Casey Rubber Stamps is a charming, long-standing gem of a store in NYC, a cool and unusual find packed with all sorts of beautiful rubber stamps. It is a treasure trove and nothing like it in the city, offering novelty, retro, vintage, graphic, animal, plant, nature, and clip art rubber stamps, as well as stamp pads. As old school rubber stamp makers, they provide custom rubber stamps, including Save the Date and invitation stamps, with a diverse choice.
The owner is super awesome, skillful, knowledgeable, and understanding, knowing his stuff and providing super helpful service. Customers can get stamps created in varying sizes, with custom orders shipped to them. The quality of each and every hand carved rubber is impeccable, always with great attention to detail, making them amazing and a steal for the reasonable prices. Custom stamps can be made within 10 minutes after ordering, which is very practical, though mail orders may take a few weeks. The shop itself is very small but a coolest place for easy shopping and customization, complete with a cute kitty. It is a very nice experience where you get exactly what you see.
came for a raccoon stamp, stayed a lil too long for ratty
August 2026
They can make you any stamp but they are so busy might not get it done if you’re in a hurry I will definitely go back
July 2026
They were amazing and supper helpful. The shop has a very cozy and comfortable vibe. There's so many stamps designs and they're able to make you anything from their catalog incase what you want isn't on the shelf :) 10/10!
