Hotels near Sag Harbor, NY
21 locations found near Sag Harbor
View MapOpen 24 hours
31 W Water St, Sag Harbor
Hotels
10:00 AM - 4:00 PM
7 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island Heights
Hotels
“Our second time staying at Seven and we can say there will be many more! It is a fantastic B&B on the island and a great location to walk to the beach and restaurants close by. The breakfast spread is fantastic and you really are made to feel this is a home away from home when staying!”
Hotels
“Exceptional culinary experience at the Bridgehampton Restaurant! Everything was delicious and on point including the drinks! Much thanks and respect to Kyle, the commander & chief of spirit mixology! The service here was very professional and the attention to detail from the drinks to the food was outstanding, which lead to a very memorable experience. Highly recommend this gem while visiting Long Island. I loved the decor and ambiance of this historical building. It felt like you were traveling back in time. Looking forward to bringing the entire family next time! Thank you again for everything. Best regards?”
5:30 - 9:30PM
143 Main St, East Hampton
Hotels
“Ate there only...priced as expected.Food & drinks: My partner found that a good fish wasn't well served w/a sauce of lobster.. (sometimes simple rings the bell!) Sadly nothing vegetarian or gluten-free offered - (mashed potatoes a bit watery?) Creme brule cinnamon-y?? We ate in the downstairs bar - described by true friends as 'cosy'... the service was perfect! It's always full it seems so res a good idea.”
Open 24 hours
503 Front St, Greenport
Hotels
“I recently stayed at the Tapestry House for a girls overnight and thoroughly enjoyed my stay. Our host Joan, was lovely and extremely accommodating! The decor was beautiful and the house felt very welcoming. We really enjoyed sitting out on the front wrap around porch by the fire feature at night and while having breakfast. I’ll definitely be back!!Walkability: Many shops and restaurants in close proximity.Noteworthy details: Stunning trim work in every room. Beautiful high ceilings and lots of original details. Beautiful flowers adorn the porch.”
Hotels
“The Reform Club is the perfect place to celebrate a wedding!As a groomsman in a recent wedding at the Reform Club I can honestly say that it's the perfect place to celebrate a wedding. The grounds are absolutely stunning, with lush lawns, gardens, and a charming apple orchard. The staff is incredibly attentive and helpful, and they went above and beyond to make the day special for everyone involved.I was particularly impressed with the guest rooms at the Reform Club. They were spacious, well-appointed, and very comfortable. I had a great night's sleep, which is important after a long day of celebrating.I highly recommend the Reform Club to anyone looking for a beautiful and unique wedding venue in the Hamptons. It's the perfect place to create lasting memories with your loved ones.Lastly the grounds are perfect for taking photos. There are so many beautiful spots to choose from, so we were able to get a variety of great shots especially in front of the light house.Overall, I was very impressed with the Reform Club. I highly recommend the Reform Club to anyone looking for a beautiful and unique wedding venue in the Hamptons, where you and your guests can enjoy a relaxing and memorable stay.”
8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
207 Front St, Greenport
Hotels
“Mario and his team at The Menhaden are top notch. This was our second stay at The Menhaden and we have already started planning our return. The Galley areas on each floor are fully stocked with all you may need or want while relaxing on vacation. Who wouldn’t want to wake up to fresh baked croissants or grab a homemade chocolate chip cookie after dinner? And if you need anything else, the General Store has you covered. Upon our return from dinner, Felicia mixed us up a specialty cocktail and we enjoyed closing the night out in the private guest lounge. If you’re contemplating a trip to the North Fork, the Menhaden should be your first choice for accommodations. Tell ‘em Nino sent you!Rooms: Extremely clean, spacious, and comfortable.Walkability: Walkable to all that downtown Greenport has to offer.Food & drinks: Complimentary food and drink, including fresh baked croissants and cookies. Specialty cocktails and local beer and wine. Gourmet coffee available in the General Store.”
Open 24 hours
31 N Main St, East Hampton
Hotels
“I have traveled the world and stayed at thousands of beautiful hotels, resorts and even Palaces … the hospitality and warmth I experienced at Mill House Inn was special!I am not given to hyperbolic statements … but this place is a treasure! No matter what you need or ask they are there to serve and are so helpful … they know the Hamptons it’s traffic , it beat beaches … it spots for sun set or sun rise! The rooms are cute and very very clean !The food is great !Thank you Mill House Inn for being my home away from home !”
