Buffalo Exchange is a popular thrift and resale shop that offers a unique selection of retro and fashionable used items. Customers appreciate the friendly and kind staff who are always welcoming and helpful, whether they are shopping or selling clothes. The selling process is described as easy, with staff members acknowledging items and offering fair prices, often purchasing around 70% of what is brought in. Many find great deals on brands like Sandro, Ted Baker London, and Anthropologie, discovering one-of-a-kind pieces at good prices. The shop is known for its decent selection, especially for those interested in retro items, though some find prices a bit higher than local thrift stores. Finding plus-size items can be more challenging, which is common in retro shops. Customers also mention the shop’s consistent friendly greeting and positive atmosphere. However, there are some concerns, particularly about the dressing rooms, where curtains are sometimes pulled open unexpectedly, causing embarrassment. Customers suggest that the store could improve privacy by installing doors or hooks on the curtains. Overall, Buffalo Exchange is a place where many return regularly to find unique, fashionable items and enjoy a friendly shopping environment, despite minor issues like dress room privacy.
Excellent for selling clothes. The Manager is very personable and helpful.
May 2026
Great spot! Good variety, upbeat employees, fun atmosphere. Definitely recommend.
May 2026
First time here after hearing glowing reviews and was not disappointed! Lots of good selection and well organized. Good mix of unique items and classic builders.
