Pet Stores near Central Islip, NY

28 locations found near Central Islip

“Jacqueline and Staff were awesome hosting the Dog Adoption Event Sun 02/23/25 for Carol's Senior Pet Sanctuary and the kind sharing of their store brought both of us a lot of new fans... 06/29/25 ANOTHER awesome Visit Shopping & collecting Donations!”

4.6 Superb171 Reviews

“Maximum K9 changed our puppy from a fearful, reactive, defiant dog to a confident, well-mannered, GOOD BOY with the Board & Train program. Katie and the team have been fantastic and are still helping us after Drogo has been home. Special shoutout not only to Katie, but Kayla and Will also. Drogo loves and misses all of you!
Drogo is an 8-month Cane Corso puppy. When I arrived at the store to drop him off for training, Drogo was lunging and growling at every person who entered. It was dangerous and not to mention embarrassing. I’ve had to leave other dog-friendly places because of the same awful behavior. What a mess we were.
When I returned to Maximum K9 for a demo after 2 weeks, Katie and Kayla trained me with Drogo and then took us into the same store, this time more bustling and crowded than at drop-off. Drogo and I were able to walk around calmly, he was not reactive at all, and I was able to put him into a down position and he stayed. It was like I was seeing a DIFFERENT DOG! Wow!
I could go on and on with examples and stories and I honestly can’t say enough great things, but the bottom line is that this was one of the best decisions we’ve made and we had an amazing experience. Drogo is a GOOD BOY and he was loved and well cared for by all of the staff. I am now confident and proud to walk with Drogo. I highly recommend Maximum K9 and we will be returning for ongoing classes. Thank you for teaching us and for loving Drogo. We will see you again soon!”

5 Superb353 Reviews

“What a great store! Love going in there to buy my grand pups treats and toys! Healthy food choices, unique gifts and lots more… do yourself a favor… Go check out Barkfield Road. The staff is amazing too. Big shout out to Caitlyn.”

5 Superb104 Reviews

“We have been there a couple of times since getting our new German Shepard puppy. We live the large selection of healthy foods and the knowledge of their staff. I see no reason to go anywhere else.”

4.9 Superb115 Reviews

“Love this place! They have great quality products and my dog loves every single employee here. The girls here are so kind and extremely helpful always. This place is my go to for sure. Speaking honestly, some products can be a bit pricey but for the main products I come for (like their bulk chicken patties) well worth it! And they do offer a veterans discount for all my vets out there ❤️ I highly recommend this place ??”

4.8 Superb67 Reviews

“I had never even heard of Central Park Puppies when I began searching for my Cavapoo. The site came up when I did a Google search. I never knew anyone who used them, had no referrals, and no background. All I know is that from the second I contacted Central Park Puppies, I was provided feedback, pictures, videos, etc. I dealt with Ash and she was a pleasure- her responses were quick, she had all the details I wanted, and even reached out to the breeder for additional videos of our pup. I would HIGHLY recommend Central Park Puppies! My husband and I kind of jumped into our purchase, but every step of the way was simple, straightforward, and pleasurable. It has been a little over a month that we have had our pup and I still keep in touch with Ash. She loves getting updates for all the pups she places in homes, which shows how much she cares about these puppies. Five stars and highly recommended for sure!!!!! ❤️ Thank you Central Park Puppies ❤️”

4.7 Superb159 Reviews

“This place was like Wonka Factory for pets! Not only was it so well stocked, but the grooming session my new Shihtzu puppy had with Taylor was spectacular! She was so kind, caring, and very patient with a new first timer puppy and Miley left looking like a beauty!! I will definitely be back and thank you!! ??”

4.7 Superb155 Reviews

“I can honestly say I have been blown away from the customer service I have received here. After Months of trying to find a pet store or a shelter. They can provide me with some guidance as a first time reptile mom . repxotica was the only place willing to help. A big thank you to Ana and Rick for reassuring everything l need and providing with more information you guys are the best !!”

