Grocery Stores in Bay Shore, NY

13 locations found near Bay Shore

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 1819 5th Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.3 Superb 113 reviews

    “I have lived in Brentwood and Bay Shore for many years and for me Gala Supermarket is one of the best in the area. Their Dominican food is the best, it feels like being back in the DR. Always fresh and with authentic flavor. The owners are very kind and helpful, and the cashiers are excellent - super friendly and fast. If you want to feel at home, this is the place. Highly recommended! ???”

  2. 1617 5th Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.3 Superb 88 reviews

    “So we walked in to a totally unexpected restaurant disguised as a grocery store. An endless array, of delicious Latin food, pork, steak, chicken, macaroni & potato salad along with all different types of soups, to choose from, the hardest part was picking what to eat. So we decided on the rice and beans accompanied by a steak and some yuca with chichón. Well worth the trip up east. Big portions, come hungry leave satisfied.”

  3. 42 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.3 Superb 77 reviews

    “Family oriented and very clean environment with friendly service and employees. My kids love sandwiches from deli. They are all good people and they have wonderful employees and food. Excellent store.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 1750 5th Avenue Ste 5, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.6 Superb 34 reviews

    “They have items you won't see in a Supermarket Or in a deli I really enjoy Buying From here they have Spices And Snacks and Essentials from Africa and the Caribbean there's no other store on long Island unlike this one trust me the African Caribbean market is a crown Jewel of long island NY”

  6. 1750 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.8 Superb 23 reviews

    “Love the owner, she's so warm and welcoming. Her prices are the same as the African markets in Queens or the Bronx except I don't have pay gas and tolls since I live on Long Island. She has an array of clothing and anything she doesn't have she's willing to order for you.”

  7. 834 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4 Good 90 reviews

    “My husband swears the cold cuts are better here than where else. It is a board head deli. Employees cut them just like you ask. Store is clean and organized. They have good weekly sales which is good because it is a pricey supermarket”

  8. 1789 5th Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.1 Good 32 reviews

    “This is a great place to find authentic Latin food. They are slowly fixing up the place but not ideally nice yet. The food makes it worth it though. The one big con is all the drunk guys around the facility.”

  9. 1851 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

    3.9 Good 185 reviews

    “My experience was ok. There were only 2 cashiers and the lines were very long. Finally another cashier came on to help get the lines and customers out. The prices have increased, like everywhere else, but Aldi is still the cheapest store to shop at.”

  10. 1535 Brentwood Road, Bay Shore NY 11706

    3.6 Good 45 reviews

    “Me and my fiance get their fresh naan, frozen naan and the samosa from there twice a week . Best Pakistani little establishment . We love the staff too , very friendly and polite . I appreciate you guys”

  11. 533 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

    3.7 Good 187 reviews

    “I brought some chicken breasts over to the meat department. The gentleman that work there are very nice & accommodating. I was able to get the breasts sliced thinly. I go to Stop & Shop in West Islip quite often. I always have a good experience. The people that work there are very devoted. I feel special when I shop there because they seem to make the shoppers priority! They definitely treat and assist shoppers, like myself. THANK YOU FOR A GREAT EXPERIENCE YESTERDAY!!!”

  12. 1819 5th Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706

    1 Poor 3 reviews

  13. 1905 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

    3.4 Good 216 reviews

    “You can download the application and order online. This is my favorite store. It’s organized, clean and the costumer’s service is very nice. I bought some items, today May 20/2025.”

  14. 838 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore NY 11706

    2.6 Average 43 reviews

    “I took a ride to Target to purchase Açaí super fruit packs. I bought the last one in the frozen food section. A young man (didn't get his name) was super helpful and looked up Açaí...told me aisle G19. So thank you for the fantastic customer service. As for Danielle, cashier 7. She needs to have training on her customer service skills. Too busy looking at her cell phone. Claims she wasn't opened then opened 1 minute later. Another bouffon who clearly doesn't enjoy her job.”

Advertisement

Grocery Stores in nearby cities

Related topics

  • Aldi, Walmart, Lidl and Sam's Club Introduce 2026 Thanksgiving Deals

    Thanksgiving dinner is getting cheaper this year as major retailers compete to offer families the most affordable holiday feast. Discount grocers and big-box stores are launching deals that feed 10 people for as little as $36. This marks a significant drop from last year's prices as companies respond to ongoing concerns about grocery inflation.

    Read the post
  • Kroger to Open 110 New Stores by 2029, Unveils 3 New Store Formats

    The Cincinnati-based supermarket giant will open about 110 new stores in fast-growing markets by 2029 and introduce three updated store formats, executives told investors Oct. 20 at the company’s Investor Update in New York. Kroger already runs about 2,700 stores in 35 states. The formats come in three sizes, a bit like small, medium and large, matched to each market. Mary Ellen Adcock, Kroger’s executive vice president and chief merchant and marketing officer, walked through the lineup.

    Read the post
  • Walmart Survey: 70% of Shoppers Say Lower Prices Would Ease the Holidays

    Walmart shoppers want a head start on the holidays, and money explains a lot of it. Some 44% of respondents call affording the holidays their top stressor, and 61% say holiday costs shape their shopping mood. Asked what would make the season easier, 70% picked lower prices and 57% picked more deals and promotions. Convenience ranks lower: 30% want one-stop shopping across categories, and 20% want faster delivery.

    Read the post
  • Walmart Expands 30-Minute Delivery to 33 Markets

    Walmart wants your groceries at the door before the ice cream softens. On May 29, the retailer said its 30-minute-or-less delivery had reached 33 U.S. markets, adding a wave of new cities across the Northeast. Shoppers in those areas can order from more than 100,000 items, everything from fresh produce and baby formula to pet food, electronics, cold medicine, and prescriptions. Behind the scenes, the service leans on Walmart's store network and an algorithm that factors in order size, available drivers, and distance from the store.

    Read the post
  • Trader Joe's Plans 25 New Stores Across the Country

    Trader Joe's keeps adding stores, and shoppers keep showing up. The California grocer has marked nine more locations as "opening soon," pushing its expansion into new corners of the country. The grocer also took first place in the American Customer Satisfaction Index's 2026 supermarket rankings. It has held a spot near the top of that list for years.

    Read the post