Tire Dealers in Castro Valley, CA

“After getting a flat tire the night before, I searched online for a nearby tire shop. Castro Valley Tire Pros immediately stood out because it had a 4.9-star rating from more than 2,000 reviews. I felt compelled to give the shop a try—and now I understand why it is so highly rated.

Francisco examined the tire and showed me the nail and crack that made it impossible to repair. When I told him I simply needed something durable, he did not try to upsell me. He inspected my other three tires, said they were still fairly new and in good condition, and assured me that I only needed to replace one. He even suggested checking with my previous tire shop to see whether the damaged tire was still under warranty. His honesty truly stood out to me.

The total was only $159.78, including the tire, computerized wheel balancing, disposal fee, labor, and sales tax. Francisco also noticed that I was missing a hubcap. He suggested buying an affordable set of four from the nearby O’Reilly Auto Parts and offered to install them for free.

No one at the shop asked me to write this review—I simply could not help myself! Honest service, fair pricing, and genuine kindness like this deserve to be recognized. I highly recommend Castro Valley Tire Pros. Thank you, Francisco and the entire team!”

“I've been coming here for years for my vehicles. The staff is very helpful and I appreciate the list of items that were repaired, items that will eventually need attention and items that need to be fixed ASAP.

I never had any issues after getting my services there. They've always have done a good job.”

“These are the best, most honest, reliable, plain spoken, kind mechanics in the Bay area. We have taken all our vehicles to them over the last 30+ years. They will give an honest clear assessment of what needs to happen to your car and when, every time. They will also give you a very realistic estimate of when it will be done and help you to keep the most accurate and up to date records of your vehicle. They are a tremendous service in our community and we are lucky to have them nearby.”

“Needed all new tires on my bmw after an Oakland pothole blew out 2 year old tires. This is a family run business with decades of racing experience. Brandon knew his stuff inside out and treated me and my car like they were his. It's by appointment, super easy and available. Love my new tires, Brandon's recommendation that he uses on his M car. Reasonable price too. Liam is awesome too, and enjoyed chatting with Roger. Sorry if this sounds like a love-fest post but it's just so refreshing not to deal with a corporate run business and talk to real experienced people.”

“First time being there today, it was an emergency. I had a fantastic experience at this car repair shop. I needed a new tire, and they went above and beyond to assist me in finding the perfect replacement. Ultimately, I decided to have them switch out my damaged tire with the spare, and they patiently guided me through the process, demonstrating each step. Their helpfulness and willingness to empower older and young customers such as myself with DIY solutions really stood out to me. Not only were they respectful of all vehicles, but they also created a welcoming atmosphere for both regulars and newcomers as well. I highly recommend this shop for their exceptional service and their pro consumer approach.”

“Larry’s Automotive is a an exemplary automotive service repair shop. Their honesty and integrity are noteworthy.

Our 2025 Subaru had a reminder to get the oil and filter changed even though we were 3,000 miles short of meeting the milage requirement. Subaru recommends getting the service done every 6 months or 6,000 miles which ever comes first.

After dropping our car off at Larry’s, he called and said the car did not need service. He advised getting serviced when the mileage was closer to Subaru’s milage requirement.

How many other dealers would have gone ahead and performed the service?”

“Very friendly and knowledgeable people. Offered the best price on a set of tires. I left the car there while I went to work (wife drove), but coming home traffic was bad and I was running late. I called the shop and asked if I could come in the morning but the gentleman offered to stay after closing so I could get my car that night. This is the kind of service and commitment that is hard to find these days.”