11AM - 6PM
80 Main St, Sayville
Jewelry Stores
“Ricky is the best. He exceeded all expectations. I had gone to him looking for an engagement ring, and described everything that I was looking for. He has a great inventory in store that he was able to show me similar options, confirm everything that I wanted, and offer great advice and recommendations. He is not pushy at all, gave me a clear timeline of how long it would take for drawings and delivery of the custom ring, along with an extremely reasonable price and told me to take as much time as I need, shop around, and comeback if I want to purchase it. There was no questions, I bought it that same day. The drawings were sent to me for approval and I was able to talk with him on the phone to ask questions about the design and make any changes if I wanted to. The ring was finished even earlier than he originally said, and it is absolutely beautiful. The ring is everything i wanted and more and my fiancé couldn’t be happier. I have since gone back to Ricky for other Jewelry and will continue to use him in the future. 10/10.”
“I was in a time crunch and in need of a quick resizing of my wedding band. I haven’t been able to take it off for 15 years and yesterday I tried the floss technique, on a whim. It was 2 days before going on vacation, and I was shocked that it worked!! Needless to say, I did not want to put it back on my finger, but I also didn’t want to go on vacation without my wedding band. Why did I do this right before vacation when I have a million things to do?! A quick search revealed several jewelers in the area, but Elegant Jewelry stood out because of their overwhelmingly positive reviews and the mention that they have been around for many years. Well!!! The reviews were spot on!! In business over 30 years and it was clear why—Arsen is amazing and the rest of the staff are true gems! Not only did Arsen resize my wedding band and make it look like new in an hour, but he also noticed the unpolished state of my engagement ring and offered to quickly make it as beautiful as my wedding band at no additional cost. What a class act! As I was leaving I noticed exactly the pair of earrings I have been searching for, so I will definitely be back with some old trade-in jewelry. I live 40 minutes away and just happened to be in Patchogue for the afternoon, but I will happily make the drive again after my vacation because of the quality of service and the quality of the staff.”
“I love the creativity of this shop - there is always something different to browse through! I pop in every single time I’m in town and am never disappointed. The staff is always helpful and delightful - make it a priority to stop in!”
“Staff was extremely helpful, polite, an even dealt with my chatty nature. Hahaha. I had Euro cash from a trip I needed to cash in for USD. They helped me out and even gave me a great exchange rate. Highly recommend this place.”
“Ronny’s the man!! Picked up a new diamond rolex oyster perpetual datejust today. He worked with me gave me a great deal and had good conversation while getting everything together!! Only shopping with him for now on.”
“Stopped by today not knowing the place was appointment only until I read the sign at the door, but the gentleman at the counter let me in anyway and asked what he could do for me. I needed an install/downsize after my cat ripped my titanium post out of my eyebrow. My temporary replacement was far too long, mystery metal, and really, really irritating my piercing. He squeezed me right in and got me set up with a new piece real quick. VERY clean, VERY professional, very honest. Autoclaved the jewelry right in front of me. Talkative and kind. There’s always a risk of rejection with eyebrows, but I’m happy he was willing to work with me to try and save it. Wish I could remember his name! Affordable pricing before jewelry for one of the only APP shops on the Island. My eyebrow looks and feels better already. So relieved and will be coming back soon for some new holes. Thank you!
TLDR; clean, professional, friendly, accommodating. Price is right. Would recommend.”
“The prices were respectable and frankly I can't complain about them. The service was STELLAR, and almost seemed free if you consider the usual retail prices for silver.TLDR: They shortened a chain to my perfect length, made a bracelet from the spare links, and made a new bail for my pendant, making no fuss about any of it whatsoever throughout the whole process. And I can't emphasize enough how reasonable their prices are if you need any work done.Steve was beyond helpful. (I'm pretty sure Amanda) was lovely and helped me find the perfect chain, but it was way longer than I wanted. Not only did Steve shorten the chain for me, they are also turning the spare length into a bracelet! Steve even measured the chain on me to make sure that the length I wanted matched the length I asked for. On top of that, I have a pendant that's incredibly important that I wanted to put on one of their chains, but the bail was beaten to heck and way too small. They added a new, sturdy bail and attached it for me.All in all, two sterling silver chains, a bail, shortening a chain, and putting a rush on all of it only cost me a couple hundred. STELLAR service, beautiful people, and I intend to go there for ALL of my jewelry needs because of those two. (Not just to purchase, but also maintenance and miscellaneous work)”
“Went in on a Sunday to replace a watch battery, Addy was very professional, tended to my watch needs and no charge, I did bring the battery. My new go to Jeweler in Smithtown, Thank you.”
