Grocery Stores near Fire Island Pines, NY

30 locations found near Fire Island Pines

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

    4.4 Superb 84 reviews

    “I love the pantry, their selection is fantastic. I recommend coming here even if you’re in Cherry Grove, the prices and selection are much better than the store in the Grove.”

  2. 160 East Main Street, East Islip NY 11730

    4.7 Superb 57 reviews

    “All the food is super fresh and they have the best mozz in town, hands down. People are super friendly and the store is clean and extremely well kept. My only gripe is the wait-I often drop in for one or two small items, and get stuck there for 15-20 minutes-I've actually walked out a couple times, because I simply couldn't stay any longer. It's still my go-to spot!”

  3. 20 Duneway Ave, Ocean Beach NY 11770

    4.6 Superb 67 reviews

    “They’ve got everything you could possibly need, and then some. I wouldn’t consider shopping anywhere else while on Fire Island. The Little family looks out for their customers in a Big way.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 5 Trustees Walk, Patchogue NY 11772

    4.8 Superb 39 reviews

    “2026- Update- I haven’t been over to the Island in a bit and it was happy to see so many upgrades and improvements Flight ride is now $25 round-trip but aside from the getting to the store itself once you get to the store there’s everything you need including gourmet, coffee, and fresh cut cold cut sandwiches. My very favorite place to be, I look forward to my yearly family gatherings here on Davis Park, it’s just a slice of paradise. Just $20.00 round trip ferry ride from patchogue and your here. The store has everything you need for a day visit and many staple items if you are renting a house for a a couple of days.”

  6. 399 Medford Avenue, Patchogue NY 11772

    4.2 Good 255 reviews

    “CLEAN CLEAN CLEAN! I was there on a Sunday afternoon and they had an incredible team working at the deli counter making the process extremely fast and easy! Usually people avoid the deli counter on Sunday and I didn’t even have to wait! Even if I did it would’ve been worth it. Everyone working there was so friendly and helpful. I am very impressed with this meat farms and will be back! Great work! No Sunday scaries for me!”

  7. 5147 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia NY 11716

    4.4 Superb 65 reviews

    “Ulku is the nicest cashier!!! Always has a smile on her face-even after a long day! So courteous & helpful. Store inventory is well-known for being unique with good deals as well as excellent seasonal promotions available. Very good prices...”

  8. 112 Carleton Ave, Central Islip NY 11722

    4.5 Superb 43 reviews

    “Been going here everyday for years. Everyone is so super friendly. Great prices and amazing food. Always fresh also. Facility is very clean inside and they take meticulous care of their kitchen as well. No way you can’t be satisfied coming here.”

  9. 100 Broadway Rd, Saltaire NY 11706

    4.4 Superb 46 reviews

    “Love this place. Great breakfast sandwiches and their baked goods are amazing. Sandwiches are good. Good selection is pretty great considering the store footprint.”

  10. 4585 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia NY 11716

    4.1 Good 133 reviews

    “I love Giuntas cold cuts and baked bread... I like their produce and sometimes the clearance section stuff. Unfortunately, some items are more expensive than the "Big" supermarkets... but depending on what you go there for, you can't find better anywhere else.”

  11. 29 Montauk Highway, Blue Point NY 11715

    4.1 Good 120 reviews

    “Great neighborhood grocery store! The staff is always friendly and helpful. The store itself is clean and neat with a good selection of items. It sure beats having to go up on Sunrise Highway to do my daily shopping. Thanks King Kullen.”

  12. 1104 Smithtown Ave, Bohemia NY 11716

    4.5 Superb 26 reviews

    “It's an average deli with average services. They don't take care customers like other delis in the area. Also, they don't have a lot of chips nor drinks in the store. Very few items. But this is probably the best place to buy lottery tickets in the area, you'll never win though.”

  13. 179 South Ocean Avenue, Patchogue NY 11772

    4.1 Good 78 reviews

    “A beautiful supermarket on south ocean very well stocked good prices and a lot to choose from . As soon as you walk in you smell fresh baked bread fish ? yummy will shop here regularly.”

  14. 440 Sunrise Highway, Patchogue NY 11772

    4 Good 165 reviews

    “I only ran in for Bread. Place is clean, well stocked. A little pricey but not ridiculous... EDIT: IT TOOK LESS THAN A MONTH FOR THE NEW OWNERS TO ABSOLUTELY DESTROY THIS SUPERMARKET.”

  15. 367 Sunrise Highway, Patchogue NY 11772

    4 Good 155 reviews

    “I want to specially say thank you to Bryan, he went above and beyond by helping me with the pick order I got every week (I was kind of upset with the service, always got the fruits in bad condition) but he was very helpful and collaborative, definitely fix what his co-workers did wrong! Thank you! And overall the store is goor and organized!”

  16. 865 Lowell Ave, Central Islip NY 11722

    4.6 Superb 18 reviews

    “We loved the old fashioned more for for your buck treatment. Their meat pkg deals are generous, its enough to last the month. Huge saving compared to supermarkets.”

  17. 1387 Montauk Hwy, East Patchogue NY 11772

    4.3 Superb 26 reviews

    “Makes the best breakfast (especially The Hungry Man Hero). F.Y.I it's best to call in your order because the breakfast hours are their busiest hours! They also have great lunch and dinner options as well.”

