Mayfly Market and Deli is a charming business located near Randyland, offering a unique blend of high-quality grocery items, delicious deli sandwiches, and delightful gifts. Customers appreciate the fresh and healthy food options, including prepared salads, sides, and soups. The deli's sandwiches, particularly the roast beef on artisan bread, are noted as superb and worth the wait. The market features an impressive selection of items, including local specialties, cheeses, snacks, and even Leona's Ice Cream Sandwiches. The space is beautifully decorated with original art and fresh flowers, creating a welcoming atmosphere that customers love. While some visitors mention a slight confusion about the menu and ordering process, the friendly staff and the overall experience make up for it. Many locals frequent Mayfly, signifying its popularity as a hidden gem in the Northside. With offerings like seasonal sorbets and coffee to go, Mayfly Market and Deli serves as a must-visit spot for anyone in the neighborhood looking for good food and a pleasant experience.
The breakfast sandwiches are amazing and the service is always excellent.
December 2025
Such a great spot. Their breakfast sandwich is so good. Lots of groceries and a really curated selection of local products/gifts. Mediterra bread in stock and a surprisingly nice selection of cheeses.
August 2025
I loved it! Such a great great great shop. Sorbet was so good. Italian sandwich was to die for! So glad I found this gem!
