Gas Stations near Shelter Island Heights, NY

19 locations found near Shelter Island Heights

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 177 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island Heights NY 11965

    3.7 Good 3 reviews

    “I wanted to share my experience with Piccozzi's because I've had extensive dealings with them both professionally and personally over the years. They have consistently come through for me, communicated clearly, and conducted themselves in a professional manner. Honestly, I can't point to a single complaint. I also feel fortunate that we have a company like Piccozzi's on Shelter Island. Without them, those of us who live here or need services on the island would have a much more difficult time finding reliable support. They provide a valuable service to the community, and my experiences with them have always been positive.”

  2. 1 Bridge Street, Shelter Island Heights NY 11965

    3.4 Good 11 reviews

    “Easy to rent and return a bike. Bike was new and very comfortable for getting around the island. Staff was nice and super quick to get me setup. I liked being able to drop off the bike at the gas station since the shop was closed”

  3. 24375 Main Rd, Orient NY 11957

    5 Superb 67 reviews

    “Excellent and friendly service. We made it to the ferry on time just to realize we had a flat. Google closest repair shop and was greatly impressed by the service they provided. I mentioned we really needed to make that ferry. They had us in and out of there within minutes. Plugged tire and off we went.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 1100 Main Street Suite 2, Greenport NY 11944

    4.9 Superb 39 reviews

    “Had a rental, and a puncture. Trying to navigate Avis to try and get help was a nightmare. So gave up and looked for a local place that was open in Saturday. Got there explained the problem thinking maybe it's a slow leak and can return the car. He said, No fix it right away. And they did. Super quick. No fuss and really good price. Thank you”

  6. 32001 NY-25, Cutchogue NY 11935

    4.9 Superb 20 reviews

    “An magnificent full service gas station with delicious Latino food inside that’s made fresh. What a great combo !! Really good customer service at this gas station I highly recommend it. The employees are very nice and friendly.”

  7. 46155 County Rd 48, Southold NY 11971

    4.8 Superb 16 reviews

    “My parents have been customers of this company for many many years! My father has been in the hospital for quite a while so my mom has been the one taking care of everything, which is new for her. She wanted to b sure on how the propane system worked….A technician came to house to show her, which came with a cost…. Today, the company called to dismiss the cost, in consideration of my fathers health. We are so appreciative of their compassion for their customers. Highly recommend this agency to anyone! Thank you Van Duzer, for your service to my parents… Maldonado Family 🙏”

  8. 32001 Main Rd, Cutchogue NY 11935

    5 Superb 3 reviews

  9. 1100 Main St, Greenport NY 11944

    4.1 Good 20 reviews

    “A hidden gem!!!! Perfect location!!! Wonderful, friendly, helpful staff!!!! Clean and super comfortable!!! The view was amazing!!! What else can I say, except we absolutely loved this motel!”

  10. 28975 Main Rd, Cutchogue NY 11935

    4 Good 5 reviews

  11. 35 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island NY 11964

    3.8 Good 27 reviews

    “Why all the negative reviews! I’m astonished! New owners? It’s great now! Super yummy & well priced, get the spicy roast beef day, I promise you you won’t regret it”

  12. 3585 Youngs Avenue, Southold NY 11971

    3.7 Good 24 reviews

    “Coffee selection is INCREDIBLE!!! I only get their coffee and gas so that’s all I can speak for. Prices on items aren’t labeled so it’s inconsistent. It’s very clean inside and the employees are very nice! Parking gets crowded in the summer but the rest of the year it’s easy to park and can find an open pump. Try their coffee! It’s amazing”

  13. 49670 Main Rd, Southold NY 11971

    3.6 Good 15 reviews

    “I always stop at this gas station on my way back from out east on 51, they're literally the nicest gas station and they have an absolutely huge selection of everything you could ever need or want”

  14. 63 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island NY 11964

    3 Average 4 reviews

  15. 300 Front St, Greenport NY 11944

    3.4 Good 10 reviews

    “I buy the Sunday New York Times, Twix ice cream bars, other random items and sometimes gas here. The cashiers are always courteous and helpful and the place always seem to be open.”

