Grocery Stores near Fire Island Pines, NY

30 locations found near Fire Island Pines

“Best market in the LGBT villages. Sure, prices are high so it makes sense, if you can, to bring non- perishable provisions. But if you don’t want to subsist on Kraft Mac & Cheese and Dinty Moore canned beef stew, then Pines Pantry is a treat. Though not as comprehensive as a mainline supermarket quality is usually very good and they feature a bakery with tasty croissants. It was worth walking with the gorilla wagon (inflatable moon buggy wheels recommended for the few open sand stretches) from our cabin near Sailors Haven and through Cherry Grove and no-man’s land to the Pines. Prices at the market in Cherry Grove are a bit lower but they don’t usually have the selection that Pines Pantry has.”

4.4 Superb79 Reviews

“Ryan is the man! Always there to help me when I need it & provide service with a smile no matter the situation. When I see him I know it’s gonna be a good day & an even better shopping experience!”

4.4 Superb59 Reviews

“I absolutely adore this store. The produce is FRESH. Well stocked and just about anything you need, they have. The store is clean and organized. I am never disappointed when purchasing my produce and fresh items from this location!”

4.2 Good251 Reviews

“Absolutely phenomenal sandwiches here Delicious HUGEand affordableOn your way to #orient ferry #fire island ferry or a beach day ...wonderful petit deserts and small chip bags if your conscious of your daily caloric intakeStaFF FRIENDLY.AMPLE parking and accessible”

4.8 Superb61 Reviews

“We love to shop in King Kullen. The store is very clean and organized. Staff here are nice too.
Overall is a great place to shop for all your grocery needs.”

4.2 Good145 Reviews

“Been going here everyday for years. Everyone is so super friendly. Great prices and amazing food. Always fresh also. Facility is very clean inside and they take meticulous care of their kitchen as well. No way you can’t be satisfied coming here.”

4.5 Superb41 Reviews

“Everything is good here and I've been here many many times, so I know. But the absolute best is their homemade Split Pea soup with a buttered brick oven roll on a cold dreary day like today. SOOOOOO GOOOOOD! thank you, Furci's!”

4.4 Superb86 Reviews

“Great neighborhood grocery store! The staff is always friendly and helpful. The store itself is clean and neat with a good selection of items. It sure beats having to go up on Sunrise Highway to do my daily shopping. Thanks King Kullen.”

4.1 Good103 Reviews

“A beautiful supermarket on south ocean very well stocked good prices and a lot to choose from . As soon as you walk in you smell fresh baked bread fish ? yummy will shop here regularly.”

4.2 Good71 Reviews

“Wow! A hidden gem! GREAT food & prices! Stopped before a day on the boat .was in need of last minute food and wanted to avoid main street. So happy I went here. They were quick and had everything I needed. I got a BLT on a roll w cheddar, bacon well done and it was phenomenal I finished it so quick! Will definitely be returning !”

4.7 Superb17 Reviews

“Best piece for sandwiches on FI. Staff is always extremely nice and helpful. Giant selection for such a small market. We walk from the other side of ocean beach just to go here.”

4.5 Superb60 Reviews

“My best friend, Linda. Goes shopping here all the time and she loves the place. I even go shopping there too. People are very respectful. They tell you where the stuff are when you're lost. They show you where the stuff is. I listen to Linda because she directs me the right way. Where to go drop in for good stuff? And presents and all the above. She just has nothing but great things about this place. That's why she mostly told me about this place. I can see myself working here. And helping Linda out.”

4 Good101 Reviews

“Lidl has become my preferred grocery store. The store is consistently clean, well-maintained, and thoughtfully laid out, making it easy to find everything I need. Their produce is always fresh and well-stocked, and the bakery section is a standout — the breads, rolls, and pastries are of excellent quality and taste as though they came from a specialty shop.

Pricing is another strong point. Lidl offers great value without sacrificing quality, and I regularly notice meaningful savings compared to other local supermarkets. Their rotating weekly specials and international selections also add variety and make shopping here an enjoyable experience.

Most importantly, the staff at this location deserve recognition. They are professional, efficient, and always approachable if assistance is needed. Checkout is smooth and quick, even during busier hours.

