Unique Toy Shop, established in 1983, is a charming and diverse toy store located on downtown Main Street in Canandaigua. The shop offers a wide range of toys, from novelty and classic to unusual and collectible, ensuring there is something for everyone. Visitors appreciate the well-stocked selection, which includes toys for all ages, small inexpensive items, and special collectibles like gemstones, marbles, and bouncey balls. The store features a lovely outside window display and Adirondack chairs under the covered entry, adding a welcoming touch. Customers praise the friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable staff who go out of their way to assist, whether finding the perfect gift or offering suggestions for specific needs. Many mention the excellent customer service, including helping with gift selections for children of different ages and special needs. Although some items are priced higher, the quality and uniqueness of the toys justify the cost. Overall, the Unique Toy Shop provides a fun, friendly, and helpful shopping experience, making it a favorite destination for families and gift seekers alike.
Omgosh!!! What a wonderful toy store!!! Both staff members were more than accommodating and paid attention to detail!!! They even wrapped my purchases at no charge! DEFINITELY A REPEAT CUSTOMER!!!
December 2025
I absolutely love this toy shop! They have a unique selection indeed of toys, games, arts and crafts, and stuffies for all ages. I find their prices to be very reasonable and you get the benefit of supporting a local business over a large corporation. Win-win!
July 2025
Great old style toy store. They had lots of stuff. But some of the prices were crazy. Don't try to buy anything out of the front window. That's the stuff that's priced too high.