  16. 144 Hampton Street, Sag Harbor NY 11963

    3.6 Good 50 reviews

    “The best gas station in the Hamptons! The employees are all very friendly and helpful with everything including filling tires with air. The store has a great selection too!”

  17. 74200 Main Rd, Greenport NY 11944

    3.2 Average 13 reviews

    “Greenport Tire at Empire Service station saved the day for us! While driving to the ferry at Orient Point, we hit some kind of sharp metal object on the road which caused an immediate flat tire. We were able to pull over and safely put on a spare and saw that Greenport Tire was just 1 mile away. We ventured over and spoke with the tire serviceman. He dropped what he was doing to help us. He inspected the damaged tire and felt it was repairable. After it was fixed and checked to see if it would hold pressure, he removed the spare and installed the repaired tire. We were back on the road in about 30 minutes. The charge was a modest $30, and we gave him a nice tip. We had a long drive back to NH, and I was relieved to do not have to do it on a spare tire. These guys saved our day#ThankYouThursday”

  18. 32400 Middle Road, Peconic NY 11958

    3 Average 15 reviews

  19. 378 Main St &, Brick Kiln Rd, Sag Harbor NY 11963

    3.2 Average 29 reviews

    “This place has gas so when you need gas go here to get gas. Old pumps of full service so stay in your car or go somewhere else if you're in a rush and like to pump your own gas.”

  20. 346 Montauk Highway, Wainscott NY 11975

    2.7 Average 38 reviews

    “ROBYN she is excellent and wonderful worker. She was nice and polite while I was shopping at this gas station. I can explain how she is very professional on helping me and the other customer before. I was impressed how she acting. I hope she get a raise and promotions.”

Advertisement

Gas Stations in nearby cities

Related topics

  • Casey's Aims to Open at Least 400 New Stores Over Next Three Years

    The Iowa retailer, the third-largest convenience store operator in the country, built its new three-year plan around three priorities: store growth, food and beverage expansion, and kitchen technology upgrades. The company plans to add 120 stores during the current fiscal year. Its previous plan, launched in 2023, delivered more than 500 new stores and earned the company a spot in the S&P 500.

    Read the post
  • Love's Travel Stops Plans Big Growth and Store Updates in 2025

    Love's Travel Stops is starting 2025 with ambitious growth plans, adding 20 new stores and updating 50 current locations across the country. The truck stop company will upgrade its stores through its Strategic Remodel Initiative, which started in 2022. This includes the modernization of its recently acquired turnpike location in Stroud, Oklahoma. By 2035, over half of Love's 655 stores will be either new or updated.

    Read the post
  • How Buc-ee's Became a Roadtrip Destination Store

    Texas-born Buc-ee's is changing the way people think about gas stations and convenience stores. This chain is known for its huge stores along highways, some with over 100 fuel pumps. With its funny billboard ads, award-winning clean bathrooms, and branded items Buc-ee’s is hard to miss. The company wants people to actually plan to stop at Buc-ee's during road trips, not just go there as a last resort. And it's working - the chain has a huge fan base, with Facebook groups dedicated to Buc-ee's having hundreds of thousands of members.

    Read the post
  • Sheetz Wants to Expand in Detroit, but Not Everyone Agrees

    Sheetz Inc., the Pennsylvania-based convenience store chain, is making big moves in the Motor City. The company announced plans to open four more locations across metro Detroit, weeks before opening its first Michigan location. The first Michigan Sheetz will open its doors in late summer at 33380 Wick Road in Romulus. More locations are planned for Taylor, Warren, and Macomb Township, each employing around 30 people, mostly full-time.

    Read the post
  • Love's Travel Stops Brings Games to Work

    Love's Travel Stops is rolling out a new system that turns work into a game for its restaurant employees. Picture this: Three big screens in each restaurant, tracking how fast workers greet customers, take orders, and hand out food. It's not just for show - early results say it's making service 11 seconds faster on average. "These monitors track key performance metrics in real-time, such as greet times, order processing times and the time it takes for food handoff," Love's explains. The system creates a more interactive environment, fostering friendly competition between stores.

    Read the post