to find a combination of amazing service, amazing jewelry and amazing prices. When you go here ask for Lindsay and she will take amazing care of you.”

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

“I went in to have a watch looked at. Joe took the time out to look at it and solved my issue. That’s professionalism. I highly recommend Pangea to everyone that needs a good jeweler”

5 Superb42 Reviews

“Skydell Designs redid my original engagement ring and made it into the most amazing piece of jewelry I own . It looks like a completely new piece that is modern and stunning ! Looking forward to wearing it for many years to come. Thanks so much Jordan!”

4.9 Superb57 Reviews

“Edward did a great job walking me through picking a diamond for an engagement ring. He also made a custom ring that matched exactly what I was looking for. Would highly recommend him to anyone!”

4.9 Superb56 Reviews

“Nash, Joanne, Luisa, and Roshelle were incredible! The most amazing service I’ve ever experienced! I got to the Jeweler and they opened the store up last minute to help me out, definitely went above and beyond 10/10!”

4.9 Superb56 Reviews

“Sandy is wonderful to work with! She helped my daughter find earrings that were beautiful and great quality. They never take them off! She has a great eye and understanding of what her customers are looking for. I can’t recommend Sandy enough for all of your jewelry needs!”

5 Superb35 Reviews

“Jim repaired my wedding band this month. I was thinking I should redo the whole ring. Jim assured me he would restore it to its original state. He delivered! And for a very fair price. Highly recommend Plaza Jewlerers.”

4.9 Superb48 Reviews

“Honest, reputable, jewelers since 1993. Definitely a great experience at G Anthony Jewelers. They sell and buy jewelry as well as repair, resize, clean, polish and battery changes.”

4.9 Superb46 Reviews

“My husband and I have been dealing with Rich & family for decades. If you're looking for quality appraisals, jewelry to buy and/or honest and fair offers for items to sell, go see Rich. You will be so glad you did!! ?”

4.9 Superb44 Reviews

“They did a one of a kind piece a couple of months ago and it was outstanding. Words couldn't describe how beautiful it is . Now they are making another one .Thank you”

4.8 Superb66 Reviews

“Read the reviews and decided to come in for a jewelry repair. Reviews are very correct. Louis is very nice and doesnt try and break your bank. Reasonable prices and does a fabulous job. Thank you Louis”

4.8 Superb64 Reviews

“Where do we start! From the moment we walked into George’s store we immediately felt at home and comfortable with him. He answered all our questions, helped me figure out exactly what type of wedding band to get my husband, and worked with him to make a beautiful wedding gift necklace. He’s also cleaned my engagement ring and made it brand new right before our wedding. George is super knowledgeable, trustworthy, reliable and kind. We are so grateful we walked into his store and could not recommend him and his business more, we are lifelong customers! You rock George!!!!”

4.8 Superb63 Reviews

“I would highly recommend Frederick Jewelers for any jewelry purchases or repairs. I was so impressed with their honesty - they were really helpful in telling me what looked good on me and what didn't. I got a beautiful ring at an amazing price and I couldn't be happier!”

4.9 Superb39 Reviews

“Mr. Jason,He was a very professional and his advise knowledge on the store. I cam in with a idea and he shoe me what a really was looking for that is excellent customer service. Apreciate his knowledge and customer service at the store.Thank you.Charlie Gutierrez”

4.7 Superb115 Reviews

“An easy and positive experience getting rid of some unused jewelry that was collecting dust. Was also able to sell a silver bar that a family member gave to us as a gift. We came on a Sunday and were able to make an appointment quickly. Employees were friendly and professional.”

4.8 Superb57 Reviews

“excellence beyond belief! right when i'd given up all hope that genuine customer service was extinct, i discover this oasis! thank you for a Perfect Experience!”

4.8 Superb56 Reviews

“They exceeded my expectations. Not only did they resize my ring in just 10 minutes, but they also cleaned it, leaving it looking shiny and brand new right before my eyes. The staff was friendly and upfront, making the whole process enjoyable. I'll definitely be back for our wedding band. Highly recommend for quality service!”

4.9 Superb36 Reviews

“My wife & I have been going to Somos Jewelry store for a number of years. Marie is patient, respectful and never pushy. She knows her product and never hesitates to make appropriate recommendations and show us a number of choices. We deal with Somos jewelry almost exclusively for our jewelry needs.”

5 Superb27 Reviews

“I haven't bought anything from this store but they have serviced my watches and made some alterations to a very high end costume jewelry items and were very professional, thorough and timely and reasonable in their fees. It's why I go back to them.”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews