Buffalo Exchange is a popular secondhand clothing store that offers a unique shopping experience. Customers have had a range of experiences at this location, with some praising the helpful and friendly staff, while others have encountered more reserved employees who may not have been as accommodating. The store's inventory can be hit or miss, with customers sometimes finding impressive hauls of high-quality items, while other times leaving empty-handed. This is understandable given the nature of a secondhand store, where the selection is constantly changing. Overall, Buffalo Exchange is described as a "gem of a thrift store" with a large selection and good prices. Customers appreciate the opportunity to discover unique and vintage pieces, even if it requires some patience and digging. While the staff may not always be equally attentive, the store is generally regarded as a pleasant and rewarding shopping destination, especially for those who enjoy the thrill of the hunt.
Everyone was so kind and helpful, a beautiful and clean store with the best selection I've seen at a BE. great experience!
March 2026
I want to like this place but the racks are so shoved full that I literally can’t browse clothes easily. You have to muscle the clothes apart to see them on the racks. Every time I go in it’s frustrating and I leave.
January 2026
This place has gone downhill, you’d think they would take a look at the labels before accepting clothing. They sell so much SHEIN and fast fashion garbage brands as a “vintage store”. They should think about quality over quantity. Cleaner selection of quality clothes.
