Butchers near Hicksville, NY

29 locations found near Hicksville

“I had nice and pleasant experience every time I visited this store.Staff very much cooperative and the store was always clean.I recommend this place for everyone.”

2.3 Poor50 Reviews

“I bought a quarter cow box from them today, I was given a generous bag of Argentinian wild caught shrimp that I promptly thawed and had for lunch in a seafood pasta, the quality was amazing. Thank you for such amazing value on some produce in a time where beef is untouchable in price.”

4.9 Superb206 Reviews

“Always a pleasure to come here, nice people great quality and I live nearby too! The special burgers, the tri tip, the sausages, everything is well done. Highly recommended.”

4.9 Superb167 Reviews

“Every piece of meat we have gotten from Farmingdale Meat Market has been of great quality. The butchers are all so friendly and helpful. Have been a customer for 5 years and will be for many more.”

4.8 Superb225 Reviews

“We have been coming here for years! Never a disappointment. Denise and her staff are so friendly and outgoing. They know you by name when you walk in. They are a PRIME Butcher. Walk run you won’t be disappointed!”

4.9 Superb78 Reviews

“Best boucher on the Island. Clearly the generational knowledge has paid off. There meals and stuffed protein are fantastic value for singles and couples. Rare find.”

4.8 Superb109 Reviews

“I've been coming to Steve's Butcher for over 30 years. They sell prime grade meat. Allways fresh and delicious. They will custom cut anything you buy. The butchers are the best. Very friendly accomodating and knowledgeable. I definitely recommend trying them out.”

4.9 Superb70 Reviews

“There is NO better meat market around than R&S. Anthony & Keri and team are simply the best. Their steaks are on par with the best steakhouses, and my family and I love to cook and enjoy at home. Customer service, top notch. Need an order ahead of time? No problem, I text it in. So happy to have found this market a few years back, and will continue to be a customer for life!”

5 Superb39 Reviews

“Bayville Meats is the best!! Their sandwiches are the best I’ve had on Long Island, their prepared food is delicious and of course the quality of meat is excellent!! They also have a wide range of grass fed options which is nice to have. The store team is always so pleasant, we love the meat center!”

4.9 Superb43 Reviews

“What a wonderful place for last minute kosher food ti go. Pastrami and corned beef sandwiches are tender and fresh. Sides are plentiful and delicious. Try their premise chicken parts for a delicious Friday evening meal.”

5 Superb30 Reviews

“Delicious and tender cuts. Frozen sirloin burgers the best on the grill and the pork roast is superb. Customer service couldn't be beat. Anthony even strives to keep your pets happy - mine has a supply of bones.”

5 Superb27 Reviews

“Anteri's shop always delivers fresh, top-quality meat. You can really taste the difference—everything is tender, flavorful, and perfectly cut. The staff is knowledgeable and helpful, and you can trust you’re getting the best every time. Highly recommend if you want fresh and good quality products”

4.8 Superb37 Reviews

“Awesome meats and deli products, amazing staff and owner. They go above and beyond to help and offer advice on meat cuts and quantities needed for making a great meal. Definitely recommend.”

4.6 Superb50 Reviews

“Troy and team are amazing! Top class service, meats ingredients delicious all the time every time! This is THE butcher to go to! Perfect rating well deserved! Great people, great food and great service!”

4.7 Superb31 Reviews

“I’ve been to two locations. Most recently, the one in Roslyn. They’re both the same. If you don’t see what you need, just ask, and they can season something for you or give you a specific cut. Doesn’t appear that they have fish though.”

4.7 Superb31 Reviews

“Some of the most hospitality I've ever received on top of the amazing smashburger Philly cheesesteak steak, steak hero and the marinated skewers of filet mignon I'm taking home!”

4.5 Superb128 Reviews

“My 1st time at the store & restaurant. Both are clean & tidy & Halal. Halal meat is always fresh, they cannot sell meat from a sick animal as they carry the burden of sins. Great customer service. The food is delicious, not spicy hot. I had ginger chicken & okra.The butcher cut the meat as I asked. This will be my go to butcher & takeout once I'm at the butcher. Give it a try.”

4.8 Superb16 Reviews

“Vinny is the absolute best. He has been with this shop for close to a decade and his experience with the neighborhood and their taste in meats is spot on. Now that the Malverne Butcher Shop is his own, you can expect years more of unbeatable service.”

