Grocery, deli, butcher, bakery and catering in the Pines community. Providing all of the essentials and more making for an easy and enjoyable shopping experience. Above our store is an extension of our business with hardware, housewares, garden supplies and more!
Great store with everything you need and want. Also new store upstairs fully stocked with any household item you need! Friendly and helpful staff. A++
June 2026
I love the pantry, their selection is fantastic. I recommend coming here even if you’re in Cherry Grove, the prices and selection are much better than the store in the Grove.
October 2025
Best grocery store on Fire Island! Support local businesses like the Pines Pantry!