Butchers near Fire Island Pines, NY

7 locations found near Fire Island Pines

“Best market in the LGBT villages. Sure, prices are high so it makes sense, if you can, to bring non- perishable provisions. But if you don’t want to subsist on Kraft Mac & Cheese and Dinty Moore canned beef stew, then Pines Pantry is a treat. Though not as comprehensive as a mainline supermarket quality is usually very good and they feature a bakery with tasty croissants. It was worth walking with the gorilla wagon (inflatable moon buggy wheels recommended for the few open sand stretches) from our cabin near Sailors Haven and through Cherry Grove and no-man’s land to the Pines. Prices at the market in Cherry Grove are a bit lower but they don’t usually have the selection that Pines Pantry has.”

4.4 Superb79 Reviews

“A great place that's been around forever great food and quality. Pleased to see they are finally doing something with the old Richard York building ?. That place has been empty since 2014.”

4.8 Superb82 Reviews

“Chubs catered my party, we went with the package for 50 people. Food was delivered on time, hot, & delicious! Quantities & quality did not disappoint - highly recommend them for your catering needs.

Also picked up a hero for lunch a few days prior to the party. Massive portion & delicious!”

4.6 Superb101 Reviews

“We loved the old fashioned more for for your buck treatment. Their meat pkg deals are generous, its enough to last the month. Huge saving compared to supermarkets.”

4.5 Superb17 Reviews

“All the food is super fresh and they have the best mozz in town, hands down. People are super friendly and the store is clean and extremely well kept. My only gripe is the wait-I often drop in for one or two small items, and get stuck there for 15-20 minutes-I've actually walked out a couple times, because I simply couldn't stay any longer. It's still my go-to spot!”

4.4 Superb50 Reviews

“I absolutely adore this store. The produce is FRESH. Well stocked and just about anything you need, they have. The store is clean and organized. I am never disappointed when purchasing my produce and fresh items from this location!”

4.2 Good251 Reviews

“I love Giuntas cold cuts and baked bread... I like their produce and sometimes the clearance section stuff. Unfortunately, some items are more expensive than the "Big" supermarkets... but depending on what you go there for, you can't find better anywhere else.”

4 Good121 Reviews

Related Categories