Gift Shops in Buffalo, NY

18 locations found near Buffalo

“Thin Ice is the kind of place that makes a man slow his step, even when the road is calling. Shelves stacked with the work of local artists, small objects that seem to hum with their own quiet stories. The staff is great, straightforward and friendly, the kind of people who make a place feel right. I’ve been back more times than I can count, and I’ll go back again.”

5 Superb75 Reviews

“As a vendor selling there is very easy and as a customer the food is good and I find something new to buy all the time! It is also very cool that they hold events with the Pixie Mama’s and rescue dogs.”

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

“The first time I visited at Christmas, when my daughter told me about the store and told me I could pretty much buy anything they had for her. I loved the variety of whimsical goods! I visited again today, knowing I would find Buffalo themed magnets and clothing for my daughter’s friend, but I did not expect the shopkeepers to be so kind and helpful! Regardless, this store is great , and I will be back… Easter basket items next!”

5 Superb46 Reviews

“They have Beautiful Irish gifts there something for everyone! Had a great conversation with the gentleman that worked there. Definitely recommend going in to look around. Will be back!”

4.9 Superb65 Reviews

“Love this place! Very unique and well made crafts and textiles and other neat items. Got some beautiful pieces from the shop on a cold day, warmly welcomed and no pressure atmosphere.”

5 Superb35 Reviews

“Incredible selection of one of a kind quality gifts you will not anywhere else except at Neo’s
Best personal customer service.
Always feel welcomed”

4.9 Superb25 Reviews

“Wonderfully friendly service. A nice selection of South Buffalo wares and souvenirs . Fair prices and tasty, complimentary coffee . A relaxed, enjoyable experience.”

4.9 Superb16 Reviews

“Very cute gift shop. Great place to buy gifts or souvineers. They have lots of Buffalo and Buffalo Bills themed merchandise, clothing, witty napkins, scented candles, purses, and even oils/vinegars from Saratoga. The owner also has a very sweet dog named Milo.”

4.9 Superb11 Reviews

“I went to bon fire last Christmas to have a bracelet made for my wife, she absolutely loved it. I went back to shop for a Christmas gift this year the owner REMEMBERED ME. I just thought that was awesome. Great place to shop. With the owner's help and some descriptions of my wife's style another unique beautiful gift was purchased.”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“I love it in here! It's so cute and they have a great selection from boozy accessories, baby stuff, and women's clothing. Everyone is so friendly and they do a great job at keeping their products current and changing with the seasons!”

4.5 Superb29 Reviews

“I came here this afternoon Feb 16th from across the border with my children.
My daughter shovelled driveways for hours in our neighbourhood to make enough money to buy a Hatsune figurine. With the American exchange it’s quite a bit more for us, but they’re so hard to find around here.

We were greeted by Ember when we walked in. Ember was so sweet and she helped with a sign up discount during our purchase. My daughter was ecstatic she had money left over from her shovelling money after Ember applied the discount.
We have never been to this store before but it’s so super cool in general.
And with staff having the positive aura Ember was giving off and her amazing personality , we would 100% cross the border to come back and shop here again.
Thanks for the wonderful experience !”

4.4 Superb86 Reviews

“Fantastic store! They have top quality products, many very creative items & very good prices. That Karina lady is so helpful & such an adorable sweetheart.”

4.4 Superb54 Reviews

“Cone Five Pottery has an excellent selection of high-quality handmade pieces—a perfect spot to treat yourself or find a truly special gift. Greg, the owner, was incredibly helpful and patient in guiding me to the perfect choice. This gallery is a true gem in Buffalo!”

4.1 Good26 Reviews

“A true hidden gem and the ultimate all-in-one gift shop! (kinda overpriced tho!) Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, Christmas, Halloween, retirements, or any special occasion, this place has it all. They carry so many trendy and beloved brands - from Jellycat, Stanley, and Owala to Yankee Candle, Hello Kitty, Marin, Palm Pals, NFL, Kendra Scott, Little Words Project, and more! You’ll also find the most unique and niche items you won’t see anywhere else.

Beyond gifts, they’ve got everything from stationery, apparel, and beauty finds to kitchen goods, snacks, fidget toys, blind boxes, board games, kids gifts, men’s gifts, books, and candles. Every corner feels like a new discovery. Definitely worth a visit - you’ll leave with something perfect (and probably a few things for yourself too)!”

4.1 Good58 Reviews

“This is a great local shop with helpful and friendly staff. I saw a cap on their website, forgot to screenshot it, then went in and vaguely described it. The person I asked for help was able to find it for me right away. I think they also have very fair prices, and a great selection of things you can't find anywhere else.”

3.9 Good42 Reviews

“A wide range of Buffalos sports teams gear, with a distinct flair for the cities sports culture. Located in the Walden Galleria it is easily accessible from a wide range of the cities outlying suburbs and most major freeways.”

4 Good35 Reviews

“In 2018 I got a giant golden retriever plush for under $70. It made my mom so happy when she was in a nursing home for rehab. Every visitor had to pet him, it spooked the night at first because he looked real, and even brought joy to her roommate. To some people this is just a store that didn't sell everything they wanted. To me it is the place where I got something that made my mom happy for a couple weeks about two months before she died.”

2.7 Average15 Reviews