“CJ was awesome! She was patient & helpful in the process of us choosing our wedding band!! They cleaned up my engagement ring which was really nice & allowed us to view our options better. :)”
“My late mother and I have always been grateful to Vinny; He gives the best prices for Gold and Silver! If you have gold jewelry you don't use get cash for it!”
“Nancy was a great help with picking out my earrings. She was attentive, patient and I didn’t feel rushed. I am so happy with my purchase. thank you so much Nancy!”
10AM - 3PM
87 W Main St, Smithtown
Jewelry Stores
“Recently I decided to redeem my coins at CCJ in Smithtown. I met with Mike and he was extremely likeable, courteous, and knowledgeable. It was my first experience involving this type of transaction. Mike's personality and expertise made this an informative and pleasurable experience. I can honestly recommend Mike and CCJ in Smithtown to anyone interested in exchanging coins.Bob Newman”
10AM - 5:30PM
48 Main St, Sayville
Jewelry Stores
“Each and every time I shop at this lovely jewelry store, I leave happier and happier. The staff is professional, kind, courteous, and willing to go that extra mile for the consumer. Kelly is delightful and accommodating. I highly recommend this fine jewelry store for your best shopping experience.”
“Adorable place with great service and selection! My daughter found her flower girl dress there and they made the whole experience so special! Reasonably priced gorgeous dresses available for all ages ✨️”
“I recently purchased an engagement ring at D’Ore for my now fiancée. The entire experience was amazing! All of the employees, especially Donna, were so knowledgeable, friendly, and professional. I will be recommending D’Ore to everyone I know looking for quality jewelry!”
“Went in there today get to my jewlery serviced. I was helped by Artie, he was great, courteous, and assisted me with everything I needed. Definitely recommend this place. Thanks again Artie.”
10AM - 5:30PM
429A N Country Rd, St James
Jewelry Stores
“Just took my 10 year old daughter to get her ears pierced for the first time. She was very nervous but they made her feel so comfortable and made it overall such a special experience. The store itself is beautiful and the women who work there are so kind. Highly recommend for anyone looking to get their child's ears pierced. Will absolutely return for future jewelry purchases.”
“First time walking into the store to sell gold, greeted by igal. He is an outstanding businessman. Hassle free, friendly, and truthful. I called 6 other places before coming here. You won’t regret it.”
“First time coming here to get my second lobe done! She explained to me thoroughly the aftercare and recommend me what earrings I should get. It was very helpful, reluctant as I was. Definetly would come here again to get my other lobes done!”
“Joann and Stella were phenomenal. Took their time explaining all of the different jewelry and clarity of certain diamonds. They were both very patient and kind. Not pushy and informative. Thanks ! I will be back.”
“Best place to buy a gift. The staff is friendly and they gift wrap. They have many unique gift choices. Christine delivered great customer service. I would give more than 5 stars if Google let me.”
“After an off-putting experience with an OTHER local jeweler, my fiancé & I came to Lamonica Jewelers to have her engagement ring taken down a size. It was beyond refreshing to deal with all the friendly faces we were greeted with. And the work was excellent. You can tell they really care about their business. They are not just out to get your money; coming here feels like coming to a family-friend. You will not regret choosing Lamonica over any other jeweler.”
10AM - 1PM 2 - 5PM
9 Windsor Ave, Brightwaters
Jewelry Stores
“Wow! Went here today with my mom to get my necklace fixed and not only did the jewler immediately know how to solve my problem but he also fixed it on the house! Such an amazing experience. I will be back in the future for any of my jewlery needs!”
“Warm and friendly family owned store! It's so hard to trust people these days, which makes Markar truly stand out as a diamond in the rough. I've never felt more comfortable leaving my jewelry 6 it looks as good as new when I pick it up.”
“Love this place! My hubs and I took a stained glass class. The ladies that run it are so knowledgeable and patient. They walk you through every step. It took us about 6 weeks to finish our product with night classes. We can't wait to go back to start another.”
“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”
“Repaired my wife’s engagement ring! Was told from the original jeweler it was beyond repair. Kiersten’s Jeweler was not only able to repair the ring but it looks brand new! Wife and I couldn’t be happier, repair price was very fair.”
“They did such a fantastic job on my rings! A couple of stones on my band had fallen out and they were able to repair and clean within a week. The most genuine and honest people. Met them for the first time and felt like I knew them forever. Seriously great. 10/10 Highly recommend!!”
“Jorge is AMAZING!! He is kind patient, informative and has a great personality!!! He shines as much as the GORGEOUS crystal in the store. Best experience ever!!! Thank you Jorge and everyone go to this location for your Swarovski!!”
“Found this beauty in the MCM booth. I have never had such a good experience with an antique store! The staff was super helpful, and Mike, the owner of the clock, was willing to ship this for me! I live in Florida and saw the clock on a Facebook post. If you are ever in the area, definitely check this place out!”