Tire Dealers near Lake Grove, NY

30 locations found near Lake Grove

“Great I blew a tire on the LIE at like 4 pm on a Saturday. Luckily I am smart enough to have AAA I was towed home and now need tires so I call on pep boys and discovered they had the 4 I needed
AAA to the rescue. Towed me and my car to get 4 new tires they were quick and. Certious”

4.6 Superb235 Reviews

“I had an excellent experience at Firestone thanks to the outstanding customer service provided by Patrick, the manager. From the moment I walked in, he was friendly, professional, and made sure I fully understood the services my vehicle needed. He went above and beyond to ensure everything was completed in a timely manner and kept me updated throughout the process. It's rare to find someone who genuinely cares about customer satisfaction the way Patrick does. I highly recommend this Firestone location.”

4.2 Good143 Reviews

“This place is great. The service is fast, employees are nice, prices seem extremely competitive compared to other service centers I have been to. For christmas I was sent a coupon that nearly covered the cost of an oil change which was truly excellent service. I don't really have a ton else to say besides the fact that this is the best service center I have been to and I see no reason to go elsewhere.”

4.9 Superb192 Reviews

“My tire was punctured on a random side road, luckily this shop wasn't too far off so I came here and the guy at the front was friendly and straight forward. Got my tire replaced with a donut in the trunk and the guy said that the service was free, what a nice guy, I REALLY wish I tipped more.”

4.9 Superb219 Reviews

“Came here twice and I won’t go anywhere else!!!! They are affordable, friendly, quick, and just all around good people!!! This is how businesses should be ran. Thank you for the help today and any going forward!”

4.9 Superb200 Reviews

“These guys are amazing, I’ve brought my 2023 Subaru brz to install new custom wheels and tires and they did a phenomenal job. I also came in today for a flat and they fixed it in 10 minutes! Highly recommend these guys they will never let you down”

4.9 Superb166 Reviews

“23 Colorado Z71. Just had Richie Jr and the guys install Eibach Pro stage 2 coilovers/shocks along with new wheels and tires. Richie took his time to explain everything to me along with pros and cons of what I was looking.
I could not be more pleased with the work they performed. They now have a life long customer . Thanks RMS off-road you guys rock.”

4.9 Superb157 Reviews

“Highly recommend this tire shop. The team was friendly and honest. Prices were fair, service was excellent, and my car drives much smoother now. I’ll definitely be coming back here for any future tire work or maintenance.”

4.8 Superb160 Reviews

“I feel so confident leaving my car here! I trust their work for necessary repairs and their recommendations for maintenance. Work is guaranteed and covered! Friendly yet professional. Don’t hesitate leaving your vehicle here. You’ll be happy you did.”

4.8 Superb164 Reviews

“I just bought a used car and got a flat, when I looked at the tire it had a nail at the edge between the sidewall and tread, also a slash in the middle of the tread. I brought it to Costco, they wouldn't patch it. I found Terry Bros highly recommended in a local facebook group. Called them, described the problem and the owner said bring the tire, we will fix it. Got there around 4:20pm, someone met me at the door, took a look and started patching it right away. 15 minutes later it was done, only hole was from the nail. I will be back and recommend them to everyone. A great business.

Update: 11/11/2025 had another flat tire, this time a big metal tack. Brought the tire over at 8am, out the door by 8:10. Great place, great service.”

4.8 Superb173 Reviews

“Excellent!!! Went here for a set of 4 new tires for my wife’s car and the store manager Joe was friendly , knowledgeable and explained everything. Joe recommended the Goodyear comfort tires and the car now rides smooth and my wife loves the ride. Joe never tried to sell me anything I didn’t need like so many places try and get you to spend more than you need. The staff were friendly and location is great. They even had great coffee and TV while we waited in the waiting room. I will recommend to all my family and friends.”

4.8 Superb136 Reviews

“Exclusively come here whenever I need anything with my car. The service is always fantastic, extremely knowledgeable and personable. Would recommend to everyone!”

4.7 Superb242 Reviews

“Keith and Thomas provided exceptional assistance in repairing my flat tire. Their expertise and professionalism were evident throughout the service, which exceeded my expectations. ❤️❤️”

4.7 Superb256 Reviews

“I recently had two nails in my tire and I must say I was so impressed with the staff and service I received at the Mavis Tire in Smithtown! Larry and the woman up front ( I'm sorry I didn't get her name) were wonderful, along with the gentleman who took care of my tire. They all were so welcoming and friendly. They didn't force me to get a new tire. They showed me where it was and how they would fix it. I'm so happy I went here. The service is incredible. Thank you all.”

