Grocery Stores near Old Bethpage, NY

30 locations found near Old Bethpage

“I live in the area for years and recently started shopping at Han's Natural Farm. I cannot say enough about the quality, freshness, and selection of their fruit. The staff is extremely friendly. I am in the store at least twice a week and highly recommend it!”

4.4 Superb24 Reviews

“Great choice of cooked foods. I especially enjoy the diced grilled chicken to mix with salads, add to sandwiches or warm up with potatoes or rice and vegetables. I put a little salad dressing on the grilled chicken to add flavor. The Turkey meatloaf dinner,stuffed cabbage and butternut squash with spinach and cranberries is quite delicious, too!”

4.2 Good204 Reviews

“The owners are wonderful people and they are like family to us at this point. Most convenient place to get last minute food items, high quality deli meats, and my go-to place to quickly exchange my propane tanks all year. Our family needs this place to stay.”

5 Superb113 Reviews

“I had the chicken shawarma. It was absolutely delicious! The portion size was big too. This is a must try! It was made fresh and quick! I will be back! I also catered Shabbat from here and it was delicious. The rib eye bowl was incredible so much flavor”

5 Superb185 Reviews

“Very well organized store you will never see anything missing of selfsame, meat section is always clean , I never had a issue with meat quality even though I am extremely picky on meat quality”

4.8 Superb72 Reviews

“My wife introduced me to the Forest Pork Store when we first started dating. I am a huge fan of the leberkase and the hockey pucks! Great stuff for picnics! We go for Thanksgiving, Christmas, select birthdays!

A big shout out to Ray and Kyle!”

4.8 Superb180 Reviews

“This place is amazing. Def a gem on Long Island for sure. Only issue I have is the hassle to get someone on the phone at times to place an order and there’s no system for online ordering or a number for the kitchen. Apart from that this place is great , staff is great , quality is great”

4.9 Superb56 Reviews

“Store is Awsome. I used to deliver to the store out of New Hampshire. It was my favorite stop. Mick and Tina are great people. Every year I would get one of their giant pumpkins. I miss them and hope they are doing well.”

4.8 Superb60 Reviews

“Lots of private labels - all at a great price point . As good if not better than national brands .
Wish it was closer to my home . Staff answered any and all questions completely . 5.16.26”

4.4 Superb299 Reviews

“This place is amazing. The owner and his family are kind, friendly people. All of the oils and balsamic’s are absolutely delicious. I have replaced my salad dressing with their flavored balsamics. All natural no toxic ingredients. If you haven’t tried it you need to. I drive 40 minutes just to come for my oils and balsamic.”

5 Superb63 Reviews

“One of the only Filipino markets on the Island, but yet prices are reasonable. Notably, they have a number of items you simply won't find at nearby hmart or the Chinese supermarkets in the area. Hot bbq and prepared food are decent. Customer service excellent.

Only problem is lack of parking - few spots available on the street in front of the place. Still, turnover is quick so you will not wait long for a spot.

Pro tip: I am originally from Jersey City and this place is the only market in the area I've seen that sources their pastries from Philippine Bread House in JC. Try the ensaymada.”

4.7 Superb112 Reviews

“Our cake was made identical to what we asked for, we could not be happier. Angela made the ordering process simple and she is so delightful. She made sure to make us a beautiful and delicious cake. It was a real hit at our party!”

4.4 Superb199 Reviews

“Food were pretty good in the food court. But I came when they are almost time to close. The staffs used their actions ,not words, to rush us. I tried to finished my food asap but the food was really hot, so I still told a while to finish my food. That was the only thing that bothered me.”

4.3 Superb353 Reviews

“Somewhat expensive prices, esp for brand names and healthy foods, but literally have EVERYTHING you can think of buying to cook and eat!!! I go esp around the holidays to get my traditional ingredients, never disappoints!”

4.3 Superb187 Reviews

“Took me back to the island. They all kinds of authentic home know brands and a wide variety specialty items. Everyone I interacted with was extremely courteous and cool. Stop by and enjoy the experience!”