  18. 876 Church St C, Bohemia NY 11716

    4 Good 61 reviews

    “Absolutely phenomenal sandwiches here Delicious HUGEand affordableOn your way to #orient ferry #fire island ferry or a beach day ...wonderful petit deserts and small chip bags if your conscious of your daily caloric intakeStaFF FRIENDLY.AMPLE parking and accessible”

  19. 1769 Montauk Hwy, Bellport NY 11713

    4 Good 54 reviews

    “Excellent hot Hispanic food and very good attention from the owner. The employees are all very friendly and there are money transfers with the company Viamericas thank you.”

  20. 580 NY-112, Patchogue NY 11772

    4 Good 48 reviews

    “i really do love this smoke shop because of the way i get treated here at night time, don’t care to come here during the day. day staff is inconsistent and i find it unprofessional, the night staff is what keeps me coming back and what makes me actually feel like a valued customer. i rated 4 stars so it wouldn’t screw with their overall rating because they are good; but really only at night. ??‍♀️”

  21. 655 Montauk Hwy, Patchogue NY 11772

    3.9 Good 118 reviews

    “Great variety of fresh produce & frozen fish. Meats are always fresh & reasonably priced. Love all the imported products. The Lidl brand items save me quite a bit off my bill.”

  22. 21 Broadway Ave, Fair Harbor NY 11706

    4 Good 43 reviews

    “Pioneer market is one of the best markets on the island. Top notch Deli and the Unfriendly’s section for egg sandwiches is awesome too. Robbie and the rest of the crew do a phenomenal job keeping everything fresh and presentable. Pioneer is a true Fire Island Staple!”

  23. 60 Washington Ave, Patchogue NY 11772

    4.2 Good 17 reviews

    “I remember stopping here before we used to go to Corey beach. So clean, great food, very nice people. I miss living out east, our deli's in Lindenhurst should be this good!”

  24. 1050 Islip Ave #11, Brentwood NY 11717

    5 Superb 5 reviews

  25. 1721 Montauk Hwy, Bellport NY 11713

    4.3 Superb 10 reviews

  26. 2650 Sunrise Highway, East Islip NY 11730

    3.8 Good 183 reviews

    “It clean, well organized store that is my go-to place. They have a large bakery section, as well as takeaway, sushi and various other pre-prepared foods. They carry a lot of brands that can be difficult to find in other stores. Their produce section is well stocked and always fresh.”

  27. 4560 Sunrise Hwy, Oakdale NY 11769

    3.8 Good 111 reviews

    “My best friend, Linda. Goes shopping here all the time and she loves the place. I even go shopping there too. People are very respectful. They tell you where the stuff are when you're lost. They show you where the stuff is. I listen to Linda because she directs me the right way. Where to go drop in for good stuff? And presents and all the above. She just has nothing but great things about this place. That's why she mostly told me about this place. I can see myself working here. And helping Linda out.”

  28. 1249 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale NY 11769

    4.1 Good 8 reviews

  29. 904 Johnson Ave, Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    3.8 Good 87 reviews

    “Always have everything I'm lookig for in a hurry staff and owners are very friendly and knowledgable about the products and prices aren't bad breakfest and lunch sandwiches are great”

  30. 36 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip NY 11722

    4.2 Good 5 reviews

  31. 440 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue NY 11772

    4.2 Good 5 reviews

    “Ordered Heros here for my daughter's bday. Amazing! Best prices and awesome service! We usually order from a smaller deli, but king kullen had better prices, sliced the hero, had no extra fees, and the Heros were GREAT! Def order from this King Kullen! Thank you!”

Advertisement

Grocery Stores in nearby cities

Related topics

  • Kroger to Open 110 New Stores by 2029, Unveils 3 New Store Formats

    The Cincinnati-based supermarket giant will open about 110 new stores in fast-growing markets by 2029 and introduce three updated store formats, executives told investors Oct. 20 at the company’s Investor Update in New York. Kroger already runs about 2,700 stores in 35 states. The formats come in three sizes, a bit like small, medium and large, matched to each market. Mary Ellen Adcock, Kroger’s executive vice president and chief merchant and marketing officer, walked through the lineup.

    Read the post
  • Walmart Survey: 70% of Shoppers Say Lower Prices Would Ease the Holidays

    Walmart shoppers want a head start on the holidays, and money explains a lot of it. Some 44% of respondents call affording the holidays their top stressor, and 61% say holiday costs shape their shopping mood. Asked what would make the season easier, 70% picked lower prices and 57% picked more deals and promotions. Convenience ranks lower: 30% want one-stop shopping across categories, and 20% want faster delivery.

    Read the post
  • Walmart Expands 30-Minute Delivery to 33 Markets

    Walmart wants your groceries at the door before the ice cream softens. On May 29, the retailer said its 30-minute-or-less delivery had reached 33 U.S. markets, adding a wave of new cities across the Northeast. Shoppers in those areas can order from more than 100,000 items, everything from fresh produce and baby formula to pet food, electronics, cold medicine, and prescriptions. Behind the scenes, the service leans on Walmart's store network and an algorithm that factors in order size, available drivers, and distance from the store.

    Read the post
  • Trader Joe's Plans 25 New Stores Across the Country

    Trader Joe's keeps adding stores, and shoppers keep showing up. The California grocer has marked nine more locations as "opening soon," pushing its expansion into new corners of the country. The grocer also took first place in the American Customer Satisfaction Index's 2026 supermarket rankings. It has held a spot near the top of that list for years.

    Read the post
  • Target Launches Its Biggest Store Remodel in Over a Decade

    Target is rolling out its most ambitious store overhaul in more than ten years, with plans to remodel over 130 locations and open 30 new stores across the country this year. The retailer is also putting money into supply chain technology upgrades to keep pace with how shoppers buy today.

    Read the post