The Diamond Cellar is a family-owned jewelry store in Columbus, Ohio, that has been serving customers since 1947. Specializing in engagement rings, luxury watches, and designer jewelry, the store is known for its personalized service and talented, highly trained staff. The Diamond Cellar's roots are in the goldsmith trade, and they manufacture much of their own jewelry on-site, using the best materials and craftsmanship. Customers can work with the store's experts to design custom pieces, from setting an engagement diamond to a full-blown custom design, without their jewelry ever leaving the store. Reviewers consistently praise the enjoyable and stress-free experience at the Diamond Cellar, particularly when working with staff members like Mike DiCello and Marcie. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable guidance, patience, and lack of pressure, as well as the store's ability to bring their visions to life. Whether it's selecting a special piece for a birthday or anniversary, or exploring the store's collection of watches and jewelry, shoppers always feel welcomed and valued at the Diamond Cellar.
Don was very helpful in showing me some of the latest Rolex models, including the pictured ombre green Datejust. I very much enjoyed experiencing the pieces in the metal!
July 2026
I recently had the opportunity to work with Daniel Gordon and his prote'ge', Cassadi. The experience was top notch from the time I walked in the door. They took time to understand what I was looking for and went above and beyond to accomodate the sale. Highly recommend this duo.
June 2026
Gracious and informative meeting with Mike DiCello.
