Tire Dealers in Lancaster, PA

24 locations found near Lancaster

“First time customer. Got 4 new tires for a reasonable price. We were in and out in 20 minutes. Friendly and honest service. We will definitely use them again. Thank you!”

4.8 Superb228 Reviews

“The experience was above and beyond what I expected. It was honest and up front with very solid pricing and professionalism all while being combined with a personal service that made me feel more like a friend than a customer.”

4.7 Superb138 Reviews

“Nate’s Auto exceeded my expectations—top-notch service and results. From the moment I scheduled the appointment to driving away, the team was friendly, transparent, and took the time to explain what needed to be done and why. my car now drives smoother !!They provided a fair, honest estimate with clear upfront communication and no surprise charges, and the turnaround was fast without sacrificing quality. I’ve found a trustworthy shop I’ll stick with and highly recommend Nate’s Auto to everyone.”

4.7 Superb106 Reviews

“I didn't walk away with exactly what I wanted, but the supervisor, Louis, stayed patient and was very accommodating and respectful so I thank them for that. Otherwise it was a good experience. Very good leadership, good team, thanks.”

4.7 Superb101 Reviews

“Traveling through the area on the way to a meeting and ran over a screw, which cause a slow leak. They got me right in, patched the tire, and got me back on the road within 30 minutes. Service was great and the employees were super friendly.”

4.5 Superb308 Reviews

“An incredible blessing to have a local mechanic that you can fully trust. I have had some pretty significant concerns with my vehicle over the years, and never once have I been taken advantage of, or my concerns minimized. Work is always done very well, as quickly as possible, and with great consideration for cost. And they always take the time to explain what’s going on. I feel as taken care of as if I were a family member. Ron, you are huge blessing to this community.”

4.7 Superb79 Reviews

“Really appreciate Raymond as a person and a mechanic. I have experienced him to be professional, accommodating, and most importantly honest. (He also remembered me after not speaking for almost 1 year- impressive.)”

4.8 Superb60 Reviews

“We got a flat tire while site seeing, and visiting Lancaster. There were torrential storms roads closed trees down, and somehow another. We could not find anyone to help us. Jack was absolutely amazing! He and his team helped me with not only figuring out that the tire was actually shot, but put the spare room for us wrapped up the old tire and really helped us out tremendously.”

4.5 Superb199 Reviews

“I thought I wrote a review before but it may have disappeared. This has been my shop of choice for the past 3 years. Not only are the prices reasonable but the mechanics and front desk guy know their stuff.

On many occasions they’ve helped me find reasonably priced tires in the area, worked with me on inspection requirements, changed my oil quickly, and most recently caught a “recall” on my transmission for the model of my car in which I was able to go to the dealership and get it replaced/fixed at no cost.

Good people, good shop, and will continue to go back. Keep up the great work you guys.”

4.5 Superb182 Reviews

“Excellent Service everytime! Honest, friendly and goes beyond expectations! Always tries to save you money. Reputable family business! Ask for Zack! You will be so glad to do business with Wissler's Service Cente!! 5 stars for sure!! 😃 👍👍”

4.8 Superb46 Reviews

“1st experience with JW tire..I'll be back. Adam was genuinely accommodating from explaining a tire purchase to helping avoid future problem with a maintenance issue.
Courteous and kept me informed during my wait. Well done.”

4.4 Superb283 Reviews

“Thank goodness for Kenny and the Mavis crew! Our car died a few blocks from this magical place (and at least 2 hours from our home) leaving us all out of sorts. Kenny got us a jump, walked us through our options, made a bunch of phone calls on our behalf (even though it was the end of a very long day) and got us sorted out and back on the road. All while being super helpful and an absolute mensch! The whole crew was fantastic and I literally can’t thank them enough!”

4.4 Superb227 Reviews

“Brought my wife’s car into the shop on a Sunday to get a leaky tired plugged and John got me in and out in 15 minutes. Absolutely remarkable. Thanks John!”

4.4 Superb196 Reviews

“Had a bad valve stem on my trailer.
Got me in got me out, and you wouldn't find a better price anywere...they actually didnt charge me so I gave the man a tip. Ill be stopping by again if I ever need anything. Thanks yal”

4.5 Superb54 Reviews

“This location was very responsive to our needs.
Rob even stayed late for our convenience.
It's easy to believe, Mr. Sheaffer will be the top salesman for this company in 2025.
Thank you, guys.”

4.5 Superb41 Reviews

“The guys working in the tire department are fantastic they earned the 5 stars! The problem is…they also have to work the front desk AND handle all propane sales and fill ups. This has them running all over the place dealing with way too much. Even with that, they still had my tires installed as quickly as they could.

Lancaster BJ’s should really look into hiring an additional person to handle the front desk and the propane, so these guys can do their actual jobs and install tires!”

4.3 Superb15 Reviews

“They helped me find white wall tires for my 67 chevy, service was great. A few minor follow up items that were addressed immediately. They are my new service center.”

4.2 Good126 Reviews

“I’ve had a fantastic experience with this location. Ordered tires, they called to schedule an appointment once they came in, and took about 1.5 hours on a busy Sunday to get in and out. Knowledgeable and friendly staff - and Costco stands by what they sell! It’s a no-brainer to get the tires here if they’re available. 2nd one I’ve gotten at Costco. My only gripe is I wish they had wheel-alignment service as well!”

3.3 Good36 Reviews

“First and foremost this place should get more then 5 stars. beides their excellent service, they come through when you need them. For example, today my girlfriend locked her keys in her the car. she walked up to McCoy Automotive. She told them what happened and no questions asked, A worker name Colin jumped, took my down to my car and got my car unlock no question, no problem and did it and real good time in like ten minutes. I recommend this place to anybody!!!!”

3.8 Good125 Reviews

“I would like to recognize Anthony, Service Mgr, and Arlo, Technician, at Plaza Blvd Lancaster PA location. We had a nail in the sidewall of a rental car tire, 9 hours from home. Both guys were so helpful and accommodating to us. They even stayed beyond closing time to take care of us! We cannot thank them enough for their care.”

3.8 Good210 Reviews

“Service was timely and thorough. I received courteous service from Nick R. and Lance F. They were patient with all my questions and explained the types of service my car required and services that were recommended. I will be using their services in the future!”

3.6 Good165 Reviews

“I got an appointment sooner than I expected. The work was completed faster than I expected. Everyone was pleasant and informative. They accommodated my desire not to leave the car for the day. This location is downtown so there are plenty of places within walking distance to pass the time.
On 7-31-2026, I got my state inspection done. Amy went above and beyond. Although I was late for the appointment, she and Shawn managed to get my car back to me a half hour earlier than I expected.”

3.4 Good154 Reviews

“A big thank you to the young man in the garage who helped out a dame in distress and filled my leaky tire with air. I didnt have an appointment, but just drove up and asked if he coukd help me.
He graciously filled my tire and pointed out the nail that needed to be taken care of.
He reassured me that it will be fine until I get home and it was. Thank you for saving my day!”

3.4 Good335 Reviews