AJ Collectables is the Midwest’s premiere location for new and vintage sports cards, memorabilia, jerseys, bobbleheads, and more. Customers consistently praise the shop for its honest and courteous staff, particularly highlighting the helpfulness of employees like John, Mike, and J.W. They provide valuable advice and education for both seasoned collectors and newcomers, making the shopping experience enjoyable. Many visitors appreciate the variety of supplies available and the engaging atmosphere, especially for children, with affordable options like $1 boxes that keep kids entertained. Overall, AJ Collectables is recognized as the go-to destination for sports card enthusiasts and collectors, offering great deals and exceptional service.
The best card store in Wisconsin! Chris is the man!
September 2026
Aj’s is my favorite card shop in the area! I’ve been to others in the area (I live in Sheboygan so I have to travel) but nothing compares to the chill and lowkey atmosphere of Aj’s!
August 2026
Went in there for the first time on Monday at the guy running the shop was super nice and welcoming to answer questions. There is plenty of cards and stick to go through. I could spend hours there. I enjoyed my experience and will definitely be back!
