Thrift Stores near Pickerington, OH

14 locations found near Pickerington

“Easy drop off and clearance is high enough for my enclosed trailer!
Some prices could be a little lower, but not bad if you need stuff!
Dropped off a lot of kids toys and housewares hopefully someone will get some use out of!”

4 Good111 Reviews

“When my mom was near by goodwill she would sometimes pop by to get her some things. In 2019 this place was booming. People everywhere. Good and better toys. Bags. The place does not have any custom bags the last time i have been here so you would have to get your own if you wanted lost of things.”

2.9 Average69 Reviews

“Stopped in to look around. Clean. Neatly stocked items. Bit pricey, but tags are marked with stamped-on color marks to indicate what % is off. No large signage, but lovely surprise to have 80% discount at check out.”

4.1 Good187 Reviews

“Clean store. Extremely reasonably priced. I bought a very nice, extremely good condition fridge for $125. They had checked it already, and it came with a 30 money back guarantee. I always find nice things here!”

4.6 Superb35 Reviews

“I do really like this location BUT I did remove 1 star simply because they don't have a public access bathroom. So take that into account if you have any condition that may require access to a bathroom and plan accordingly.”

4.2 Good122 Reviews

“I've been to a lot of thrift stores across the country. This location is now my favorite in the Columbus area. The store is extremely well organized, super clean and all the employees that I interacted with were very pleasant and helpful. 10/10 would shop there again and again!”

3.8 Good109 Reviews

“Lovely place to shop, the ladies working are so kind and helpful. I struggled with a dress, unsure of the look, but the ladies gave me the confidence! Styling, and everything. Prices are very decent for their selection, very reasonable.”

4 Good28 Reviews

“I love this place. You never know what you're going to find and the prices are awesome. Got a vintage Colman stove today for $3.99. wow!! I spend hours in here every time I come. Stop and check them out. You wont be sorry.

This place is the best way of finding whatever you are looking for and even stuff you never knew you wanted. Check them out. Always fast friendly service”

3.8 Good57 Reviews

“Large selection. Many new items also, some of which seem to be clearance items from Target. It’s not always clear if the prices on clearance items are better than what you would get at the original source.

Lots of jeans. Good amount of glassware. I found some used items to be out of the range I am willing to pay (like $9 for a vinyl music album set).some winter coats had decent prices, while others seemed quite high (like someone on the staff is pricing items by Googling what the “vintage resale” value would be, which seems to not be the true spirit of second hand stores.

With a visit nonetheless, as there are some good bargains to be had. There is a separate small room with some good items in the back, just before the restroom.”

3.7 Good106 Reviews

“I spent an hour here and left with 5 pieces! The store is nicely organized making it easy to sort through. Prices were fair and if you find items on sale, it’s a steal. The employee running the store was sweet and helpful.”

3.5 Good81 Reviews

“The ultimate thrifting experience! Everything you could ever want from a thrift store from in-demand electronics to top-shelf brand name clothing, they have it all (at insanely cheap prices!). On my last visit, I got a $100+ hoverboard for $24! Go there, you will NOT be disappointed!”

3.2 Average80 Reviews

“I've gotten a lot of great stuff from the bins for real cheap. It's an experience. You gotta wear gloves and be able to tolerate a certain level of gross, but spend a few hours there and you will be dressing to the nines!”

3.3 Good149 Reviews

“This was a pretty nice Goodwill. Some things were higher in price than what should have been, but overall a good shopping visit. I did find two pairs of shoes that I've paid substantially more for in the past so that was a big win!”

3 Average65 Reviews

“Great deals and friendly employees, my only complaint is that a lot of the food was past it's expiration date. Not only that but the skincare face masks were also expired by nearly two years, which could have caused major breakouts. Other than that a pretty decent shopping experience.”

3 Average71 Reviews