Grocery Stores near Old Bethpage, NY

30 locations found near Old Bethpage
View Map

“I live in the area for years and recently started shopping at Han's Natural Farm. I cannot say enough about the quality, freshness, and selection of their fruit. The staff is extremely friendly. I am in the store at least twice a week and highly recommend it!”

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

“Tavlin is a neighborhood gem. Fresh Mediterranean dips & spreads, falafel and other meatless delights. Great selection of dried fruits & nuts. The owners and warm and extremely helpful.”

4.9 Superb142 Reviews

“I only have positive things to say as well. My family used to visit the shop in Ridgewood and we finally made it to the Huntington Location. Our favorite as the krainerwurst, cervelat, chicken rolls, pretzel rolls (ask for the salt, they will give you a container). There is also a bunch of German / European items throughout the store, such as mustards, sauces, and candies. They have adorable Christmas shaped fondant candies that would be too cute for me to even want to eat - they were a little expensive or I would have bought them all. Oh and they have other candies shaped like a pig which I wanted as well. Customer service is top notch. Needless to say, I will be back.”

4.8 Superb142 Reviews

“I found this place randomly one day. The food is a pleasant surprise. They serve healthier tasting dishes with less grease than traditional filipino places. The convenience of their grocery section is a plus. It’s a small mom and pop spot with all the pantry staples and snacks. The price is a bit higher than what you can find at big Asian grocers, but considering the ease of having everything you need in one place it is fair. The options are limited here in LI and I can easily pass on the trip to Roosevelt Ave for this spot instead.”

4.6 Superb87 Reviews

“This place is awesome!! I’m not Greek, but I love the food, this guy takes it to another level. Everything he has is home made besides all the imported Greek products but he explains everything to me and teaches me about the food and what’s healthy, what’s not, and he just is an incredibly great human being.”

4.6 Superb81 Reviews

“The best around. Sherry’s Market is one of a kind. Healthiest products and supplements you won’t find anywhere else. Endless organic and vegan options that will not disappoint. Nutritionist is very knowledgeable and helpful friendly staff.”

4.6 Superb80 Reviews

“Always welcoming and accomodating! Love stopping by here to grab something quick and go! The freshly made sandwiches are incredible and better than any sub stop I have been to! Highly recommend.”

4.8 Superb38 Reviews

“Good for fruits and vegetables that you can't find in most supermarkets - the mainstream fruits and vegetables are a bit more expensive.The meats are very reasonable!”

4.4 Superb115 Reviews

“Nice place, but waaaaaaaay over priced. $6 for carrots ? they're definitely taking advantage of the affluent neighborhood. Bought a small apple pie ($23) and it tasted good but it's like a jiffy pop popcorn, obnoxiously high crust so you can't cut a slice cleanly, definitely can NOT serve this to guests, impossible to plate (see pics) also a small 6" zucchini bread ($8.95) it was good.”

4.6 Superb52 Reviews

“I went there 07/25/18. Honestly, I love everything I got here. Everything I got here tasted African made, you know what mean? Cow skin, can't stop leaking my fingers. The atmospheric condition here is simply the best. Was my first time meeting the owner of the place, she is a very friendly person. If i could rate according to how she treated us, I will give her ⭐⭐🌟⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐🌟⭐. RUN TO THIS PLACE if you want real African food.”

4.8 Superb33 Reviews

“Enjoy eating lunch, and sometimes dinner at their buffet. Has a small seating area. Found the food freshly made, and healthy eating. The grocery store has a large selection of items for purchase. Has a south-of-the-border feeling while inside. I am still teaching myself Spanish, the staff is very cooperative with my unique sign language, and the toddler like pointing to what I wish to purchase. Happy with the choice offered of self-check-out for a fast shopping experience.”

4.4 Superb87 Reviews

“Easy access from LIE and Northern Parkway, spacious parking lot shared with a number of other businesses, big market inside with plenty of selection, there's even a small food court on the right immediately after entering the H Mart, the ready made Korean food makes for good options to take home for an easy meal option, the meat section towards the back has plenty of marinaded Korean BBQ meats anyone can use to have a nice at home dining experience, overall this H Mart is one of the better ones I've shopped at”

4.4 Superb87 Reviews

“Was very impressed with all the different varieties they had in the store . Everything was well stocked and the store was extremely clean . The gentleman at the counter was very polite and helpful . Ordered Halal meat ? which was very clean and well cut . Thank you and you will be seeing me again .”

4.8 Superb31 Reviews

“Stumbled upon the Olive tree in the village of North Port. So glad I did. The owner was friendly, knowledgeable and passionate about his products. The beautiful variety of olive oils and vinegars was amazing. They encourage me to taste anything that I was interested in. So much so that I bought 10 bottles of a variety of products. The woman was new, and she was so friendly and helpful. This place is a real gem, and a great addition to the small Town Of North port.”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“It was taken down in my neighborhood but I completely recommend. I remember it being my whole childhood and I loved going there and taking bread samples. If you want a place where the staff and service is amazing I would strongly suggest this place for you. The variety of different foods and supplies is impeccable. Next time you need a friendly supermarket I very highly recommend fairway for you and your family as a place to go.”

