Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

“Wow, I wish I could rate this place a perfect 10 stars! We had an absolutely fabulous time. The hosts were incredible; they made us feel incredibly cozy and at home. They went above and beyond to make our stay feel special, and I felt like I was in a family’s home. The location is also fantastic.”

“My husband and I had our wedding here last September. We had the best weather and views - our family and friends are still talking about it. Sherri was nothing but helpful. She went above and beyond what she originally told us would be her roll in the whole thing and she definitely took a lot of stress off of us. The grounds are a blank canvas for whatever style wedding you are going for but your back drop will without a doubt be breath taking for your ceremony and or reception. It was the first venue we visited in the beginning stages of planning and we knew right away we didn't need to look at any others. We kept our boat at their dock that weekend and left on it Sunday afternoon. Many of us stayed the whole weekend; the rooms and views were dreamy I would love to stay there again.”

“Amazing place, great bar and rooms were clean and comfortable. Pillows on the bed were amazing, I have never had a better night sleep in a bed that wasn’t my own!! The ladies at the front desk were so sweet and accommodating, they actually upgraded us for free. There was a pool and a nice patio in the back (that we discovered as we were leaving!). We stopped by the bar both nights we stayed there and had the best French fries - super thin and crispy. Ended up chatting with a few friendly locals who made the hotel even more charming…always a good sign when you know it’s a regular spot!! ? all and all, can’t speak highly enough about this charming inn.”