Hotels
“Gorgeous accommodations. So pretty, clean, nice pool and seating area. Complimentary coffee station in lobby (with actual good coffee!). Friendly staff! Loved it! Highly recommend staying here.”
Hotels
“My husband and I had our wedding here last September. We had the best weather and views - our family and friends are still talking about it. Sherri was nothing but helpful. She went above and beyond what she originally told us would be her roll in the whole thing and she definitely took a lot of stress off of us. The grounds are a blank canvas for whatever style wedding you are going for but your back drop will without a doubt be breath taking for your ceremony and or reception. It was the first venue we visited in the beginning stages of planning and we knew right away we didn't need to look at any others. We kept our boat at their dock that weekend and left on it Sunday afternoon. Many of us stayed the whole weekend; the rooms and views were dreamy I would love to stay there again.”
Hotels
Hotels
“Brian Arm is very professional, attentive, and kind. He provided me with great care and I did not feel rushed during my visit. The staff are all very sweet and the office is clean.”
9:00 AM - 11:00 PM
226 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton
Hotels
“We had a fantastic stay and can't recommend it enough. The location is PERFECT - in a beautiful peaceful setting - half a mile from the village. The rooms were immaculate, bright and nicely appointed. Pool was a bonus and a hit. The grounds were spacious. It's extremely family friendly. Loved all the amenities. We had a wonderful time and look forward to our return.”
7:00 AM - 9:30 PM
1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton
Hotels
“We recently had a girls weekend in SH and had the most amazing dinner (all 8 of us) and our waiter Chris was the MOST amazing part. He went above and beyond to make sure our drinks were full along with our bellies. He would show up to our table with something that we were about to ask for ! It’s like he read our god damn minds. If you’re lucky enough to be graced by his presence consider yourselves BLESSED. We love you Chris !!!!!!!!!! Get the caviar!!!!!!!!Noteworthy details: Chris = the best”
7:00 AM - 11:00 PM
326 Front St, Greenport
Hotels
“The staff here go above and beyond to cater to their guests. The staff makes you feel like family and it’s a special place. The rooms are spacious and well thought out and very conveniently located. I can’t wait to stay here again.”
9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
7850 Main Rd, East Marion
Hotels
“Absolutely lovely stay over Labor Day weekend with friends. We reserved a two bedroom suite that comfortably slept 5 of us and we were able to bring along our puppy! Breakfast was provided every morning including delicious donuts. The room, pool and grounds were very clean and well kept. The nearby beaches were lovely. We especially enjoyed spending time at the wineries and in the town of Greenport, which was only 5 minutes away by car. Lots of great restaurants and shops to explore and the views from the harbor were amazing!! Will definitely be back, thank you for a fantastic end-of-summer weekend!!”
Open 24 hours
209 Front St, Greenport
Hotels
“Wonderful little spot in Greenport. Amazing location, beautiful clean and up to date rooms. The staff was incredibly kind and helpful - would definitely come back!”
Open 24 hours
207 Main St, East Hampton
Hotels
“We had an absolutely wonderful stay. The hotel is under new management and they are doing a great job! The staff very accommodating and friendly. They are also very dog friendly a must for us. Everything was terrific from the Continental breakfast complete with fresh berries and Goldbergs bagels that were often warm when they arrived, to the bikes and beach umbrellas and chairs. we also loved sitting on the front lawn watching the world go by having coffee, reading the papers or having a cocktail.”
9:00 AM - 10:00 PM
714 Main St, Greenport
Hotels
“we come by boat every year by boat for a couple of nights location is fabulous. Property is beautiful staffing owners very accommodating. Our bonus was concert on the lawn right behind our boat on Tuesday night. We had a wonderful time as always highly recommended.”
Hotels
“The place to be in the Hamptons! We film here every single summer and the owners and managers are amazing, courteous, and accommodating. We look forward to 2024!”
Hotels
“We've been to Sunset Beach many times over the years. But this is the first time we stayed at the hotel.Amazingly bright and spacious rooms with balconies.Great place to enjoy good drinks, food and just relax.Definitely the most vibes on Shelter Island.”
“We had dinner at Barons Cove last Saturday, and it was quite enjoyable. Our party of 7 was comfortably seated upstairs, where we enjoyed pre-dinner cocktails. The service was on point and attentive. We had several entrees, including the special ribs, salmon, and steak. All were very well prepared and tasty. The chowder was also very good.”