Gas Stations near Port Jefferson, NY

30 locations found near Port Jefferson

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 616 Main Street, Port Jefferson NY 11777

    3.2 Average 5 reviews

  2. 2950 Horseblock Road, Medford NY 11763

    4.5 Superb 160 reviews

    “I always get my gas at Sam's because it's super convenient. You just scan the QR code and pump your gas. No need to pull out any cards, it charges whatever card you have on file and emails a receipt. Their prices are lower than Costco and BJs , highly recommend!”

  3. 260 Echo Ave, Sound Beach NY 11789

    4.8 Superb 33 reviews

    “Stopped by on a Saturday around 9am to see if they had time to do a motorcycle inspection seeing my inspection was due, they told me to pull right up, they took time out of what they were doing to help me out. Good guys Derek and Craig, will be a returning customer”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 32 Briaroot Dr, Smithtown NY 11787

    5 Superb 13 reviews

    “He is very good, very reliable, flexible, responsive, good price. So why I replaced him? Just because Petro supply me not only with oil, but also with propane and boiler service, so I only need to deal with one supplier rather than 3. Otherwise I would stay with him forever. Very recomended”

  6. 285 Main St, Holbrook NY 11741

    4.5 Superb 53 reviews

    “I couldn't be happier with the service I received at this auto shop. From start to finish, the team was professional, honest, and incredibly skilled. They did an excellent job on my car — it runs better than ever! The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about doing things right. It's rare to find people who take such pride in their work, and it really shows here. If you're looking for a trustworthy, top-quality auto shop with the best people in the business, look no further. Highly recommended!”

  7. 1801 North Ocean Avenue, Medford NY 11763

    4.5 Superb 25 reviews

    “Best gas station experience ever! Gas is gas but I only use Mobil (which I find to be the least expensive). But, this Joe’s mart is great….good coffee, fancy machines for creamer/sugar/special coffee. Most especially, the nicest, kindest clerk with a fantastic smile, smiling eyes and great personality.”

  8. 3089 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.5 Superb 44 reviews

    “I dont want to write this review because its already getting very popular and busy. The best prices in town, no doubt. Same price cash or credit. Clean, and surprisingly easy to get in and out, considering the location. Thank you, owner of Conoco Hallock Ave. Your one of the best if not the best.”

  9. 435-A Smithtown Blvd, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    5 Superb 30 reviews

    “Excellent service! Had a crank sensor replaced almost a year ago and part failed again ( not their fault) they replaced it in 2 hours after dropping off fully covered under warranty.”

  10. 525 N Country Rd, St James NY 11780

    4.5 Superb 28 reviews

    “Experience professional knowledgeable car care when you bring your vehicle here. Steve is an master mechanic who can restore it to perfection My LX 470 purrs like new at 20 years old. Forgot bringing it to the dealer.”

  11. 240 W Main St, Smithtown NY 11787

    5 Superb 8 reviews

    “I like the fact that he charges the same price for cash and credit, something increasingly rare. Also, I don't like to use no-name brands in my car, so I like the idea of this being a well-respected brand.”

  12. 545 N Country Rd, St James NY 11780

    4.5 Superb 20 reviews

    “Searched out this place for ethanol free fuel for my snowblower. Having read on multiple snowblower forums, it's the fuel of choice. Arrived on a Saturday afternoon, the day before the big storm was to hit Long island, and the amount of people standing and waiting with their gas cans for this was insane. I asked the pump clerk is this a normal occurence and he said pretty much. Overall a cozy gas station, friendly staff and one of the only places on the north shore of Long Island that offers ethanol free fuel.”

  13. 322 Ronkonkoma Ave, Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    4.1 Good 85 reviews

    “We spent the day exploring the sites on the north shore of Long Island. On the way home, we stopped at this BP station/DD to get coffee and water. Good coffee and pleasant service.”

  14. 3173 NY-112, Medford NY 11763

    4.7 Superb 22 reviews

  15. 3003 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville NY 11738

    4.1 Good 75 reviews

    “Great place to use your gas points. It's an actual stop and shop gas station and their prices are very competitive even without using points. Last two times there I paid 0.599 and 0.899. If my tank is not very near empty I bring gas cans. Limit now is 20gals.”