Overall, this Lidl sets a high standard for grocery shopping in the area. It combines quality, affordability, and excellent customer service, and I would highly recommend it to anyone in the East Patchogue & surrounding communities.”

4 Good96 Reviews

“All the food is super fresh and they have the best mozz in town, hands down. People are super friendly and the store is clean and extremely well kept. My only gripe is the wait-I often drop in for one or two small items, and get stuck there for 15-20 minutes-I've actually walked out a couple times, because I simply couldn't stay any longer. It's still my go-to spot!”

4.4 Superb50 Reviews

“I love Giuntas cold cuts and baked bread... I like their produce and sometimes the clearance section stuff. Unfortunately, some items are more expensive than the "Big" supermarkets... but depending on what you go there for, you can't find better anywhere else.”

4 Good121 Reviews

“I've been shopping here for about a month. The 1st two circulars had incredible coupons and sales. These last 2 weeks, not so much. Without the sales and coupons, it is not worth the drive to Oakdale.”

4.1 Good40 Reviews

“Very friendly and helpful staff, solid selection of food drink and toiletries and the grill has a small but solid menu of deli foods like breakfast sandwiches,quesadillas and subs. Nice seating outside, and the town gazebo is nearby along with a covered awning on the side if it rains.”

4.4 Superb42 Reviews

“It's an average deli with average services. They don't take care customers like other delis in the area. Also, they don't have a lot of chips nor drinks in the store. Very few items. But this is probably the best place to buy lottery tickets in the area, you'll never win though.”

4.6 Superb26 Reviews

“The cashiers are very friendly
Easy to buy because it is not that big
And I always find fresh bananas, great Dominican avocados and everything is organized

I had some cup cakes, sponge cake and macarons made for my son's birthday, all delicious”

4 Good47 Reviews

“i really do love this smoke shop because of the way i get treated here at night time, don’t care to come here during the day. day staff is inconsistent and i find it unprofessional, the night staff is what keeps me coming back and what makes me actually feel like a valued customer. i rated 4 stars so it wouldn’t screw with their overall rating because they are good; but really only at night. ??‍♀️”

4.1 Good46 Reviews

“I go to this Aldi quite often because the prices are better than any other stores. I get in and out real fast and the cashiers are always very nice and friendly!”

3.9 Good142 Reviews

“The best deli around!!! Harry is the man over there. Harry will take care of you and the have the best prices in town!!!! They have anything and everything you could need!!!”

3.9 Good78 Reviews

“Super busy at times!!! Super clean!! Good deals with app too!!!

Stop & Shop on Sunrise Highway in East Islip is a reliable choice for your grocery needs, offering a well-rounded shopping experience.
Customers praise the store's:
* Variety and Selection: From national brands to their own private label "Nature's Promise" line, Stop & Shop offers a wide array of groceries, including fresh produce, bakery items, and organic options.
* Convenience: The in-store pharmacy and gas station are a big plus for one-stop shopping trips.
* Deals and Rewards: Their GO Rewards program allows you to earn points towards gas discounts and other benefits.
Some reviewers mention occasional inconsistencies with produce quality, but overall, Stop & Shop provides a clean and convenient grocery shopping experience in East Islip.”

3.8 Good159 Reviews

“Woah they got a lot of food here you gotta be pretty hungy to eat all that it's gotta be eighty five characters (this review) so im gonna keep going shabobaboyd sosbson dikns. Sism d f”

3.8 Good125 Reviews

“very convenient good deals .end of day visit most fresh vegetables was gone whatever i bought was not good as Bravo quality. this was sad as C-Town waa known for fresh vegitables.”

3.8 Good106 Reviews

“I had a great experience at the BJ’s Tire Center in Bellport. The staff actually pick up the phone to make appointments, which is rare these days! The technician—unfortunately I didn’t catch his name—was courteous, professional, and did an excellent job balancing my tires. I was in and out quickly and everything feels great now. My only wish is that they had an alignment machine, but other than that, it’s a solid spot for all your tire needs. Highly recommend!”

4.3 Superb19 Reviews

“We loved the old fashioned more for for your buck treatment. Their meat pkg deals are generous, its enough to last the month. Huge saving compared to supermarkets.”

4.5 Superb17 Reviews

Related topics