Casey's at 2004 Morthland Dr in Valparaiso is a large gas station with many pumps, so you don't have to wait. It is a nice, safe, clean, and easily accessible place to stop. The store is super clean and the bathrooms are excellent. Customers report the customer service is amazing and the hospitality is wonderful, making them feel like they mattered. The store always has items in stock. It features the best pizza delivery and pickup, with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and the freshest toppings. Their food is oddly good for fast food, with great breakfast pizza. They also offer appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. The smores coffee and new coffee machine are awesome, offering espresso-like coffee with a crema. While prices can sometimes be a little higher than surrounding gas stations, it is a clean environment where you can also fill up your tank with quality fuels. Whatever you need, Casey's is here to help.
I started coming to this Casey's as I own a small biz nearby and the gas is always cheaper (on my Upside app!). I keep going back, not just for reasonable gas but because the staff is always SO nice to me. The ice cream is amazing, too! 😁
August 2025
Wish I would have known pickles come on the brisket sliders, never would have grabbed them. Doesn't say anywhere on packaging that they have pickles and i can't stand pickles. Even after I picked off pickles flavor was soaked in, ended up throwing them away.
August 2025
Absolutely LOVE their pizza. Everyone at this store is super friendly and helpful.
