Butchers near Amityville, NY

20 locations found near Amityville
View Map

“All around a great place. Very welcoming and always excellent experience. The quality of the meats they provide is unlike any other deli, the coldcuts are super fresh, and the sandwiches are delicious. Defiantly recommend for anyone who has not been here yet.”

4.2 Good10 Reviews

“Prime Time Butcher's products, service and professionalism are over the top. I truly do not like to slice brisket, how thrilled I was to find out they will do it, after I cook it. As it was being sliced, I got suggestions on how to reheat it so it is perfect for my family. They have a new customer for life”

5 Superb65 Reviews

“I have never been to a butcher shop and this is the first time I have ever been to one. I met Joe the owner and he was fantastic. He explained exactly what meats I should get and how I should cook them and at what temperature. He explained everything in a manner that I could understand. Not only that he gave me a few stuffed mushrooms for my first time purchase. The customer service is absolutely amazing here. Every time that I need to purchase meat I will not go anywhere but here. Thankyou so much for your amazing service.”

4.6 Superb27 Reviews

“Always fresh, delicious, and ample amounts of kiełbasa, cold cuts and pickles. Can't get enough of this place. Scott behind the counter is the best. Wouldn't go anywhere else for my meat.”

4.7 Superb14 Reviews

“Wound up finding this business on Google because they carry A5 waygu cuts. I wound up calling in and speaking to a nice gentleman who answered my questions. Wound up driving 30 miles the next day to pickup a waygu strip and prime aged and the owner and his son were super friendly. They thanked me for my business and taking the drive out to them as well. They understand how to treat people and offer great steaks!!!”

4.7 Superb14 Reviews

“My wife ordered the Valentine’s Day Special from Tony’s MeatMarket.She knew this would be a great gift since we both enjoy the prepared chicken cutlets and fresh meats.The food was the best of the best and for a fair price. We would be hard pressed to get the quality of food at any restaurant.Caesar salad with homemade croutons,Lobster Bisque (quart)Jumbo shrimp cocktail (side of small lobster tails)2 Filet Mignon (my wife added slices of Tony’s bacon)4 twice backed potato’sCream spinach (cheesy and delish)Grilled jumbo asparagus2 glass cups of tiramisu (or other choices)$140 we had 2 Meals out of it.The filet was the best part but everything was amazing!Tony’s is our goto for prepared food to heat and eat at home and for the tenderist of steaks. It’s worth it every time.”

4.9 Superb10 Reviews

“My 1st time at the store & restaurant. Both are clean & tidy & Halal. Halal meat is always fresh, they cannot sell meat from a sick animal as they carry the burden of sins. Great customer service. The food is delicious, not spicy hot. I had ginger chicken & okra.The butcher cut the meat as I asked. This will be my go to butcher & takeout once I'm at the butcher. Give it a try.”

4.3 Superb31 Reviews

“Family owned and operated! Always giving great deals, very friendly, always willing to go the extra mile! Wether cooking for a family, a BBQ, or any special holiday, they are my go to butcher!”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“The roast beef here is amazing! Hands down the best and freshest roast beef sandwich I've ever had! Super nice and friendly staff too!They lost 2 stars because when I ordered rice pudding I found the rice was crunchy and undercooked but the taste was delicious. They gained a star back because when I let them know about it they apologized profusely and gave me my money back even though I didn't ask for it and I wasn't expecting it. I just wanted to let them know so they were aware and they could cook it throughly whenever the next batch was made.”

4.4 Superb13 Reviews

“Omfg. Bring your wallet. Tell them too cut the large sandwich three ways. Incredible sandwich, awesome store. Got the amazing pesto pasta salad and fillet mignon tips both also 10/10”

4 Good52 Reviews

“Fantastic food! We ordered a grandma pie, chicken parm, and eggplant parmesan heroes, and everything was delicious, our new no-cook order out Friday spot for sure.”

4.3 Superb10 Reviews

“Smelled great, the minute I walked in. I passed so many times and never made it in. Picked up some of their homemade pasta and homemade ricotta and some ricotta Salata. Awesome”

3.9 Good25 Reviews

“Best butcher in town. Everyone is helpful and friendly. Followed butcher's advice for cooking and roast was perfect. Butcher cut back bone before tying prime rib, which made carving a breeze.”

4 Good7 Reviews

“Pam S Love this store The people who work there are all helpful. Always find what I need and usually do a full food shop there One day as I was leaving and in parking lot a container of blueberries in my cart opened up and fell, and one of the employees saw it happen he ran over to me and said "stay right here I will get you another one. No worries" always shop there and will continue being a customer”

3.7 Good49 Reviews

“This place is a family favorite! Not only do they have good quality meat and friendly staff, they also have musical instruments for kids to play. My (toddler) son always looks forward to going to the butcher to with the electric guitar and get a balloon.”

3.5 Good8 Reviews

“Abundance of fresh produce, veggies, fruits...Best Baked on premises Italian bread ? ???I dont live in the area..but visiting family & I've fallen in love with their warm fresh baked Italian bread..and 3 for $5..?”

3.5 Good51 Reviews

“First time visit to select items as a "corporate gift". Very helpful staff. The recipients were very pleased. Item packaging was also very convenient. PS - I do not eat red meat.”

2.3 Poor4 Reviews

“I've always been obsessed with Uncle Giuseppe's!!! That loaded Potato Salad is the bee's knees!! Homemade Meatballs!! Which I'm constantly placing in the air-fryer!! I always tell everyone when picking up a package. pop-em in. Convenience!!EVERYTHING in the PASTA BAR!! Let's be honest with ourselves. Carbs are LIFE. I'm pretty much okay with mass consumption of carbs!! PASTA CARBS!It's 2024 so who says you can't eat like a QUEEN for NOTHING!!!Uncle G's, I peep you in the Newsday circular!! Jan 5th to Jan 11th!! YAY for 2024 SAVINGS!!INFINITE LOVE AND BLESSINGS!!! Time to save B-ig!You're a REAL G, Uncle!✨✨✨”

3 Average28 Reviews

“I had nice and pleasant experience every time I visited this store.Staff very much cooperative and the store was always clean.I recommend this place for everyone.”

2.2 Poor8 Reviews

“The staff and atmosphere was inviting and helpful. It was my first time to shop there. I could not find what I wanted in the 3 previous stores in which I searched. The staff here was most helpful and I found what I had been looking for. I will certainly return.!!!”

2.3 Poor20 Reviews