Pet Stores near Port Jefferson Station, NY

“Always a good shopping experience! Great choices, good service, and usually quick in and out. Shout out to Ashley for taking my call and putting aside an item I needed until I got to store later in day.”

“Patty makes magic happen for our pup at Fetch. Whether we are here to buy dog food, a new toy, treats, or a gift for dog owner friends, we always find what we need and love chatting with Patty. So grateful to have this shop nearby!”

“This place is amazing people won't work there are super friendly and knowledgeable my dogs have so much more energy and are a lot of healthier since I've been giving them the raw food the owner is really amazing and sweet I am so happy with this place my dog's love it and love going there give it a try”

“So, this is a chain pet store, but I don't feel that they are created equal. There is a different feeling about this one in particular, as I have been to these stores upstate as well as through Suffolk County (particularly in Central Islip and Ronkonkoma). Firstly, the staff are awesome here - insanely helpful even when you don't ask, friendly if you bring a furry friend in, and lovely when they check you out. I am also constantly impressed by their stock - I believe the only time in recent memory that they were out of stock in something that I needed was walnut cat litter, but I chose a reasonable alternative. The store is always incredibly clean as well, and doesn't smell off like other Pet Supplies Plus do in the area. Tanks and cages for small animals never have debris or are in need of care. I enjoy shopping here and haven't been to Petsmart or Petco in years because of how much I love this store!”

“My dogs are the pickiest of picky when it comes to food but I went there today and just wow night and day my dogs are eating it and they are happy and I'm happy”

“i’ve bought all my fish and snails here since i moved to long island. run by very kind people. the store has a bit of an outdated look but the animals are well taken care of. a nice alternative to petco.”

“This is one of the best locations, the staff is always friendly and helpful. I have been bringing in my beagle for grooming monthly with the same groomer for years. Hannah is such a friendly and professional groomer. She has a way of calming her down for her bath and keeps me updated on how's she's doing. My dog always leaves her grooming appt smelling fresh and clean and sporting a new cute bandana. I highly recommend bringing your pets to their grooming services.”

“Stopped in for cat food one weekday evening.The store was clean and welcoming. It has automatic doors and is pet friendly.Plenty of parking.Also, has curbside pickup parking spaces.”

“I am giving them 4 1/2. Stars !!!!!!!!!! I have been in the store about 20 times since I adopted my Lab puppy in march of 23. Mostly because they have a large variety of dog products, food, bully sticks toys etc. . Their prices are a bit higher or equal to that of the chain stores. But they carry so many items in stock on their shelves it's worth it. Example! My pup is a chewer, loves bully sticks, they have them in all sizes, shapes imaginable including a three foot bully stick. You're lucky if you can find any in the big box stores without ordering on line. I mostly shop in the Selden store, and have been helped by many different employees, all of them have been extremely polite and courteous every time. Never had a problem with any of their employees. Just wanted to mention this because of all the negative reviews on their employees.”

“I adopted Molly from Long Island Feline Adoption Center in January 2023 and Im glad i did and its been nothing but joy and love ever since. Molly is my first cat and I definitely was a bit nervous as I only had dogs previously and I knew the breeds were definitely different. As soon as I arrived at Feline Adoption Center Cheryll took her time to get to know me and my living situation and what I was looking for and matched me with Molly. I came in on a Monday and visited every day that week and went home with Molly that Saturday. Molly is such a sweet, beautiful and well behaved cat. Im so lucky to have her and Im so thankful to Cheryll for matching us Molly is what was missing from my life. Molly is so comfortable in her new home and its only been 5 months and I know that love and joy is only going to continue to grow as I hope she lives a long & happy life. Thank you so much to Cheryll and Long Island Feline Adoption Center!!! You are the BEST!!”

“If you're a "bird person," you know that the number of parrot specialty stores in the NY metro area has decreased in recent years. Some places I had previously patronized for supplies, boarding, and grooming- like 33rd and Bird in Manhattan and For Birds Only in Mineola- have sadly closed, and, when taking my first extended trip in a while, I needed to find somewhere new for boarding. After speaking to Tom on the phone, I decided to take my bird to First Flight despite not having been there before and it being a bit out of the way for me. I am so glad I did. The store is well-organized, brightly lit, and so fresh and clean. Immediately upon entering his temporary cage my bird was totally at ease and eating like a pig-- and couldn't have cared less about saying goodbye to me. When I came back to collect him, I also had his nails and beak done, and the grooming was gentle and expertly executed. I am sort of hesitant to entrust my bird to others, to a degree that I have sometimes avoided traveling; but after seeing what a nice time he had at First Flight, I'm confident that I have a great boarding option for the future and look forward to more anxiety-free trips.”