4.4 Superb150 Reviews

“For the most part, really like this store. However they are a bit pricey The biggest criticism I have is the quality of their produce. Everytime I purchase their lettuce, cucumbers they inevitably go bad WITHIN A WEEK! I do not purchase produce from them anymore! Everything else is ok”

4.4 Superb186 Reviews

“halal meat which is fresh
Paan quality will remind you Karachi.
Burgers / catering and grocery items are really top notch.
Brother Shakil is a great guy at your service !
Worth visiting !”

4.6 Superb49 Reviews

“I love how friendly everyone is, the deserts are so good! I honestly think it’s the best Greek market on Long Island. Forgot to mention , they have amazing feta cheese ! I am getting hungry writing this !”

4.8 Superb73 Reviews

“As with most Trader Joe's, a happy shopping experience. Took a little one to the bathroom and found it scrupulously clean. With the LIDL, Wendy's , Taco Bell and Burger King adjacent, I recommend entering from eastbound Merrick Road and exiting via eastbound Merrick Road. The turn onto or off of westbound Merrick Road can be harrowing.”

4.3 Superb252 Reviews

“Anything and everything you could want or need at this tiny store that is CRAMMED to the ceilings with offerings from the greek islands! Friendly service anytime you go!”

4.7 Superb97 Reviews

“Many exclusive items from South America.
Lots of fruits, vegetables, fresh and frozen, spices, candy, all kinds of hard to find exclusive items from South America.”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“A lot of really good food. Prices are ok, lot of veggies and fruits. There is a fishmarket with fresh and good lookimg sea food. Everything looks clean and well arranged. Nice music in background.”

4.4 Superb112 Reviews

“I pass the store every time I come home. This past Tuesday I purchased a grab and go hanger steak dinner. To say it was out of this world is an understatement. I went back yesterday and they said it was a promotion and they’re not selling it anymore. I was so disappointed, but the staff is so accommodating and friendly and eager to help and Howard The manager said that they could make it for me, but I would have to wait and it was significantly more expensive so I chose to buy something else and it was just as good. Their bread is amazing and their customer service is exceptional.”

4.6 Superb39 Reviews

“Used the West Islip location to cater some of my Christmas Day offerings. The Teriyaki Skirt Steak was fantastic and abundant. Will definitely be using them again. Also, ordered the cranberry Walnut salad from them which exceeded expectations. Very happy that I decided to try them out, the service was great and the food was beyond what I was expecting in both quantity and quality.”

4.5 Superb69 Reviews

“This place is great! They have an incredible selection of health foods, supplements, and natural products. They have everything from organic produce and bulk grains to high-quality vitamins and essential oils.

The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and friendly. They took the time to answer all my questions and offer personalized recommendations based on my needs. I felt truly valued as a customer.

I highly recommend this shop to anyone looking for healthy and natural options. You won't be disappointed!”

4.6 Superb91 Reviews

“Mind-blowingly fresh seafood, every single time. It’s like the ocean moved into the grocery aisle. Perfect cuts, rich flavors, and service that makes you smile. A true hidden gem! ??✨”

4.4 Superb99 Reviews

“WOW that's awesome I love it very lucky I have a supermarket European and Americans notice great value good enough from examples to be used for Aldi supermarket about notice looking for them sometimes but Aldi has them lidl have a sometimes notice of chance of Glad!”

4.2 Good102 Reviews

“This is the best place in town their specials are the best in the area. Nothing compares to how clean this people are. Cashiers are so nice and helpful!btw I’m always there and have never seen any cops, nothing wrong with that but if you are afraid of the cops getting some water or snacks then you the problem.”

4.3 Superb120 Reviews

“I came to Whole Foods with my 92 year old mom and her aide for lunch a big selection of hot and cold food it cost me 45.00 half way through with our lunch a man passed the table and put fifty dollars on the table and said I bought you lunch shocked and thinking it was fake I never got to say THANK YOU he was out the door so if you ever read the reviews we appreciate your heartfelt generosity which gave us a warm positive feeling of hope entering the new year 2026.”

4.2 Good104 Reviews

“Nice place , very clean and organized. Prices are good, small store but well stocked with a variety of choices. The guy behind the register was very courteous. Overall a good place stop for Indian grocery before Hicksville. Oh and most important indian beers are there too!”

5 Superb19 Reviews

Related topics