Thrift Stores near Menomonee Falls, WI

15 locations found near Menomonee Falls

“Not very organized. Prices are OK. It wouldn't take to straighten the merchandise on the shelves and keep it that way. And then make employees keep it that way”

2.8 Average107 Reviews

“great store , always find something there at a great price !! and today they had a pop up food bank! ( Tuesday and Friday 1:00) they gave out alot of great food including frozen pizzas thank you Super Thrift you all are a true blessing !!”

4.6 Superb53 Reviews

“Stopped in randomly and was warmly greeted with smiles! Staff was very helpful and kind. Got this beautiful antique for a very fair price. Really cool little spot, will definitely be back!”

4.9 Superb18 Reviews

“This is my favorite spot in the neighborhood! I’ve found some of my favorite shoes here for 3 DOLLARS. And the ladies and the atmosphere are just lovely. ❤️??”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“I almost don’t want to leave a review because I want to keep this gem a secret. I always find so many things for such good prices. The ladies that work here are super kind and generous as well.”

4.9 Superb50 Reviews

“Love this store! Whether I'm looking for something for the kitchen, or looking for a piece of furniture to refurb (and almost everything in-between) this place has quite a variety to choose from. I only wish I could shop here daily just to see all the new stuff on the floor each day*Photo included is standing in front of the store, looking over the freeway. It was a beautiful cloud display so I just happened to grab a moment*”

4.3 Superb79 Reviews

“This thrift store is a fave of mine when shopping around for little trinkets. They have a surprisingly large selection of handkerchiefs which you really just don't see much of anymore. The items that are considered vintage are in a separate section and although they are priced a little higher do sometimes go down based on whatever deals may be going on that day/week. I stumbled upon it when driving by one day but have made it a point to stop in if I'm in the area, would definitely recommend checking them out if you're on the hunt for bits and bobbles!”

4.5 Superb42 Reviews

“Lots of stuff here, some of the prices are a bit much but they do have cheaper stuff too I'd say most things are priced fairly. The old man who tested the ceiling lamp is very nice”

3.9 Good117 Reviews

“Wild experience but fun and helpful. It's a bunch of larges bin that you literally dig through to find items, then pay by the pound! ? Wild but works! Big clothing piles on tables as well.”

3.8 Good20 Reviews

“I love this location and can’t stop recommending them to everyone I know. I had a baby in September and almost every clothing item has come from this store. It’s nice to know that I am not contributing to the dumps of clothes that are being forever thrown away, instead contributing to a recycle reuse system for a fraction of the cost of brand new, especially when the clothes are in such great condition they are practically brand new. I had an issue with a swing that I purchased from here, the store was very understanding and replaced it with the same exact model they had in their store. The store is always clean and well kept. I really can’t say enough about how amazing it is.”

3.8 Good164 Reviews

“Under new management!! The shop continues to offer new and like-new items at very reasonable prices, with hidden gems galore. They are very selective for the merchandise offered; no dirty, broken, junky things. Wonderful, helpful volunteers. Many shoppers come weekly! There's lots to discover!”

3.6 Good55 Reviews

“Prices are usually reasonable. Selection is above average. Store is clean and organized. Needs more cashiers at the register, though - I spent as much time shopping as I did waiting at checkout (10-15 min).”

3.6 Good101 Reviews

“Overall good selection, clean and organized. However, prices have been climbing quite a bit, and checkout tends to take longer than at other Goodwill stores in the area. Four cashiers were open as I approached the checkout today, then suddenly three of them closed down. Nobody seemed interested in taking my money, so I left the merchandise on the counter and went somewhere else to shop. Will try back again another time, and hopefully there will be cashiers available.”

3.6 Good114 Reviews

“First of all the people they have working there are very very nice and efficient and friendly. There are great finds in all areas. However, sometimes things get so crowded and piled up that it gets a little dangerous to rummage through the shelf stacks. Just my opinion that if they priced things more reasonably, there wouldn't be such an excess of stuff. They could be pickier about putting broken items on the shelves.”

3.3 Good96 Reviews

“Rows and rows of bins and bins of stuff!! I saw lots of people wearing gloves sifting through the items in the bins. They don’t come here unprepared!

Pricing is by weight. Feels like a treasure hunt.

They do NOT take donations at this location.”

2.9 Average60 Reviews