“My first time there. I didn't eat or drink but I will next time. I loved the love music, the vendors, the atmosphere. The only negative thing I have to say is I took the shuttle to and from St. Joseph college and it was a terrible system. Not enough buses running and they need to do a better job organizing and scheduling. The security personnel had no radio contact with the drivers, or so they said. Only got to enjoy the event for one hour.”

“I’ve found my groomer for life! The service here is unmatched- so much so that when I pulled into the parking lot unable to find the location of the store, the owner stood by the door signaling me inside (haha)- he saw a woman with a Goldendoodle and knew it was him we were looking for!He offered great advice on nutrition and a couple of other pointers that would benefit our puppy. The groomer was understanding, she offered advice on how to better our Goldendoodles coat with out judgement and gave him his best groom yet! Don’t look any further for a groomer- this place deserves an award for most friendly, understanding and professional grooming in town! Thank you!”

“It's got what I need. I stop there for cat treats, love buy 3 get one free on temptations. I also have bought bearded dragon supplies and of course every kind of dog food, toys and treats. I like the Treats rewards too, though I wish they had non-purchase related ways to earn points. Pet Supplies Plus (Long Island area) let's you earn rewards points by watching videos and answering surveys, as well as purchases. Sometimes being involved with the company's app when no money is expected makes you feel more positively towards the brand and I wish PetSmart would adopt those marketing methods. Still, it's close to my house and PetSmart saves cats and holds dog adoption events. I really hope they stay in business. So many retail businesses are closing because of Amazon and I truly hope PetSmart does not close.”

“Love this place. Always a great selection of fresh water and salt water fish. Sometimes they don't have much inventory due to them being far east on Long Island. One of the best spots in all of NY for finding rare fresh water shrimp! Some coworkers are helpful and passionate at helping me find what I need. Would recommend this place to anyone. Work the drive.”

“Brought my kitten in for the first time and felt like a celebrity with all the customers flocking to meet my little one and I found everything I needed so it was wonderful”

“I was really Shocked , I heard their Radio Spot & took a chance , I'm a 1st time user & had Ordered online 4 Perscriptions for my Dog Louie after 7p.m. when they were Closed . To my Amazement i got them Delivered to me by 3p.m. the next Day & i live out in the Moriches . I am Blown away with these Folks & i saved about $30 on all 4 Meds . GREAT JOB PET DRUG STORE !!! Also Great Communication as they keep you a wear of the Order Status via E-mail .... What more can you Ask ? You a Customer for as long as Louie is still with us . Thank You & will call next month.”

“My collie was groomed there today first time visit. Lauren did a beautiful job and she smells wonderful. I will definitely come back and share the great news. Thank you.?”

“I have to be honest, when looking for a rehab I skipped this one because of the low stars. The one we picked was awful. I had to pull my father out. a friend then recommended Island. When I first walked in, it was 10pm. I noticed how absolutely clean the facility was. The staff was welcoming. They made my father feel so welcomed. Everyone is so nice. They communicate every aspect of my fathers care. The physical therapists are great. The bathrooms are clean and stocked. My father is a picky eater and they do not stop trying different food so that he eats. the nurses are awesome. I can't say enough how great they all are. Not one issue. The staff answers quickly to the call button. They make sure my father is comfortable. If you are looking for a rehab for a loved one, I strongly recommend Island.”

“My dog will only eat the dry food that is manufactured by Petco. Prior to finding the chicken and pea food of Petco my dog would always leave the cereal on the side of her bowl and just eat whatever soft food was given to her.”

“i just bought a tarantula here today and i had such a great experience! a very nice and funny lady, jackie helped me and she was so kind. she helped me get everything i needed and even recommended me many things. she helped me get a vet & helped me choose which food. & she did a spectacular job taking out the tarantula for me which can be very scary her and sam were great workers and they deserve a raise! thank you so much”