Thrift Stores near Middleton, WI

22 locations found near Middleton

“The store was well stocked with above average merchandise at reasonable prices. The jigsaw puzzle selection was excellent. We also picked up plates and some clothing. I would definitely shop here again.”

3.1 Average111 Reviews

“I would call it the most unique upscale resale store in Madison! Conveniently located on State Street with luxury brands in mint condition and excellent selections of one of a kind items. Friendly and helpful staff. You must stop in and see for yourself!!”

4.7 Superb139 Reviews

“What a sweet little surprise! Out here in Wisconsin for a volleyball tournament, and stumbled across this store. Good quality clothes, not for teeny boppers, and lots of cute household items arranged very tastefully. Prices reasonable as well! Great place to stop !”

4.8 Superb106 Reviews

“I was surprised by the large amount of pet supplies they have. Shop here first for unusual pet needs like steps to get up to higher surfaces, a cooling mat, cat tree, gates, dog life vest, and snow booties in various sizes. Also a wide selection of daily need stuff like feeding bowls, harnesses, transporting cases and portable kennels. No need to spend full price when good quality used items are available for a low price. The store is clean, organized, and friendly helpful staff.”

4.6 Superb58 Reviews

“Very kind staff and great prices. I bought a desk with a sliddable keyboard and mousepad drawer for $10 and saved so much money speakers and stereo units and some of them are not cheap online. Could have more parking but other than that, it's the best thrift store I've been going to.”

4.4 Superb110 Reviews

“Cute little thrift store. There is a rack with items that are individually priced but the majority of the items in the store are $5 each. Goodies, pants, t-shirts, shorts, leggings and more for only $5 each 🤯 You can also fill up a bag for $20 (if you bring in donations) or $30 if you don't bring anything in.

There is also a FREE bin located right outside the store where you can grab some items for FREE. I got a couple shirts and a mug for ABSOLUTELY NOTHING.”

4.6 Superb46 Reviews

“You can find some great deals on used office furniture. Items must be purchased beforehand through the online auction site which includes some buy it now items.”

4.8 Superb12 Reviews

“The workers are very friendly, and Laura is the BEST!
She makes me want to donate more stuff just so I can interact with her.
Good job, Team Goodwill!”

4.3 Superb49 Reviews

“Love the Wauakee store. Always clean and organized. Items are always changing. I buy something everytime I go. Prices are always very reasonable. Also, love that you can donate items 7 days a week during open hours. They make it so easy to donate by letting you drive right up and then they help you unload your items. Did i mention how much i love this store!!”

4.3 Superb72 Reviews

“this shop has lots of great artwork and stickers! The shopkeeper was so sweet and fun to chat with. Visiting from out of town, will definitely be back! The whole neighborhood has good vibes!”

4.3 Superb47 Reviews

“Lovely items! I am not sure it is a typical thrift store most of the items were boutique stuff, so there were a lot of supplies of similar items. Reminds me more of Charlotte Russe in the clothing options. Great location and price for items were reasonable. Be sure to check out their bulletin board too, lots of resources and information about local activities and events.”

4.2 Good113 Reviews

“Really good people and really great stuff. The store itself holds mostly the smaller items and is beautifully curated. Larger furniture is at the warehouse, but you can follow on Instagram or talk to the owner/employees about events or pieces you are interested in. That's how we got our working Grundig! Quality and uniqueness is prioritized, and everyone here is incredibly knowledgeable and passionate about the art, storytelling, and craftsmanship of decor.”

4.2 Good31 Reviews

“Bargains for quality items. Notice some clothes have Northern Illinois area references. Also, Sean at front counter always greets everyone and makes people welcome.”

4.1 Good21 Reviews

“This is a nice thrift store with upscale furniture for resale. Otherwise, they also carry the typical thrift store type items at very good prices. This is one of my favorite places to shop!”

4.1 Good61 Reviews

“It's a run down building but they did help me even though I had an attitude about being there. They managed to settle me down. Let me keep my medical equipment on my bed. Room mates were excellent!!! I again have to go back so I hope they welcome me again”

3.7 Good49 Reviews

“Awesome place! This is my new favorite place. Clothing, blankets, all fabrics by the pound. $1.50 a pound. Great prices on ither items. Got a huge crockpot for 3 bucks!”

3.9 Good90 Reviews

“Returning to Madison means that I get to visit this Goodwill spot again! The shop was very clean and organized, which sometimes is tough for thrift shops to do. Our cashier was super friendly and there was a speedy checkout process. She offered to wrap things up that were glass and wished us a great day.The selection here is usually great for housewares and clothing -- my two biggest categories! I find great glass pieces and usually a vintage looking item or two will be on the shelves. This is a smaller Goodwill and the parking lot is a bit tight, but they are my favorite location and I'll always drop by.Also their donation center is a quick and easy drive through -- love that!”

3.9 Good103 Reviews

“This place has filled out nicely since opening! Great stock, all the time. Their selection changes often, so if you see something you need to think about, think quick because it likely won’t be there on your next visit. Their prices are a bit steep for having received the items from free. Some items absolutely outrageous and I can’t figure out how they justify the high price tags. But still a fun place to walk through, you never know what you will find.”

3.9 Good92 Reviews

“Well it was our family's lucky day. My very tall husband found some very nice items that fit him. I have also been lucky getting good quality shirts when I've come here. A better selection than most.”

3.8 Good86 Reviews

“Actually half the Goodwill store is a tax preparation place that's what I went there to do people are very very nice and the clean the table after you leave for the next customer”

3.7 Good76 Reviews

“Oh, let me share the ways I love this thrift shop! It's my favorite in all of the greater Madison area. (Light years better than all the Goodwills!) It's very well organized. They don't sell broken, crappy junk. Their prices are super reasonable -- better than Goodwill.The people working here seem artistic and creative and committed to creating a great shopping experience for guests. They are always helpful and polite. They display stuff very well. The store is organized intuitively and items are easy to look through and displayed neatly. I always find great stuff here; it is worth a drive across town once a month for an enjoyable excursion searching for treasures. Highly recommended!”

3.4 Good104 Reviews

“Perhaps it's because it's near to Epic, perhaps because Verona is a charming small town, perhaps I'm just lucky, but I always find great clothes here, many from good companies like l.l.bean, Gap, etc. and pretty jewelry. People donate good things here!”

3 Average82 Reviews