Hotels in Hampton Bays, NY

“Reveka is an amazing host. I spent the last weekend here for my birthday and had an amazing time. The property was gorgeous with lots of seating and a unique look. The marina is beautiful as well. Any issues with our stay were solved immediately and i was reimbursed for any inconvenience. I will definitely be coming back next year. I love the gift shop as well, if you forgot supplies for the beach or your stay, she will most likely have it in the shop. I can’t recommend this place enough. The walk to the beach is about 15-20 minutes but it’s a gorgeous walk. There is great restaurants all around.”

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5

We stayed at Canoe Place Inn & Cottages for two nights and absolutely loved it. The property is beautiful — elegant, quiet, and full of charm. Our room had a fireplace, which made it feel so cozy and private, especially during the holidays. When we arrived, there was even a Christmas tree in the room — such a thoughtful touch.

The service was excellent — warm, professional, and personal. Every staff member we met went out of their way to make us feel welcome. The food at the bar was delicious, and the atmosphere was relaxed but refined.

The room was spotless, incredibly quiet, and beautifully designed — you can feel the attention to detail everywhere. The breakfast buffet in the morning was generous, with fresh bagels, eggs, cheese, fruit, and pastries — the perfect start to the day.

We were there just after Christmas and right before New Year’s, and the whole place felt festive yet peaceful. It’s a high-end boutique hotel that still feels personal. We can’t wait to come back — it was a wonderful stay from start to finish.”

“My friends and I had the best time staying at The Drake Inn! The place was super clean, cozy, and exactly what we needed for a little Hamptons getaway. What really made it stand out though were the hosts, Simon was amazing and his wife was so sweet — they were so helpful and easy to communicate with. Always quick to respond and genuinely wanted to make sure we had a great stay.

They gave us awesome local tips and went out of their way to accommodate a couple of requests we had. It’s rare to find hosts this thoughtful. We would 100% stay here again!”

“We loved our 3-night stay in Cottage #8 and have the best things to say about Colonial Shores. We are already planning a return trip - the staff is lovely and they lent my son a fishing rod for our stay. We enjoyed having the convenience of the pool, a playground, the grill, the fire pit and beautiful Bay views. The birds chirping and flowers in bloom really set the tone for a lovely stay. Highly recommend this place!”

“We went during restaurant week so that needs to be considered.. Loved the unique salad and artichoke appetizer. Enjoyed the white sangria and the salmon dish was superior. The paella was the only negative. We felt it was very low in the amount of protein in the dish. 2 small shrimp and several bits of calamari. 2 mussels and that's about it.....ask before ordering this dish.”