Meat Shops near Lindenhurst, NY

19 locations found near Lindenhurst

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 633 West Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst NY 11757

    4.7 Superb 97 reviews

    “Great place. Great service. Young man at deli counter gave me a good education about their products. When is the last time a 20 yo gave you good service and had good knowledge to share? You get what you pay for in life and Tonys is worth it”

  2. 237 South Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst NY 11757

    4.5 Superb 131 reviews

    “I’ve been here numerous times and they never disappoint. Last time I was there I was uncertain of what to get and the Giuseppe behind the counter told me to trust him and go with their cheesesteak. I told him I’d try it and if it was good I’d leave a review so here it is: it was GREAT! Very good, filling, and flavorful. I’ll be in there for lunch again soon. Haven’t had a bad meal there ever. Enjoy!”

  3. 8045 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury NY 11797

    5 Superb 201 reviews

    “I bought a quarter cow box from them today, I was given a generous bag of Argentinian wild caught shrimp that I promptly thawed and had for lunch in a seafood pasta, the quality was amazing. Thank you for such amazing value on some produce in a time where beef is untouchable in price.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 210 Main Street, Farmingdale NY 11735

    4.8 Superb 225 reviews

    “Every piece of meat we have gotten from Farmingdale Meat Market has been of great quality. The butchers are all so friendly and helpful. Have been a customer for 5 years and will be for many more.”

  6. 249 Old Walt Whitman Rd, Huntington Station NY 11746

    4.9 Superb 159 reviews

    “Food ain,t just food. And it hasn't been for many years. The small business proprietors of healthy foods are not getting rich. In a time when quality food is at a premium, C&C exemplifies the best of what is possible when it comes to clean natural meats. My family and friends can taste (and feel) the difference. Thank you C&C.”

  7. 380 E Jericho Tpke, Huntington Station NY 11746

    4.8 Superb 180 reviews

    “My wife introduced me to the Forest Pork Store when we first started dating. I am a huge fan of the leberkase and the hockey pucks! Great stuff for picnics! We go for Thanksgiving, Christmas, select birthdays! A big shout out to Ray and Kyle!”

  8. 974 Fulton St, Farmingdale NY 11735

    4.8 Superb 72 reviews

    “Very well organized store you will never see anything missing of selfsame, meat section is always clean , I never had a issue with meat quality even though I am extremely picky on meat quality”

  9. 85 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon NY 11702

    4.8 Superb 131 reviews

    “The best real meat beef, turkey and chicken you'll ever have. They cook their own meat and slice it and their sandwich assortment is amazing!! We have catered from Babylon meat market for our Church events and everyone raves about how delicious and fresh everything is! The sandwiches are displayed beautifully on a tray! All different kinds of breads, veggie wraps. Rolls, chabata bread, Pannini and rye bread!! You'll go back for more!!”

  10. 3608 Merrick Rd, Seaford NY 11783

    4.5 Superb 42 reviews

    “I drive out of my way to come to this German deli, unfortunately, they were sold out of the Pinkelwurst, I came for but they have the BEST liverwursts, headcheese and smoked meats and the BEST bread (Lithuanians) so I still had the BEST FEAST imaginable”

  11. 245 NY-109, West Babylon NY 11704

    4.5 Superb 27 reviews

    “This is the best Ribeye I have had. Everything about it was 10/10 from the Marbling to the Color and of course the taste. I have tried many places and even shopped online a few times and Matthew's Ribeye has been the best. I will certainly be coming back for a long time customer. John or his father cuts it himself and they take care and time about properly cutting the different types of meat especially this prime ribeye steak. Some butchers skip steps and care when cutting the meat then small bones get on the steak but never had this happen with Matthew's Prime. They are great people, specialist in their field who you can order with and they will take care of you which ever you need. Thank you! ?”

  12. 1500 Sunrise Hwy, Copiague NY 11726

    4.4 Superb 150 reviews

    “Took me back to the island. They all kinds of authentic home know brands and a wide variety specialty items. Everyone I interacted with was extremely courteous and cool. Stop by and enjoy the experience!”

  13. 27 John St, Babylon NY 11702

    4 Good 23 reviews

    “Best butcher in town. Everyone is helpful and friendly. Followed butcher's advice for cooking and roast was perfect. Butcher cut back bone before tying prime rib, which made carving a breeze.”

  14. 548 Central Ave, Bethpage NY 11714

    4.2 Good 47 reviews

    “Very friendly and helpful. Everything looks delicious. We went right before Easter last year. There was a very long line. But they had their sales people on top of it. They made the line move fast. I will be going back again. Did I tell you everything is delicious?”

  15. 929 N Broadway, Massapequa NY 11758

    4 Good 123 reviews

    “What a wonderful store ? The food is phenomenal! They even have a very specific style of sausage, Chevalatta, that my 94y.o. dad used to get all the time from Corona. It's a specialty and they had it! We got sausage filled with broccoli rabe, regular ring sausage, multiple types of taralli, and ravioli. But what makes it completely worth driving across the county for me was the customer service! Kind, big smiles all around, just an absolutely delight to go there. I found them on a whim driving somewhere else. I'll definitely be going back and bringing my Dad so he can reminisce as well as get more amazing food! Thank you A&S for keeping it old school and bringing big smiles to this gal and her Dad ❣️ You're simply the best! Sincerely, another Emily ?”

  16. 1753 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park NY 11729

    3.9 Good 65 reviews

    “they are friendly. just may be they supposed to use freshener or sth in the store. a lot of bread choices available. Centrally located, right on Deer Park Avenue. Butcher shop where you can find halal meat.”

  17. 1170 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon NY 11703

    4.1 Good 184 reviews

    “First, i want to say i really like this store. My problem with it is their chicken breast they sell in the meat department. It is so rubbery when i cooked it! I stopped buying it a few years ago for that reason. No matter what the sale was, i was done buying it. The prepared chicken cutlets are like that too and i made the mistake today buying the vodka chicken parm entree. I heated it up, served it for dinner and there it was again. The rubbery chicken cutlet. This is a big concern, chicken should not have that texture. Where are you getting this meat from? Feel like i wasted $$ on this dinner. Please find another brand or vendor that raises chickens don’t taste like the bottom of a sneaker.”

  18. 115 East Main Street, Babylon NY 11702

    3.9 Good 167 reviews

    “Gemellis deli and restaurant in Babylon Village serve delicious healthy Italian food specialties. The owners of the Babylon Village restaurant and store is a conscientious, friendly and kind person who genuinely cares about his community and the people in it. These successful businesses have been in Babylon Village for over 30 years because of people like Vince the owner. Thank you so much for making sure my 92 year old mother had a dinner to eat, when I couldn’t be there to do it myself. I’ll never forget your kindness. Best wishes for good health, happiness and prosperity. Lorraine”

  19. 601 Old Country Rd, Plainview NY 11803

    4 Good 169 reviews

    “One of Long Islands best kept secrets. Torn between telling you how much I love this market and keeping quiet so it doesn’t get too crowded. Here’s some helpful hints. Bring cash and be in the mood for meat and fish. Once again, no credit cards, no grocery shopping. Cash. Steak. Chicken. Fish.”

  20. 997 Little E Neck Rd, West Babylon NY 11704

    3.7 Good 128 reviews

    “This was always my go-to spot when I grew up in West Bab. You can’t beat their fresh chicken cutlets or homemade sausage. If you’re looking for a true, old-school market with authentic Italian food, I highly recommend it! 🇮🇹🥪”

Advertisement

Meat Shops in nearby cities