4.7 Superb128 Reviews

“This is the best store in NY state if not the US. I have gone to many stores and Tropical Island aquarium has it all. From rare and exotic fish to the highest end coral. For beginners it is where you must go to start off in the hobby. The reason why I say it’s the best because they have the most competitive prices for the nicest coral and exotic fish beats the highly marketed online sellers and the staff is very knowledgeable and friendly.”

4.7 Superb78 Reviews

“I go to pet supplies plus Smithtown at least once a week to get my dog food, treats and crickets. It’s always a comfortable and happy environment. The staff is always kind and ready to help if needed. There’s one specific employee, Nick, that I really have to mention, because he really just puts a smile on my face every time I’m there. If I’m not smiling when I walk in the store.. I’m definitely
Smiling when I leave. He is always SO kind and his energy is unmatched! So, thank you Nick, and thank you PSP for being the best pet store in town!<3”

4.5 Superb135 Reviews

“Maria is amazing!! She is gentle and patient, and my dog looks so handsome!! Most importantly, She listens to you when you tell her what you want done. 5 stars across the board!!”

4.8 Superb70 Reviews

“Love, ❤️ love this place. Awesome customer service. Always in stock on most items. Grooming service, very caring groomers that do a great job. Visit this store at least every other week. Only pet store I shop in now.”

4.4 Superb188 Reviews

“Amazing groomers and pricing! I’ve been to many groomers and they are amazing here, my older girl has had trouble in the past she is not a fan of getting groomed and she loved it here and gave them no issues keeping her grooms low stress as she’s getting older is so important and they make that happen! Definitely continuing to use them! ?”

4.7 Superb40 Reviews

“Lidl in New York is like a little piece of Europe! The store has a great selection of delicious products, many of which remind me of favorite European items. There's always something interesting and unique to find, and the prices are fantastic for New York. The products are fresh and high-quality, and the atmosphere feels like the cozy stores in Europe. I'm very pleased and will definitely be coming back!”

4.3 Superb82 Reviews

“I brought my 7 month old mini golden doodle to Doggie Dons for grooming. When we arrived we were invited into the back while Don finished shaving another dog. My puppy was nervous and shaking at first but calmed down after a few minutes. When it was her turn she was calm and relaxed. They did a great job and when I picked her up a few hours later I was very pleased with her appearance. I will definitely be back in the future.”

4.7 Superb61 Reviews

“First time in after living in East islip my whole life. Cute little store with everything you need, owner is so welcoming and friendly. Will be coming here from now on to support small business”

5 Superb11 Reviews

“I’ve been a customer with Farmingville Feed for approximately 6 months. I use them to get my mini-dachshund groomed every few months. I have always been comfortable with each grooming session, and have always been pleased with how my pup looks. Laurie is friendly, attentive, and always handles my dog with care. Laurie’s grooming is always done efficiently, and my pup looks adorable and smells amazing every time! Overall, I would highly recommend Farmingville Feed to anyone in need of a professional pet grooming service that is reliable and top-notch!”

4.7 Superb57 Reviews

“Super friendly & helpful staff. They were all awesome at interacting with my 2-month old puppy and they spent a lot of time showing me around the store helping me to find supplies and food for little Mushwell. Really appreciated the way they interacted with my pup and helped me out. Great place.”

4.2 Good162 Reviews

“I adopted Molly from Long Island Feline Adoption Center in January 2023 and Im glad i did and its been nothing but joy and love ever since. Molly is my first cat and I definitely was a bit nervous as I only had dogs previously and I knew the breeds were definitely different. As soon as I arrived at Feline Adoption Center Cheryll took her time to get to know me and my living situation and what I was looking for and matched me with Molly. I came in on a Monday and visited every day that week and went home with Molly that Saturday. Molly is such a sweet, beautiful and well behaved cat. Im so lucky to have her and Im so thankful to Cheryll for matching us Molly is what was missing from my life. Molly is so comfortable in her new home and its only been 5 months and I know that love and joy is only going to continue to grow as I hope she lives a long & happy life. Thank you so much to Cheryll and Long Island Feline Adoption Center!!! You are the BEST!!”