  16. 255 Lake Ave, St James NY 11780

    4.6 Superb 19 reviews

    “New local father & son business. Very fast, decent prices, and good work! Mechanic is very knowledgeable and friendly. Would recommend to anyone in the Saint James area who needs quick and reliable work as it’s not usually busy. I believe this place is under new management so all older reviews are likely outdated and unrelated. I decided to try this place out for the first time as I live within walking distance. I have an older car (‘98 Mitsubishi Eclipse) and was having problems with a check engine light throwing a misfire code. I dropped it off at K D S on a Thursday around 4pm, and by 6pm I had gotten a call back regarding my car. The mechanic diagnosed my car completely free of charge and informed me the misfire was coming from a leak in my exhaust and not from the engine itself. We arranged to have him fix the problem the following day. He told me it would be $250 for the fix, and offered to include a tune up package (spark plugs, filters, etc.) for another $150 as well as an oil change for $75. While the oil change was a bit expensive the rest of the prices were reasonable enough for me. The next day I dropped my car off around noon. K D S closes at 7:00pm, but I wasn’t going to be back until 7:30. I informed the mechanic and he agreed to leave the key for me so I could grab the car after they closed. When I got there at 7:30, he was there still working on my car, and said he needed another 30 min. I came back once it was done, and he did not charge me anything more than the price we discussed even though it kept him there late. Have had no problems with the work he did and the car runs great. 10/10, would recommend.”

  17. 105 Main St, Stony Brook NY 11790

    4.6 Superb 17 reviews

    “I have been taking my car here for 6 years now. Brian Thomas and Little Brian are great at what they do and I've always been Fair with their prices. I have seen different makes and models of cars in The Bays doing various jobs. Pennies has always been trustworthy and reliable with my vehicles I highly recommend”

  18. 440 Hawkins Ave, Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    4.3 Superb 20 reviews

    “This gas station has everything you will need late at night. Cereal gallons of milk even soups. Open till around 12:30. Their prices are above-average but what do you expect a small business to do trying to survive in Suffolk county New York. They are privately owned small business, so stop by and give them your business. The guys that work there are very nice.”

  19. 90 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket NY 11733

    4.3 Superb 37 reviews

    “I stopped in one day because my tired pressure was very low. They helped me fill it with air and offered to check it out for me. No was pressed for time. I offered them money for their help but they refused. Two days later, I stopped in again because my pressure was low again. It was clear they were busy, but they checked out my tire and plugged a nail hole. I was so thankful. I didn't have any cash on me and they said I could bring it to them later. I COMPLETELY FORGOT! When I finally remembered, they were so gracious. I felt terrible and they were telling me not to worry.”

  20. 200 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station NY 11776

    4.3 Superb 23 reviews

    “Open 24 hours now. New updated gas pumps. Under new management. Great Customer Service. Lowest gas prices in town for diesel, gas, and E-85. Easy Enter and Exit for TRUCKS and BUSES. Nice big store with lotto, soda, beer, cigarette, coffee, and ice cream. Highly recommend. Friendly staff. A+”

  21. 2665 Medford Avenue Route 112, NY-112, Medford NY 11763

    4.7 Superb 15 reviews

    “Filled up and dropped some bills on the ground. The cashier came out and returned my money. I did not thank him enough. People surprise you and there is good out there.”

  22. 913 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    4.1 Good 20 reviews

    “One of the lower prices always if you prefer shell gas. Plus with their fuel rewards program everyday is 5 to 10 cents off depending on your gold or platinum status which is filling up 12 times for 19 gallons each fill in a 3 month period earns you platinum status 10 off each day. Many other discounts promotions and ways to earn off money per gallon. Highly recommend”

  23. 1740 Middle Country Rd, Centereach NY 11720

    4 Good 48 reviews

    “Always clean. I would have given 5 stars, but the pumps don't always give a receipt and then I have to go inside and stand on line to get it. Just a minor inconvenience. The staff is really nice, though. If they see me waiting, they ask which pump I used, and get the receipt for me.”

  24. 5477 Nesconset Hwy, Mt Sinai NY 11766

    3.9 Good 65 reviews

    “I have been coming to this Mobil location almost every single day because it is one of the closest gas stations right on my route. Over the years, I have probably stopped here hundreds of times, and I can honestly say I have never had a single issue. That level of consistency is rare. The pumps are reliable, the area is clean, and everything works the way it should. It is simple, efficient, and dependable, which is exactly what you want from a 24/7 gas station. The convenience store inside is also very well stocked. They have plenty of cold drinks, milk, snacks, coffee machines, sandwiches, and everyday grab and go items. They also have New York Lotto and a self serve machine, which makes it very convenient. It is easy to fuel up and quickly grab what you need in one stop. The staff and management are always friendly, polite, and helpful. Every interaction has been smooth and professional. If you are looking for a consistent, well run, and convenient gas station in the area, this is a solid choice. Five stars from me without hesitation.”

