Hotels near Kelleys Island, OH

9 locations found near Kelleys Island
View Map

“First time renting. New owners. A little clunky to book but they will work it out. On site staff great. Loved the location and pool. Quite hours at 10 PMNearby activities: This on kelleys Island a little more quite than south bass. Glacier groves are a must see. Good restaurant and a couple of wineries. Not much else”

3.5 Good33 Reviews

“Wonderful accommodations at a lovely inn. My husband and I frequently stay at Inns when we travel and loved our stay at the Red Fern Inn’s Bay Point Room. Great view of the lake, clean and comfortable!”

5 Superb42 Reviews

“Beautiful 100+ year old lake front hotel. Perfect getaway from bustle of. Modern times. Modern comfortable bed, nice new bath. Fun antiquities all over. Mary Jo left us beautiful flowers for our anniversary celebration. Thanks we will be ”

4.3 Superb54 Reviews

“Marie was awesome, making our check in wonderful. Beautiful room, great location, and a decent price. This will be our go-to going forward.One recommendation: Bring pillows, they provide ones with a plastic inner liner, which reflect heat. <- This is a very minor issue, but worth noting.Rooms: Large clean roomsNearby activities: Tiki bar 50 foot from the front doorWalkability: It is just off the stripFood & drinks: The bartenders/servers were super friendly and attentive.”

4.5 Superb27 Reviews

“All in all it's a pretty cozy hotel and walk time to CP is pretty short. The restaurants inside are expensive. You can have Dominoes pizza delivery directly to your room, also expensive.”

3.8 Good137 Reviews

“The location is not bad plenty around to do and eat. The community fire pits and the pool and volleyball are nice. Love that it's dog friendly most places are not and the fee for your pup is reasonable. $10 per night under 40 lbs. , and $20 per night over 40lbs. Much cheaper than boarding and safer too. My only complaint is the beds are so uncomfortable. And the one bedroom we had the paint was coming off the paneling. That should have been corrected when housekeeping saw it. The couch was more comfortable than the beds. But for what it's worth it is a great place to stay.”

3 Average47 Reviews

“This was our second time at the commodore and we will be coming back! I suggest the pool view rooms. We had a slight issue with our room and Kelley was super accommodating and helped us out and gave us great reccomendations about things to do. Rooms are great rates and the best location on the island. Easy access to late night food. I will say if you’re looking for a quiet secluded place to stay, this might not be for you, but we come here for the fun atmosphere and this place puts you right in the middle of the action.”

2.3 Poor47 Reviews

“The location is the best! Right on the lake - great view of the lake from the tiny restaurant or from the outside patio. The staff was friendly and very accommodating. The pool was small and need skimming, but otherwise nice. The room, however, left a little to be desired. The major issue was that the room had a very pronounced mildew smell. We were on the first floor, which was a good thing, because the elevator to the other floors was broken. That being said, we will definitely be back. The staff and the location made up for the other inconveniences.”

0 Na0 Reviews