Gas Stations near Shelter Island Heights, NY

22 locations found near Shelter Island Heights
View Map

“My new go-to place after my last mechanic said I needed all kinds of work that was confirmed as not needed. Professional and friendly staff who have the knowledge to fix any car problem.”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

“This man saved my car, my dog and my life. George not only got the car going, he supplied water and treats to my dog and fed me a buttered roll.Service: Electrical repair”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“An magnificent full service gas station with delicious Latino food inside that’s made fresh. What a great combo !! Really good customer service at this gas station I highly recommend it. The employees are very nice and friendly.”

4.8 Superb20 Reviews

“Van Duzer has been providing propane to my home in Mattituck since 1984. Mark the manager promptly returned my call and solved my question. Outstanding customer service ( Geri and Mary office staff included!)Happy Customer!”

4.7 Superb10 Reviews

“Title: "More Than Just a Gas Station - Gulf in Sag Harbor, NY"I can't say enough good things about Gulf in Sag Harbor, NY. While it may appear to be your average gas station from the outside, it's the incredible staff that sets this place apart. Over time, they've become like close friends to me, making every visit a delightful experience.From the moment I pull in, I'm greeted with warm smiles and a genuine willingness to help. The staff here goes above and beyond to ensure that customers not only get the fuel they need but also feel welcomed and appreciated. It's that personal touch that keeps me coming back.Aside from the exceptional service, Gulf offers competitive fuel prices and a convenient location in the heart of Sag Harbor. Whether you're a local resident or just passing through, this is the kind of place you'll want to stop at. Plus, they often have clean restrooms, which is an added bonus during road trips!But it's truly the staff that makes Gulf special. They remember your name, your preferences, and they take the time to chat and build a connection. It's this level of customer care that transforms a routine pit stop into a memorable experience.If you're in Sag Harbor, NY, don't think of Gulf as just your average gas station. Think of it as a place where you'll find fuel for your car and friendship for your soul. I can't recommend it enough.”

4.1 Good40 Reviews

“Great little store for a quick stop for a morning coffee and small gear items if you are going to spend the day on the boat. Easy location to fuel up your boat when trailered over to Klipps Marine Park boat ramp.”

4.7 Superb3 Reviews

“A hidden gem!!!! Perfect location!!! Wonderful, friendly, helpful staff!!!! Clean and super comfortable!!! The view was amazing!!! What else can I say, except we absolutely loved this motel!”

4 Good22 Reviews

“I buy the Sunday New York Times, Twix ice cream bars, other random items and sometimes gas here. The cashiers are always courteous and helpful and the place always seem to be open.”

3.6 Good11 Reviews

“Greenport Tire at Empire Service station saved the day for us! While driving to the ferry at Orient Point, we hit some kind of sharp metal object on the road which caused an immediate flat tire. We were able to pull over and safely put on a spare and saw that Greenport Tire was just 1 mile away. We ventured over and spoke with the tire serviceman. He dropped what he was doing to help us. He inspected the damaged tire and felt it was repairable. After it was fixed and checked to see if it would hold pressure, he removed the spare and installed the repaired tire. We were back on the road in about 30 minutes. The charge was a modest $30, and we gave him a nice tip. We had a long drive back to NH, and I was relieved to do not have to do it on a spare tire. These guys saved our day#ThankYouThursday”

3.6 Good16 Reviews

“This place has gas so when you need gas go here to get gas. Old pumps of full service so stay in your car or go somewhere else if you're in a rush and like to pump your own gas.”

1.8 Poor5 Reviews