Grocery Stores in Bay Shore, NY

11 locations found near Bay Shore

“I had an excellent experience at Dairy City Supermarket! The customer service was top-notch—everyone was so friendly and helpful. I was in and out quickly, thanks to their fast checkout process. I also grabbed a sandwich while I was there, their buffalo chicken sandwich was absolutely delicious—definitely a 10/10. I'll definitely be coming back.”

4.5 Superb68 Reviews

“Looking for Dominican food? This spot has a vast majority of food. Although it's a hole in the wall within a supermarket their food and service is great! Those hole in the walls can be hit or miss this is definitely a HIT!!!”

4.1 Good104 Reviews

“Great service and great food . Speaks English and Spanish. They also accept apple pay. They have many options of food and they cater too. I love buying rice from them. 10/10 Another plus they always have ready avocados.”

4.2 Good66 Reviews

“Love the owner, she's so warm and welcoming. Her prices are the same as the African markets in Queens or the Bronx except I don't have pay gas and tolls since I live on Long Island. She has an array of clothing and anything she doesn't have she's willing to order for you.”

4.8 Superb17 Reviews

“I enjoy shopping at Aldi's the most important thing is that it's affordable and produce is definitely worth it. Shopping for a weekly order or every two.”

4 Good176 Reviews

“I can’t understand why anyone would say this store is overpriced, maybe they want it free everything in this shop is cheaper than all supermarket nearby and far. We use to drive to Queens to buy our Jamaican stuff and it is more expensive there , so we started shopping at this store instead.It’s not a big place but you can get a lot of Caribbean items there . The owner is a very nice person and his family..”

4.4 Superb29 Reviews

“This is a great place to find authentic Latin food. They are slowly fixing up the place but not ideally nice yet. The food makes it worth it though. The one big con is all the drunk guys around the facility.”

4.3 Superb29 Reviews

“Found everything I needed quickly and easily.
Produce was fresh and deli man Lyric was was fast, accurate and pleasant. Young lady at the self checkout was helpful and friendly. In and out in 7 minutes what more could you ask for?”

3.7 Good156 Reviews

“Alex is the greatest cashier I’ve ever had in my whole 83 years of living. I didn’t know how to leave a review but I googled because their service was just so stupendous. I have never been treated with such kindness and respect from someone of this generation. I just had to share this experience, I will be returning.”

3.7 Good71 Reviews

“You can download the application and order online.
This is my favorite store. It’s organized, clean and the costumer’s service is very nice.
I bought some items, today May 20/2025.”

3.4 Good186 Reviews

“A great place where you will find all Indian spices and groceries. Good basmati rice e.g Tilda . Amazing Nirvana brown sugar a couple to name. Also some Indian sweets. And veggies like onions, cilantro and tomatoes. And all these at very good prices. Flour like Sujata.Also freshly butchered chicken & mutton. Friendly staff and courteous service. We’re a regular it’s been more than 2 years. And shall continue to visit .Do recommend ??”

3.1 Average40 Reviews

Related Categories

Related topics