4.7 Superb227 Reviews

“Had some major work done on my Chevy pickup truck on the front end with the steering and axles. I usually do repairs myself but didn’t have time due to work schedules and James took good care of my truck. He thoroughly explained what he was doing and charged me fairly for the work done. Extremely satisfied with the work done and will be returning in the future”

4.9 Superb63 Reviews

“The East islip Mavis was one of thee best places I have went on Long Island. Very affordable with great deals , quick service, and the mechanics there are so helpful, personable, and knowledgeable. My whole family will be coming here for their cars ! Can’t thank them enough ! !!”

4.7 Superb213 Reviews

“Would give more than five stars if I could! Brought my dad's car here with a huge bolt in the tire, Dan and Josh helped me and were amazing! Very nice and got the tire patched so quick!!! Thank you!! ?”

4.7 Superb220 Reviews

“Smithwest Service Center took me in without scheduling to repair my leaking tire. Work was completed fairly quick with minimal wait time in their comfortable waiting area. I left satisfied but not sure if my AAA discount was applied to the bill. Regardless the price was fair, perhaps more reasonable than other automotive shops in the area. I recommend Smithwest Service Center”

4.7 Superb167 Reviews

“I had the greatest and quickest car inspection today. The owner was very busy and told me, very nicely, I might have to wait 30 to 60 minutes..but I said I didnt mind waiting. But he took care of my inspection and I only waited less than 10 minutes! Such a sweetheart! Thank you soooo much!”

5 Superb54 Reviews

“Good people you can trust. Nice Local place, we take ALL our family cars here. We even have then check out any used cars BEFORE we buy them! Get it fixed right the 1st time. Won't go anywhere else.”

4.8 Superb85 Reviews

“I’ve brought them two cars now, one was a hot mess that hadn’t moved in 3 years but was a newer car with less than 6 thousand miles, they took the extra step of washing the car down before giving it back. Second car had a giant crack in the windshield I forgot about and was due for an inspection. Nico’s way facilitated my glass replacement for me and went through my insurance. From previous experience I know how hard the front glass on this car is to get and they had the glass installed by the end of the day and followed with my inspection and oil change the following day. Amazing turn around time and I didn’t even have an appointment. Thank you very much guys”

4.9 Superb70 Reviews

“I came in with a flat tire for the second time within the past few months. The service was still quick and helpful and got my truck back on the road again in no time.”

4.7 Superb140 Reviews

“Taurus Auto Center has been my go-to for years, and they’re consistently excellent: honest, skilled, and fast. They explain what needs to be done (and what doesn’t), charge fair prices, and stand behind their work. I trust them completely, and so does my father. Highest recommendation. Five stars.”

5 Superb65 Reviews

“First time at Elite. This is not an “address the complaint, throw parts at it and move on” place. Richie paid attention to everything I told him, thoroughly went through my aging bmw, found the issue- even uncovered a little surprise- communicated with me clearly throughout. I was uneasy about it at first bc I have a trusted specialist, but they are far away from me and cost and timing for dropoff and pickup were too cumbersome. I’m glad I went with Elite, my car is happy and so am I. Would recommend.”

5 Superb54 Reviews

“From beginning to end, my experience was excellent!
I had significant engine issues, and the team at A&R was professional, courteous, and kept me updated throughout the entire process. Thank you, A&R!”

4.7 Superb163 Reviews

“Smithtown/St James site is a great place to have service done i called and was able to get my car in for service within the next business day. Tom told me how long it would likely take and it was completed around that time”

4.6 Superb276 Reviews

“if u need ur car looked at and fixed right bring it to Mike!!!….. unless you want to get charged hundreds of dollars for things you don’t need

good mechanics are hard to find! this guys shop has over 100 5 star reviews for a reason, COME HERE TO GET YOUR CAR FIXED”

4.9 Superb72 Reviews

“I needed a NYS safety check for my Tesla. Paul and his team made it happen w/o an appointment, in 10 mins, and for $10. This is unheard of (after previous experiences with official dealerships and small local shops) and I will certainly coming back. Great job, guys!”

4.7 Superb129 Reviews

“Was helped by Yash (great help) and Gabe
GABE did an amazing job installing my new tires in a very friendly and timely manner I highly recommend the excellent service to others thank you for getting me on my way quickly.... days ahead of my appointment”

4.6 Superb198 Reviews

“Sometimes you meet people and you can tell that they’re just genuine people trying to do some genuine good in the world. Mark is that guy, and the way he does business reflects that.

Mark, pleasure talking with you. Thanks to you and your team for fixing up my truck, thanks for also giving me a break when and where you could. I’ll be a customer as long as I’m on Long Island.

If you’re not sure, just go to Pinky’s, seriously. Car repairs are never fun, but they’re made a thousand times better when you’re working with an honest mechanic who’s got the customer’s best interest in mind.”

4.7 Superb121 Reviews

Related Categories