5 Superb27 Reviews

“Planned to bring my 3 cats for flea baths while the exterminator was bombing out our home. The guy working was really knowledgeable and told me he couldn’t see any on them. I had used Advantage on them 3 weeks prior and didn’t know it would have been too soon for a flea bath if they had needed one. I’m glad he was honest because he said it could have been dangerous for my cats to get the bath. Who knows, other places might have not cared and done it anyway. He let me board them and the dogs while the exterminator took care of the fleas, very nice guy. He has a new customer”

4.3 Superb55 Reviews

“After i lost my two cats i go to this cat shelter as a volunteer.The staff are wonderful and dedicated .They love these beautiful animals. The cats are so well treated and loved.Every time i go there, i have a wonderful experience.Kudos to Christine and her team for doing such a great job.”

4.3 Superb27 Reviews

“Love the way my Dog was groomed at Lindsey’s !! My first time there- but I’ll surely be back!! Dina was my dog Bentleys groomer-and she did a wonderful job with him… Highly recommend Dina & staff!!”

4.2 Good142 Reviews

“Very friendly pets’ store. Treat you and your love one like part of their family. Sarah was wondering! She did her job well and explained the details of service. Strongly recommend!”

4.2 Good146 Reviews

“The ladies at the Grooming saloon, very understanding and caring towards my cocker spaniel. They were very patient. they took into consideration to cut his fur first, and then wash him then groom him so that he wouldn’t be so anxious. I know this all sounds just what they should do but they were very understanding. also look like they did not rush just to get them out.”

4.5 Superb25 Reviews

“I was really Shocked , I heard their Radio Spot & took a chance , I'm a 1st time user & had Ordered online 4 Perscriptions for my Dog Louie after 7p.m. when they were Closed . To my Amazement i got them Delivered to me by 3p.m. the next Day & i live out in the Moriches . I am Blown away with these Folks & i saved about $30 on all 4 Meds . GREAT JOB PET DRUG STORE !!! Also Great Communication as they keep you a wear of the Order Status via E-mail .... What more can you Ask ? You a Customer for as long as Louie is still with us . Thank You & will call next month.”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews

“I've been searching for a good reliable groomer for over 3 years for my Labradoodle. After six different places, I was referred to Janice at South Shore Grooming. I called and left a message on Saturday and got a call back within 24hrs for a Monday appointment. I have to admit I was a little anxious, especially after having no luck with the previous groomers. I dropped off my furbaby at 10am and got a ball back by 12pm that she was ready. I was surprised to say the least since in the past it's taken at least 4+ hours at all the other places. But when I got there I was pleasantly surprised. Janice was able to accomplish what no other groomer had, she managed to do a full grooming on my relatively big (75+ lbs) girl, without having to air dry her or keep her in a kennel for longer than needed. Keke (my furbaby) was absolutely excited to see me but what I noticed was that she didn't look sad like she normally did after our previous grooming sessions. Janice took real good care of Keke and you could visibly see how happy she was. I feel like I just hit the jackpot finding Janice so close by. Thank you for taking such good care of my furbaby and making her look and smell great!!! I can officially say I have found a groomers for LIFE!!!!! If you need a reliable, fast and courteous groomer look no further than South Shore Grooming for all your needs, you will not regret it!”

4.3 Superb27 Reviews

“My best friend biggie had a heat stroke and we were scared for his life called PetSmart veterinarian services because we used them before with my other puppy Lola and they were very good with her so we brought biggie and they where able to see him right away and helped him get back to his biggie self thank you very much we appreciate you guys staff is very helpful and attentive.”

4 Good196 Reviews

“Good pet store but has an "out of order" sign on the bathroom door for 2 years now. Ridiculous that they can't provide a bathroom for customers like every other pet store.”

3.9 Good62 Reviews