Thrift Stores near Wayne, NJ

20 locations found near Wayne

“This thrift store was absolutely AMAZING! The volunteers are so sweet, it feels as though you walked into a family gathering and were instantly brought into the family. The prices are such a bargain, and so many great vintage and new pieces alike! So well organized. Would recommend coming here again and again!”

4.8 Superb13 Reviews

“Great experience in donating furniture due to the pick-up driver, Barry! He was professional, helpful, and very kind. The online process of arranging the donation date for pick-up was also very easy. Definitely recommend!”

3.9 Good89 Reviews

“Best furniture store in America!!!! They have the coolest secondhand stuff, will ALWAYS work with you on prices, and genuinely are some of friendliest kindest people you could work with! E.J. was the best and so was everyone I spoke with!!!! I WALKED OUT OF THERE with a FANTASTIC FOLDING $100+ TABLE that they makrsd down for only $30!!! And boy what awesome groovy furtnitrue they have for all price points. Even a custom made Ralph Lauren piece for $5,500 that ysed to be $10k+. And for people like me- expect to find many cool pieces from the mid 19th century, to a big 1968 TV, to the mid 2020s! Yep, this place has got it all and the kindest people to boot. Much appreciated to the whole gang, E.J. Carlos and everyone else who was in today- you all made it a great store! Thank you for honoring Jimmy Carter's memory with this friendly and kindhearted charity store with truly GROOVY STUFF! Cant wait to come back”

4.6 Superb68 Reviews

“It might look small from the outside, but it’s a sizable treasure trove inside. Hard to find the entrance - you’ll have to go to the back.

The owners are very friendly and always there. You’ll find an eclectic mix of advertising signs and displays, old typewriters, antique books, period clothing and just fun things from the past.

Prices are very democratic and they credit cards as well”

4.9 Superb80 Reviews

“Love this place and the Staff too! I love to come here and browse like my mother used to do in the stores of Brooklyn, NY. You never know what new treasure(s) you'll stumble upon and walk out with. And believe me it's never a sudden impulse buy or a pressure purchase.
You will go home items that pull at your heart strings because they remind you of someone who was/is special in your life. I'm a man, so guess what caught my eye? Almost an exact duplicate double boiler my mom use to use when I was a kid. She would use it to reheat items in the top with boiling water on the bottom. That was our equivalent to microwaves today. The main thing I remember though was she would cook franks in the bottom and heat up the Campbell's pork and beans on the top. What a great meal that was!
The point is, go to Willing Hearts and find things current and things from years ago. Even if you don't buy something this time, it is fun to see all the things around the store. This store deserves 5 stars.”

4.3 Superb62 Reviews

“PROS: Very nice thrift store I just found the other day on Yelp. People that work there are very nice and there is great variety. The place is clean and organized with a lot of parking CONS: some of the stuff tends to be overpriced. The board games being notorious for that OVERALL: I definitely will come back here when I'm in the area. It's a nice thrift store non the less. I would just stay away from the board games”

4 Good90 Reviews

“I fell in love with this place I can’t still believe I found myself one of my favorite shoes brand Nikes the classic that I was looking for everywhere and I couldn’t find and I came here I found them, can’t wait to come back soon!❤️”

3.6 Good132 Reviews

“Visited this store with my son on 12/6/25 for the first time. My son loves thrift stores. He seems to always find stuff. I was surprised to see how busy it was with customers the line to pay wrapped around the store. Store has two level and if you are patient you can get some good deals. If I visit again I would go not on a weekend but early during the week, ? the staff was very friendly, upon entering a young lady at the register greeted me. Happy I had a nice experience and I was out with my son. Check them out.”

3.5 Good158 Reviews

“I donate and buy too. Clothing is arranged by color and type. I like the selection of home good especially for the lkitchen. I always find beautiful salad bowls and baking traits. It is in great condition and has reasonable prices.”

3.5 Good153 Reviews

“I love this store. Everyone of the volunteers is great. I go there and spend hours just talking to them and looking through their amazing donations. I always find great quality and a great price. Thank you to every one of the volunteers.Michelle and Tomasz.”

4.6 Superb39 Reviews

“I love this store! I keep coming here to buy my son clothes. All of their items look new or gently used. And their prices are great! Also, everyone that works here is super nice. I highly recommend coming here :)”

3.4 Good149 Reviews

“Tremendous Prices Are Good And The Person Can Always Save Something. You Have To Make Time, Don't Be In A Hurry Good Offers And If You Always Save Some Money. God Bless All The Employees And Their Manager. Amen ???!!”

3.4 Good124 Reviews

“PROS: this place was very nice. Historically a train station that was renovated into a shop. The staff was nice, prices were amazing, variety of items plentiful, everything was organized, and the items were good quality. There was even loads of parking CONS: the place wasn't all that big which caused congestion inside. OVERALL: I will definitely come back here as this is an amazing place to go thrifting”

4.3 Superb24 Reviews

“A gem of a thrift store! You can find some truly unique and quality pieces here. Clothing is separated by style and size. Tons of shoes throughout the store, including AllBirds, Converse, Vans and more. There are dedicated clearance sections with extra 50% off discounts and a very cool vintage corner towards the back of the store. They have a good selection of plus-sizes as well. Excellent selection, well-organized and pleasant employees. Loved my shopping experience here and will be visiting again regularly!”

4 Good50 Reviews

“Best consignment with the best people in the area from furniture, accessories jewelry to current on trend clothing a fabulous place to see in a fabulous area. The owner is tremendous and will meet your every need as well as the staff go there and enjoy.”

4 Good26 Reviews

“I have no idea why I didn't review this shop earlier. Today is my third time and every time I have walked out with some awesome vintage stuff. Today I picked up a reversible caped coat with leopard print on one side and orange on the other $50. No label but this is a coat that put a smile on my face. It's a statement coat but I'll wear it all winter. A lovely gown for my nephew's wedding for $15, a very large hand crocheted blanket and a lovingly washed quilt to go over it - each for $20. A copper bar server for $10 and a vintage clothesline pin holder in a fun and funky mix of salvaged cloth absolutely made my day. Top it all off with with the nicest people running it. This is one of the best church thrifts on the East Coast.”

5 Superb24 Reviews

“Love this store, especially now with extended hours. Huge variety of items all the time. Quality is nice too but as with any thrift shop you must check that the item has all the parts, that it works-there are plenty of outlets to check electric items. Staff are pleasant and keep stocking items all day. My only complaint is their sound system which is all static and very annoying to listen to. It would be better if they just turned off the music.”

2.8 Average160 Reviews

“Amazingly large area located in an old factory the entrance is in the loading back area Parking's tight Prices are good but Wednesday's three tags great Got my winter wardrobe there Wednesday staff very helpful Try it u will like it”

2.4 Poor28 Reviews

“First time here ! I found a lamp I saw on a moving sale for $10 cheaper than the sale. I def had to get it . It had a lamp shade I didn’t want so the employee let me change it to one I wanted . Some cds were just empty cases . Idk why they would have that for sale . A lot of the prices were expensive for cups . It was an okay store”

2.5 Average117 Reviews

“I like shopping at this well organized thrift store. It's pretty pricey but I have found some great items at 25 and 50 percent off. There is always so much to choose from. Well stocked with clothing.”

2.1 Poor152 Reviews