Convenience Stores in New Windsor, NY

5 locations found near New Windsor

“I’m sad to admit I forgot about Stewart’s, even though it was a shop I was raised on as a kid; as we used to go get ice cream for a treat sometimes.

Fast forward and the quality is still unmatched, as well as the customer service. One thing I can say about this location is, the quality of the food and service has been on a cumulative roll. The ice cream, which is made from their milk (Which is ranked #1), is delicious and creamy. Especially the limited run flavors. I just realized they have pizza after my mom ordered one the other day, so I had to try a pepperoni one. The crust is so nice and thick that you can be full from one slice. They cooked the pizza to perfection, as it was well done and had a bit of crisp, but still soft and tasty. It wasn’t over-oily and it tasted really good.

I’ve been here a handful of times since I had the ice cream recently and you can tell the staff cares about their job. They do a great job. Thanks guy as always for the superb service and tasty eats!”

4.7 Superb30 Reviews

“Easy to get gas. Clean pumps. I need supreme for my car And use their app. I get $ back when I do and using their synergy gas my milage was gone from 21mpg to 23mpg and keeps rising with every fill up on my 200k mile bmw”

3.2 Average48 Reviews

“My neighborhood Bodega... Staff is good. Coffee is great and tue Rewwards Program is a real benefit. Plus Free Coffee Fridays! We also love the Available Food Menu and quality .”

3 Average83 Reviews

“OMG!!! I didn't know how big these things were! Good Gracious I ordered 2; one for me and one for my 2 kids (8 and 4). We ate off one pretzel but now have a snack for tomorrow.”

2.2 Poor33 Reviews

Related Categories

Related topics