Thrift Stores near Pickerington, OH

14 locations found near Pickerington
View Map

“I absolutely love this store! Very well organized and they always have a great selection. They have some really great employees there too. I was super excited to see that Tammy was back!! That girl is always in a great mood, always happy to help and usually has a compliment or a joke to brighten my day. She's the best!!”

3.8 Good22 Reviews

“When my mom was near by goodwill she would sometimes pop by to get her some things. In 2019 this place was booming. People everywhere. Good and better toys. Bags. The place does not have any custom bags the last time i have been here so you would have to get your own if you wanted lost of things.”

2.9 Average23 Reviews

“Nice employees good selection of items especially active wear. Just wish they had restroom and fitting room in store. Great prices for quality of clothes and often have new overstock items from Target. Favorite local thrift store!”

4.5 Superb21 Reviews

“Clean store. Extremely reasonably priced. I bought a very nice, extremely good condition fridge for $125. They had checked it already, and it came with a 30 money back guarantee. I always find nice things here!”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“I love this store. I travel 2 hours one way from southern Ohio to shop here 4 times a year. The prices are awesome but have gone up just a little bit since covid, but overall you can shop and save a lot of money here. Lots of good selection of name brand clothing for the whole family. Thanks Volunteer of America. See you soon.”

4.2 Good56 Reviews

“Re: the “no cell phone use”, I love it!! I used to work retail and when the customer was on the phone while trying to pay it was awful!! It’s rude!! And some people talk as if they were home!! Loud and I don’t care to hear your conversation!!!!!”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Pricing and customer service, very nice....location nice. Selection was very nice. I like how the store and bathroom was clean. Made it much easier and comfortable to shop.”

3.8 Good20 Reviews

“Wednesday's people 55+ get 25% off ,excluding white tag items. The bad: in the smaller size for a thrift store, no children's grab bags of play jewelry/small toys.”

3.7 Good53 Reviews

“tiffany is an amazing cashier. she always wraps my glassware carefully with great care. i always apologize for her having to do so and she’s very kind about it.”

3.5 Good23 Reviews

“Found the cutest winter outfit for great price! My daughter found 2 pairs of shoes that she wasn't even looking for!The employees were helpful in every way possible!”

3.6 Good90 Reviews

“staff is ALWAYS friendly and they have such a great selection! very clean as well! easily my favorite goodwill to go thrifting at!! couldn't recommend it enough!”

3.5 Good36 Reviews

“Very interesting Goodwill! You have one side where you can search through blue bins. A lot of resellers come here. They have anything from clothes , cd’s , dvd’s , books , and other essential items. The building is very unique and used to be a Meijer grocery store!”

3.4 Good40 Reviews

“Most Of The Staff Is Awesome! Store is always clean and organized and Prices are great! The Only Problem is If You Are 10 cent Or A quarter short They Will Not Give You A Break However, I'm Always rounding off My Total to Support And I Can't get Not One Break when it's no price or 10 cent short. Some states will Charge a different price for the same thing..”

3.2 Average21 Reviews

“We had a good experience shopping in the store. We found a shirt and a ball cap for our grandson. Like most thrift stores you have to search for the bargains. The employees were very friendly.”

2.8 Average19 Reviews