Hotels near Sag Harbor, NY

17 locations found near Sag Harbor

“We liked the town of Sag Harbor. We had dinner at The American Hotel many times. The food was excellent and the wait staff were friendly. We also like the Whaler Museum. Taking the family boat around Shelter Island and many other fun activities in Sag Harbor. We also knew many of the neighbors in our villa community.”

4.2 Good292 Reviews

“Bridgehampton Inn restaurant is a great place to take a friend for a special event. The ambience is cozy and sophisticated at the same time, the food is high quality but also not an arm and a leg' expensive -specially with amazing prefix dinner' and the staff is friendly, experienced and fun.”

4.7 Superb238 Reviews

“Wonderful property- rooms are large and clean and lovely. They have thought of everything- small amenities that make a difference. Cold filtered water provided in the room and around the property. Beach tote bag with towels provided in the room. Extra towels at the beach front. Beach lounge chairs with attached shade. Robes/slippers. Universal chargers beside. The staff is terrific- friendly and easy and knowledgeable. Dave provided dinner recommendations, was attentive- comped us a glass of wine when we had to wait a bit for our room. Absolutely recommend and will definitely return.”

4.9 Superb81 Reviews

“Modern, perfect location, meticulously clean. Great attentive staff. The only thing I wish they would add would be some fresh fruit for breakfast and snacks.
It was a perfect stay.”

4.8 Superb106 Reviews

“Stayed for a long weekend break. It was great. Very peaceful with an excellent host, lovely room, wonderful breakfast and a gorgeous dog called Peaches who we loved spending time with. Can fully understand why they have many repeat visitors, we will certainly be backRooms: Well appointed, plenty of towels etc.”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“Best place to stay on the East End!!! The pool is beautiful and so are the grounds. The front desk is very helpful and friendly and the room had everything we needed. Great location!!!”

4.4 Superb94 Reviews

“Amazing place, great bar and rooms were clean and comfortable. Pillows on the bed were amazing, I have never had a better night sleep in a bed that wasn’t my own!! The ladies at the front desk were so sweet and accommodating, they actually upgraded us for free. There was a pool and a nice patio in the back (that we discovered as we were leaving!). We stopped by the bar both nights we stayed there and had the best French fries - super thin and crispy. Ended up chatting with a few friendly locals who made the hotel even more charming…always a good sign when you know it’s a regular spot!! ? all and all, can’t speak highly enough about this charming inn.”

4.6 Superb70 Reviews

“My husband and I stayed at the Tapestry House for a wedding weekend in September. It was a truly wonderful and unique visit. The inn is beautiful–furnishings and details are perfect. Breakfasts were delicious and plentiful. Joan made us feel so welcomed. It was a memorable stay, and we hope to return!”

4.8 Superb21 Reviews

“A little pricy - but an absolutely amazing experience. Lovely and helpful staff, great rooms, amazing location - the view from the pool area is unrivaled.
Has the feel of being a guest in a lavish country estate by the water.
Good with families.”

4.2 Good154 Reviews

“We had a great stay....walked to restaurants and downtown. Kenny, the manager there was so gracious and welcoming in helping me with our reservation after I messed up online. Kelly and Dawn were such friendly hosts and so accommodating. The whole staff made us feel welcome and pampered. The chef prepared exquisite breakfasts, which we are still talking about. What a great experience, and we can't wait to go back again!! Thanks all for making our 25th anniversary celebration one we will always remember!!”

4.4 Superb49 Reviews

“Stayed at the Topping Rose during a summer weekend. Great service, great food, amazing property.

Our room was good, but looked a bit dated, which didnt ruin our stay.

I would highly recommend for a cozy stay near everything Sagharbor and Bridgehampton offers.”

4.1 Good262 Reviews

“I planned on staying one night but ended up staying an additional night. I really liked this place and the staff working here were very kind and helpful. The room was clean and comfortable and parking was easy. I would like to come back in the summer to use the pool. Bbqs are available on the patio as well and there is a large green lawn area. It’s a smaller property but I appreciated that. A quick drive to the beach and town and during the summer you could easily ride a bike to the beach.”

3.8 Good38 Reviews

“my wife and I try to stay at the Blue Inn every July for abour six or seven nights. Housekeeping is excellent, grounds are well kept, pool is immaculate. Management always makes you feel at home and welcome. Try it and you will return.”

2.2 Poor55 Reviews

“we come by boat every year by boat for a couple of nights location is fabulous. Property is beautiful staffing owners very accommodating. Our bonus was concert on the lawn right behind our boat on Tuesday night. We had a wonderful time as always highly recommended.”

3.7 Good56 Reviews

“It is on the high way and BEWARE the club scene is loud but that's why people come here, to party and then sleep it off in a nearby room. Super friendly service, great atmosphere”

3.8 Good207 Reviews

“I stopped by the Harbor Front to meet a friend for a drink. Wow, the lobby is beautiful. The design and the colours used are elegant but still fresh and inviting, accenting the really lovely details of the bar and the fireplace. This place definitely ups the game on Front Street.”

3.7 Good71 Reviews

“I was sceptical after reading the reviews. BUT, new owners and managers turned it to a stunning top star Hotel. Rooms are tiny, yes, but gorgeous. The service is outstanding. So much detail to high quality products like GHD hair dryer and Steamer in every room. Wonderfully smelling bath products, the food, 5 stars. Can highly recommend. And a Gucci Airstream with FREE coffee. Wow! Just incredible.”

3.3 Good228 Reviews