Casey's in Broken Arrow, OK, located at 2400 E Albany St, offers a variety of convenient services including pizza delivery and pickup, groceries, household essentials, appetizers, sweet treats, and drinks. Known for its made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, the store provides tasty pizza options, though some reviews mention occasional undercooked crusts or errors in specialty pizzas, likely due to busy times and staff training. Customers appreciate the friendly, helpful staff who create a welcoming environment, often engaging in friendly conversations and offering assistance with carrying items. The store is noted for being clean and well-stocked, with great products and competitive prices. Additionally, Casey’s provides quality fuel, complemented by an impressive rewards program. However, some issues are raised regarding the gas pumps, which sometimes malfunction or are slow, especially during busy hours or cold weather, and the management has faced criticism for certain changes and handling of power outages. Despite these concerns, many customers express loyalty and fondness for the store, citing the friendly staff and overall positive atmosphere as key reasons for frequent visits. Overall, Casey’s in Broken Arrow is seen as a helpful, friendly, and convenient place to shop, dine, and fuel up.
