Pet Supplies Plus New Albany is a neighborhood pet store with everything you need for furry, scaly and feathery friends. The store is well stocked, well organized and clean with a wide selection of natural and made in USA products. Friendly staff are always willing to help, very knowledgeable and super nice when conversations strike up about pets. They have great selection of dog food and the best cow bones for a bug dog like ours. The store has free curbside pickup, same‑day delivery and easy online shop. Parking is ample, bathrooms are clean and the store is easy to spot from the street. Pricing is competitive and the shop is a trusted place to shop for pet's needs.
They always have what we need for our pets although I wish their hours weren't so limited!
May 2026
Absolutely fantastic! So helpful and understanding. Check out was quick and the manager was nice.
May 2026
This is your best overall pet store. I've been to all of them on the East northeast side Easton area Hamilton road Morse road etc etc go here they will have what you want. Say hello to Dylan for me he helps me every time with my fish. I drive him crazy but he is very patient with me. Prices are very reasonable