4.8 Superb14 Reviews

“Excellent freshly cut really good quality meats. They will even marinate on the spot for you.
It's become our go to place to shop when we need large amounts of various fresh meat for our barbeques or family get togethers.
Service is usually pretty quick and accommodating. Checkout is usually pretty quick too. We travel from Queens but it's worth the time, travel and distance as we get more bang for our buck and delicious meats for our efforts!! Highly recommend!!!”

4.4 Superb51 Reviews

“Fabulous meat, poultry, and fish selections. Great premade and side dishes. Wonderful service! Lots of all organic meats to choose from. I don’t buy meat anywhere else.”

4.3 Superb65 Reviews

“For the most part, really like this store. However they are a bit pricey The biggest criticism I have is the quality of their produce. Everytime I purchase their lettuce, cucumbers they inevitably go bad WITHIN A WEEK! I do not purchase produce from them anymore! Everything else is ok”

4.3 Superb198 Reviews

“I've been going to Kollner's for a few years now. I tried them out on a whim when my old butcher let me down a few times. Super glad I did. I've been consistently impressed with the quality of the meats. The meat is always fresh, and you can have it cut to order.

When I need steaks for my family, we each have different tastes in steak. I can get a thicker steak for myself and my son, and then order a thinner cut steak for my wife. Everybody is happy. The steaks are fresh, juicy, well-marbled and delicious. The guys helping me are always happy to cut the meat exactly as I ask for it.

On occasion, we'll get some St. Louis ribs, they are meaty, and the end results is super tender—fall off the bone good. All-around great quality.

When, i've needed chicken, they'll fabricate a whole chicken right there in front of me. Or if I've needed thin cut breast, again, they slice it up right there in front of me.

Beef, pork, chicken, lamb—I've never gone wrong with any product at Kollner's.

The guys behind the counter have always been helpful with suggestions for how much to order or answering questions about the meat.

The prices are really fair, especially considering the quality of the products. I am happy to support this local, family-owned business and highly recommend them.”

4.2 Good36 Reviews

“Perhaps the best product out there by far. These people are taking the game to a whole new level. Quality product at fair prices and excellent service. Well done (execution not the meat temperature ?)”

3.8 Good10 Reviews

“What a wonderful store ?
The food is phenomenal! They even have a very specific style of sausage, Chevalatta, that my 94y.o. dad used to get all the time from Corona. It's a specialty and they had it! We got sausage filled with broccoli rabe, regular ring sausage, multiple types of taralli, and ravioli.
But what makes it completely worth driving across the county for me was the customer service! Kind, big smiles all around, just an absolutely delight to go there. I found them on a whim driving somewhere else.
I'll definitely be going back and bringing my Dad so he can reminisce as well as get more amazing food!
Thank you A&S for keeping it old school and bringing big smiles to this gal and her Dad ❣️
You're simply the best!
Sincerely, another Emily ?”

4.2 Good126 Reviews

“They have my business for life!!! Not only is the food wonderful the service is top notch as well. Ordered a cake for my son’s first birthday and the cake got dropped coming into my house. Iavarone took the time to redo the cake to the same beautiful standard and still had to cake ready in time to sing happy birthday. So grateful and will always recommend to people for catering and everyday needs.”

4.2 Good219 Reviews

“I am so grateful today I dropped my sunglasses in the Freeport location this morning and I looked but didn’t find it .. I reported to the manager and the staff /cashier .I have been a customer for the past 30years since Compare foods , totally love this store and the staff always helpful . But today after I left ,I just decided to go back at about 3pm and asked if anyone turned them in … wow !!!! They found it ,so very thankful for you all… not only great food and service but honesty!!!

Thank you and may God bless you all

Sincerely Laxmi W”

3.9 Good88 Reviews

“We used Uncle Giuseppe's to cater a birthday party for about 40 people. We were so pleased with the service, delivery, presentation and quality of the food. Everything was a 5/5. Thank you so much!”

4 Good185 Reviews

“Live poultry dressed to your preference, with a fairly wide choice of pulley variety, right here on the island! Was not crowded when I went on a Saturday afternoon, was in and out in 15 minutes. Came here to buy chicken, left with duck and chicken eggs around with dressed poultry.We have been coming to Safety Swim around the block for many years without being aware of this hidden gem.They do mind taking photographs / videos, but are otherwise polite, professional, efficient.”

3.5 Good42 Reviews