  25. 1164 Patchogue Rd Route 112, Port Jefferson Station NY 11776

    4 Good 36 reviews

    “I’ve been going here for my gas for 6 years now. I love its location, unlike no other. It’s next to my gym, it’s got the most pre workout drink selection from what I see. Shell gas is the best too I’ve heard. Great place to stop for gas, and many more!”

  26. 504 NY-111, Hauppauge NY 11788

    3.9 Good 58 reviews

    “Good gas station. Pretty good in and out access if you're on that side of 347. Very clean relatively decent prices. And most importantly the dude behind the register was actually friendly. That's a rare find on Long Island”

  27. 728 N Country Rd, Setauket- East Setauket NY 11733

    4 Good 44 reviews

    “Wow, what a wonderful experience. Grabbed a Mountain Dew and had a wonderful conversation with the tall Turkish man with blue eyes. I cant remember if his name was Goku or Gorkem. 10/10!”

  28. 1331 Motor Pkwy, Islandia NY 11749

    4.2 Good 25 reviews

    “Jimmy is the hardest working man I know, good honest prices & never forgets to ask how your days going always want to make your day a little better. If your in the area I recommend stopping in for all of your gas & convenience store needs!!”

  29. 1445 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station NY 11776

    4.4 Superb 24 reviews

    “JUST JOINED Speedway's rewards program. 7 cents off of every gallon of gas you buy. Can't go wrong. It's money in YOUR bank! And to the point of any 'bad' customer service reviews, I'm sure that kind of incident happened to you just once here. You've made your point, now maybe u can 'Let it Go.' The VERY pleasant experiences you'll have here will outweigh the very poor ones. By far. Give it another shot.”

  30. 5106 Express Dr S, Holbrook MA 11741

    4 Good 40 reviews

    “A super convenient spot as its just off exit 61. The place itself is small but it does have the necessities for most people needs. The person in the front was nice even with the fact that I tend to come up very early in the morning.”

  31. 2691 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.1 Good 21 reviews

Advertisement

Gas Stations in nearby cities

Related topics

  • Casey's Aims to Open at Least 400 New Stores Over Next Three Years

    The Iowa retailer, the third-largest convenience store operator in the country, built its new three-year plan around three priorities: store growth, food and beverage expansion, and kitchen technology upgrades. The company plans to add 120 stores during the current fiscal year. Its previous plan, launched in 2023, delivered more than 500 new stores and earned the company a spot in the S&P 500.

    Read the post
  • Love's Travel Stops Plans Big Growth and Store Updates in 2025

    Love's Travel Stops is starting 2025 with ambitious growth plans, adding 20 new stores and updating 50 current locations across the country. The truck stop company will upgrade its stores through its Strategic Remodel Initiative, which started in 2022. This includes the modernization of its recently acquired turnpike location in Stroud, Oklahoma. By 2035, over half of Love's 655 stores will be either new or updated.

    Read the post
  • How Buc-ee's Became a Roadtrip Destination Store

    Texas-born Buc-ee's is changing the way people think about gas stations and convenience stores. This chain is known for its huge stores along highways, some with over 100 fuel pumps. With its funny billboard ads, award-winning clean bathrooms, and branded items Buc-ee’s is hard to miss. The company wants people to actually plan to stop at Buc-ee's during road trips, not just go there as a last resort. And it's working - the chain has a huge fan base, with Facebook groups dedicated to Buc-ee's having hundreds of thousands of members.

    Read the post
  • Sheetz Wants to Expand in Detroit, but Not Everyone Agrees

    Sheetz Inc., the Pennsylvania-based convenience store chain, is making big moves in the Motor City. The company announced plans to open four more locations across metro Detroit, weeks before opening its first Michigan location. The first Michigan Sheetz will open its doors in late summer at 33380 Wick Road in Romulus. More locations are planned for Taylor, Warren, and Macomb Township, each employing around 30 people, mostly full-time.

    Read the post
  • Love's Travel Stops Brings Games to Work

    Love's Travel Stops is rolling out a new system that turns work into a game for its restaurant employees. Picture this: Three big screens in each restaurant, tracking how fast workers greet customers, take orders, and hand out food. It's not just for show - early results say it's making service 11 seconds faster on average. "These monitors track key performance metrics in real-time, such as greet times, order processing times and the time it takes for food handoff," Love's explains. The system creates a more interactive environment, fostering friendly competition between stores.

    Read the post