Silver In the City is a charming gift store with locations on Mass Ave in Downtown Indianapolis and Main Street in Downtown Carmel. Established in 2000 and 2015 respectively, it offers a wide selection of sterling silver jewelry, including pieces with semiprecious and raw gemstones. The store is known for its unique and quirky designs, making it a favorite spot for shoppers seeking fun gifts, jewelry, housewares, and collectibles. Visitors often find it a perfect place to buy gifts for others or treats for themselves, with friendly and helpful staff ensuring a pleasant shopping experience. The store features a variety of items such as stickers, trinkets, T-shirts, books, and home decor, making it a versatile destination for all. While prices can vary, the store remains a go-to spot for those looking for fun, distinctive, and locally made products. Overall, Silver In the City is a fun, friendly shop with a wide range of unique items that appeal to many.
I never miss a chance to visit when I’m in the area. I absolutely love this store! jewelry that lasts, adorable trinkets, and the funniest/relatable stickers for my junk journal :))
December 2025
An Indianapolis staple! A go-to for thoughtful and sometimes quirky gifts, often sourced from local businesses.
November 2025
Always love this shop. Cute items for gifts for friends, family, special ones in your life.
