Pines Pantry

Grocery Stores, Butchers
Hours:

57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

(631) 597-6200 Directions Order Delivery

Tips

Hours

Monday

9AM - 4PM

Tuesday

Closed

Wednesday

Closed

Thursday

Closed

Friday

9AM - 8PM

Saturday

9AM - 5:30PM

Sunday

9:30AM - 12PM

Photos

Most Recent Reviews

October 2025
Best grocery store on Fire Island! Support local businesses like the Pines Pantry!
August 2025
Takes grief for being overpriced but I loved it. Had bay walk wrap, don't like wraps but was trying to find bay walk.
July 2025
The absolute best. No matter how busy the island is - the service and food are impeccable.

More Comments(79)

You May Also Like

4.61 miles
Seaview Market Grocery Store
4.94 miles
Wiener World Markets Grocery Store
5.04 miles
The Pantry Grocery, Grocery Store
5.11 miles
Stop & Shop Supermarket, Grocery

Location and Contact

Pines Pantry

Grocery Store in Fire Island Pines, NY 57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island Pines (631) 597-6200 Website