Buffalo Exchange is a hit or miss thrift store known for its good and trendy stuff. It offers cheaper clothes that are in amazing condition, providing great items at a fraction of the usual price. The vibe is consistently great, with sweet staff and fun interactions between customers. It is a no bull kinda place that many love. The shopping experience can be outstanding, with passionate and talented staff offering helpful recommendations and creating thoughtful outfit options. The store has a surprising number of plus-sized options, allowing friends of all sizes to thrift together. However, selling items can be inconsistent. They are selective, often accepting all clothes except certain pieces, while sometimes turning down high-end clothing for more common brands. Pricing and buy rates can also fluctuate, with some noting increased prices and low compensation for valuable items. While management is great, some find the younger employees less knowledgeable. Overall, it is a highly recommended spot for a good day thrifting.
Had a great visit and found some really great clothing and shoes! Special shout out to Gigi for their amazing service and knowledge!
July 2026
Love going there but it's always so hot in there I can never stay long.
June 2026
This store has such a fun vibe, and the staff all made me feel very welcome. They have a variety of styles, a little something for everyone. I found a great high-quality brand tunic and some cute accessories. Thanks for a nice experience on my shopping day!