4.4 Superb75 Reviews

“Great smoothies and juices. Love that they prepare everything individually. They also have some great produce and healthy snacks. We've always had a wonderful time shopping here. The service is great, the staff is super nice and friendly. Love that it's so close to home!”

4.6 Superb40 Reviews

“Authentic Italian market. Rare find, hidden gem. A customer of mine from Lexus down the road told me about this place. Came in to try their pizza, all fresh quality ingredients at a great price! 5* will be back”

4.8 Superb27 Reviews

“Nice place , very clean and organized. Prices are good, small store but well stocked with a variety of choices. The guy behind the register was very courteous. Overall a good place stop for Indian grocery before Hicksville. Oh and most important indian beers are there too!”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“Excellent selection of everything you can imagine. Fantastic seafood section Steaks Many varieties of bread, just a wide array of fresh Foods to Choose from when you’re out and about, And you See StewLeonardsStop and check it out you will not be disappointed! Enjoy”

4.3 Superb86 Reviews

“I love Dairy Barn, now GBG. The owner might want to think about keeping chocolate donuts in fridge when it is hot out and doors are kept open. The chocolate melted :-)”

4.9 Superb20 Reviews

“5 stars!! I’m a crew member from Florida visiting back home here in ny and had the best experience at this Trader Joe’s!!! Talk about the grand finale at the register with KEVIN! He was awesome, so kind and knew all the informative facts of Trader Joe’s! Chris was awesome too talked to my sister and I in the aisle helping us out! Please shout them out in the huddles because they made such a good impression and stay for us. Great job wowing us”

4.3 Superb69 Reviews

“This place is absolutely amazing! It does not always have what you want comparing to bigger grocery chains but the quality of meat and seafood is excellent. I was amazed how knowledgeable the seafood clerks are. And the local fruits and vegetables often have good sale prices and selections.”

4.6 Superb30 Reviews

“Very impressed! I said that 3 times inside the store, so that is saying much. First time in a Lidl and very happy with their fruit, bakery and overall prices. They also carry brand names so there are a lot of choices. Crazy how we got a whole Butterball Turkey for $13 total! I liked Lidl better than Aldi and we'll be back :)”

4.3 Superb67 Reviews

“Convenient location in Plainview Shopping Centre for Trader Joe's with free parking shared across all the stores. Take a shopping cart before entering the store or pick up a shopping basket. This store is smaller than to others that I've been to but has most of the items when I need to get them here. Came here on a weekend and surprisingly not as crowded on a rainy day as normally is. Vegetables fruits and all as you enter. Aisles are marked so it's easy to find what you need, Came to pick up a organic carrots which are always .99/lb. Staff is friendly and helpful if you are looking to find something in particular. TJ's also sells their own reusable bags and re-usable cooler bags too, which comes in handy to keep food cool especially in the summer. Checkout is fairly quick with plenty of cashiers, friendly and helpful. They don't charge for paper bags here like they do in the city, which is a plus.”

4.3 Superb67 Reviews

“I need to explore this store more but popped in to check out the bakery and it did not disappoint. Prosciutto bread, onion rolls, and apple turnovers were all excellent. The bread loaves all looked awesome. Cheese selection looks great as does the produce. Was hoping to grab some fresh pierogi but a worker showed me where they would have been but they didn't have them that day. Bakery line was busy but checkout lines were fast. Will be back for sure.”

4.4 Superb43 Reviews

“I'm only taking 1 star off because isn't it known as a dairy place but has no chocolate milk? HOW? WHY? lol. Anyway my dad supposedly told us about this place years ago and our son would like it, but it wasn't until my hub's coworker told him about it did we say lets go! Took our son and y up he loved it. Got some yummy cookies, tried the cider, and debated strawberry milk but nah. Also of course tried their ice cream which is good. We'll probably come back around halloween, maybe they'll have some kind of chocolate milk or I heard it's cool for the holiday :P”

4.2 Good76 Reviews

“The food and customer service is beyond excellent. I’ve ordered from North Main for my baby shower, daughter’s birthday and family gatherings and each time it’s been better than before. I highly recommend ordering from here. Everyone is super friendly and the owner Eddie, is very understanding and flexible. Overall, a wonderful experience when ordering catered food.”

4.8 Superb18 Reviews

“For years we mostly ignored this store, but eventually we realized that it was an excellent resource. Usually for small to medium purchases, but they all.ost always have what we came in for. It is an excellent choice the day before s weather event, as it is less frenetic than other grocers in the area. The staff have always been efficient and pleasant.”

4.2 Good73 Reviews

“THE best store around. Although its been open for a little over a year, these people treat you like your family. Great prices on everything too. Considering they do have EVERYTHING...”

4.5 Superb28 Reviews