Thrift Stores near Reynoldsburg, OH

16 locations found near Reynoldsburg

“Small little thrift place, the prices are always amazing and some of my best finds are from here!!! the staff is really sweet. the hours are sort of weird but then again it is a volunteer based place so its understandable. Dressing room is available but its just curtains not doors, but for a place of this size its nice that it still has one! one of my favorite thrift spots :)”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“The ladies here just saved my life! Unfortunately I had to quickly sell a large portion of my COACH bag collection at the last minute for my dog’s eye treatment and other emergency bills. It couldn’t wait so I did what I had to do! I was shocked at their initial low offer but after talking with the manager (I cannot remember her name for the life of me, so sorry!) about the offer I had just received the day before from a different employee, she was able to work it out for me and I left with the amount I was expecting. I absolutely recommend this place if you’re in a serious crunch for money and need it fast. Otherwise, please know you will only get 1/3 of what the item is valued at so I would try selling on Depop or other platforms first.

Also, if you leave the store while they’re checking your items, you’re automatically agreeing to whatever they offer and I don’t believe you can get your items back if you decline. I had never heard of such a policy ever in my life, it’s very odd… but I just sit on the little bench and wait patiently. 😊

& They don’t have auto sliding doors or even PUSH to open doors even though people are coming in and out with baskets lol Lucky for me one of the ladies seen me coming in and held the door for me.

Thank you so much again ladies!”

4.1 Good201 Reviews

“We were told about Uptown Cheapskate while I was on my way to another consignment shop. We arrived and were greeted warmly and were impressed with the collection of clothes they had. They explained the selling process and quickly took or merchandise. I received a fair price for what I had to offer and was on my way quickly. I will absolutely take more clothes here for resale or heck. To trade in as they also had nice clothes and a great shoe collection”

4.6 Superb213 Reviews

“I do really like this location BUT I did remove 1 star simply because they don't have a public access bathroom. So take that into account if you have any condition that may require access to a bathroom and plan accordingly.”

4.2 Good122 Reviews

“Easy drop off and clearance is high enough for my enclosed trailer!
Some prices could be a little lower, but not bad if you need stuff!
Dropped off a lot of kids toys and housewares hopefully someone will get some use out of!”

4 Good111 Reviews

“Love this store been shopping there for 15 years always a pleasure an great sales an a very friendly staff the quality of the clothes are always in good condition.”

3.7 Good124 Reviews

“Nice thrift place. Very big selection and store is easy to navigate. the furniture is always beautiful and clothes are available as new. The staff keeps to themsleves. Good for little trinkets and shoes. Dressing rooms are available and have mirrors too!! Great for back to school aswell and basic necessities that are new such as curtains and bookbags and blankets!! overall nice place to stop by”

3.7 Good72 Reviews

“I love this place. You never know what you're going to find and the prices are awesome. Got a vintage Colman stove today for $3.99. wow!! I spend hours in here every time I come. Stop and check them out. You wont be sorry.

This place is the best way of finding whatever you are looking for and even stuff you never knew you wanted. Check them out. Always fast friendly service”

4 Good58 Reviews

“Large selection. Many new items also, some of which seem to be clearance items from Target. It’s not always clear if the prices on clearance items are better than what you would get at the original source.

Lots of jeans. Good amount of glassware. I found some used items to be out of the range I am willing to pay (like $9 for a vinyl music album set).some winter coats had decent prices, while others seemed quite high (like someone on the staff is pricing items by Googling what the “vintage resale” value would be, which seems to not be the true spirit of second hand stores.

With a visit nonetheless, as there are some good bargains to be had. There is a separate small room with some good items in the back, just before the restroom.”

3.7 Good106 Reviews

“I like the deals but I agree with the other review about the lady with flashy glasses. I think she’s a manager,,, not helpful and differs all work or help to other workers. I won’t even check out w her. I purposely go to other staff. Very superior attitude.”

3.4 Good105 Reviews

“I had a crazy lady run up and push stuff on me very aggressively and rude wouldn’t let me look at anything smooshed my hand multiple times was just a horrible person to have in the store acted like she owned it gave the store a weird feeling I told the manager I was upset and the lady was removed thank you for keeping the environment Friendly like goodwill always has been it should only be love. I’m disabled also which I should add which is why I was so upset she pushed me out the way my balance and hands don’t work as well. The manager handled it and made me feel a lot better and welcomed. To the manager you rock thank you so much”

3.4 Good100 Reviews

“I spent an hour here and left with 5 pieces! The store is nicely organized making it easy to sort through. Prices were fair and if you find items on sale, it’s a steal. The employee running the store was sweet and helpful.”

3.4 Good84 Reviews

“I've gone to the ReStore on Westerville Rd a couple times to look for random things that I need for my house. Like paint or a new door. You can pretty much find anything you need for your home. Including cleaning supplies. I also saw some automotive stuff but it wasn't much. They have some really great deals! Today I scored an aluminum ladder for $20. The lady at the cash register is super helpful and very nice. I love this place!”

3.3 Good116 Reviews

“Great spot to pick up some good quality 2nd hand clothes even some new still with the tags on them. I got some NIKE,ADIDAS, & North Face gear along with some shoes & a few other things. They charge by the pound not per item clothes+shoes/2.29$per pound kitchen items-1.99&per pound there’s more but I can’t remember it all”

3.2 Average162 Reviews

“Super wonderful employees, very helpful and hard workingSo much goes on behind the scenes we don’t even realize!Fantastic talent in the donations attendant, it gets so busy sometimes and they’re still able to help everyone quickly and make your experience good. Everyone there deserves a raise!! Yeah they can’t get raises there.”

3.1 Average127 Reviews

“Walked right in and was able to purchase two like new pairs of kids boots for under $10. My mom heart is so happy.

Both pairs were in great condition and just what each kiddo needed”

2.8 Average74 Reviews